Gamepro seems to be putting together a respectable stable of talent over there while 1Up becomes even less relevant. Frankly, once Garnett Lee left I stopped giving even half a shit about 1Up.
Not so sure about the EGM part. Seems like their EIC has changed once every two months since it came back, and I can't imagine that EGMi is getting all that much traffic.
Also, Gamepro has been pretty disappointing the latest couple of issues. It was awesome for the few months Davison was in charge, and 1-2 months after he left, but now we're stuck with embarrassing exploitative covers like this, as if Davison was never there in the first place:
1UP needs another 1UP à la Cifaldi and we're Yuji Bro-riis again, no matter how many galleries stretching 40 something pages (thanks to SEGA and Intel) and top whatever lists have come between us.