• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Best and Biggest Harvest Moon without junk ?

Perkel

Banned
I want to play some Harvest Moon
I had wonderfull time with FoMT on GBA it was like addiction and it is still junkless with crazy good pacing and gameplay.

What is the biggest HM in therms of content ?
What is the best HM in therms of gameplay ?

Heard many good opinions about GCN version of Magical Melody from YT art style is amazing but i fear all those animations take to long to be good in gameplay.

Opinions ?
 
Magical Melody and the new one for 3DS seem to fit this, though I haven't paid too much attention to it.

MM does feel really sluggish at first, but once you get into it, the pacing starts feeling pretty natural.
 
Wasn't Friends of Mineral Town for GBA upgraded version incuding more content of PSX version ? Someone can explain ?

Some people like awkward isometric cameras and strange inverted controls. FoMT is a better game than Back to Nature and HM64.
 
Haven't played it myself, but I've heard from fans of the series that A New Beginning on 3DS is the best Harvest Moon in ages.
 
Land of Beginnings, the latest for 3DS, is my favourite game in the entire series so far.

I've not played it in weeks due to other games getting in the way, but I've played it around 150 hours so far and will continue once I fully complete Bravely Default.

Doesn't help you looking for a game to play now, but keep your eye out for it when it releases in your region.
 
Just started A New Beginning.

It is beautiful and looks like it will have a ton of content. Love the music, love the layout, but something is off. I don't have the pull to play it, even after two hours.

I still prefer Friends of Mineral Town. That game is pure crack. Something awesome about being given a huge crappy field and in two years of hard work, turn it into a sprite-labor farm entirely covered in sweet potatoes.

In terms of console versions. Most people say that A Wonderful Life on the Gamecube is the best version. It is like $5 so it isn't hard to get (unlike the SNES and N64 versions).
 
My personal favorite is still the first on SNES.

Seriously, its like subsequent titles only did bring more linearity or non-important features or extra stuff to do that we don't necessarily care.
 
1015714444-00.jpg


Still my favorite. I wish Natsume went back to that same art-style.
 
Land of Beginnings, the latest for 3DS, is my favourite game in the entire series so far.

I've not played it in weeks due to other games getting in the way, but I've played it around 150 hours so far and will continue once I fully complete Bravely Default.

Doesn't help you looking for a game to play now, but keep your eye out for it when it releases in your region.

Land of Beginnings came out in the US last week, but its called A New Beginning here. I think its the first time Natsume has actually localized a HM game the same year it came out in Japan.

European release is TBA, though.
 
Land of Beginnings came out in the US last week, but its called A New Beginning here. I think its the first time Natsume has actually localized a HM game the same year it came out in Japan.

European release is TBA, though.

I wondered from a few posts, but I didn't bother checking; very surprising though.

Parallacs, the first month is slow, but once you can get more people moving in it really picks up.
 
Just started A New Beginning.

It is beautiful and looks like it will have a ton of content. Love the music, love the layout, but something is off. I don't have the pull to play it, even after two hours.

I still prefer Friends of Mineral Town. That game is pure crack. Something awesome about being given a huge crappy field and in two years of hard work, turn it into a sprite-labor farm entirely covered in sweet potatoes.

In terms of console versions. Most people say that A Wonderful Life on the Gamecube is the best version. It is like $5 so it isn't hard to get (unlike the SNES and N64 versions).

As i said earlier FoMT is junk less and super polished things like choping woods and working with hoe has perfect animations (meaning they don't drag) and player is rather quick in everything. I did play a little Ps2 version of HM but it was pure junk all over the place from very small FOV to things taking forever to do (long animations).

Magical Melody looks really good to me. That art style is very very good. Any info about content meaning it is bigger (in therms of content) than FotMT ?
 
What about Harvest Moon DS ? I tried to find some helpfull reviews but most of them focused why it isn't 3D version and why it won't use more stylus rather than anything about gameplay or content.

Looks like FoMT to me with other screen.
 
Magical Melody is easily the biggest HM game. It's hurt a bit by its bigness because few characters have more than one maybe two lines per friendship level/season.

A New Beginning though is fantastic.


What about Harvest Moon DS ? I tried to find some helpfull reviews but most of them focused why it isn't 3D version and why it won't use more stylus rather than anything about gameplay or content.

Looks like FoMT to me with other screen.

It's a lot like FoMT with some weird changes and slight mechanic changes to make it a bit more complicated. Touch Screen controls are largely inoffensive unlike the first of the island games. It's notoriously buggy though.
 
I got Boy and Girl on PSN for my Vita and absolutely HATE the isometric controls. I've never really played these games but due to my guilty pleasure with freemium games on my phone I figured I'd try one out, and I apparently started off with the wrong one. Would the other Vita-compatible one on PSN any better for me?
 
Magical Melody is easily the biggest HM game. It's hurt a bit by its bigness because few characters have more than one maybe two lines per friendship level/season.

A New Beginning though is fantastic.




It's a lot like FoMT with some weird changes and slight mechanic changes to make it a bit more complicated. Touch Screen controls are largely inoffensive unlike the first of the island games. It's notoriously buggy though.

A lot like is rather good review in my opinion considering FoMT was pure crack. It is as good as FoMT or worse or better. How is content (bigger?)
 
Even more content. Part of the reason why people seem to prefer HM 64 to the BtN>FoMT games is that some people feel that the games after 64 just get too complicated, making them overwhelming. This pattern basically ends with MM and HM DS, which are still the leaders in content so far as the series goes.
 
I got Boy and Girl on PSN for my Vita and absolutely HATE the isometric controls. I've never really played these games but due to my guilty pleasure with freemium games on my phone I figured I'd try one out, and I apparently started off with the wrong one. Would the other Vita-compatible one on PSN any better for me?

I personally liked Innocent Life, but it's not that popular. It didn't have the marriage system, the festivals were a little weird, and it was more focused on a silly story. The farming is pretty much identical to FoMT, which is a good thing.
 
I personally liked Innocent Life, but it's not that popular. It didn't have the marriage system, the festivals were a little weird, and it was more focused on a silly story. The farming is pretty much identical to FoMT, which is a good thing.

So is Innocent Life recommended, everyone? Anyone?
 
So is Innocent Life recommended, everyone? Anyone?

It's all right. Just all right. I wouldn't recommend it. That no-relationship system is extremely off-putting to me as that's always been a staple of Harvest Moon games, and it felt more like a gimmick game then I'd like to admit.

I thought Rune Factory was millions of times better as a Harvest Moon spinoff.
 
I'm still waiting for my copy to arrive, but WiiredShawn gave a pretty good impression of A New Beginning which I thought was the definition of "less junk".

Here's some examples of streamlined actions:

Your character actually runs rather than "lightly jogs" like in Animal Parade, which means you move around faster; plus, you can buy a horse or construct a vehicle (albeit later in the game) to move around even faster. Also, with the power to jump, you're no longer bound to going around fences; just jump over them.

In Animal Parade (and I presume ToT, though I never played it), when you upgraded your farming tools, you would hold the A button to "charge" them. You would have to hold for a certain number of seconds in order for the charge to reach its maximum size. In ANB, the charge happens in less than a second and it expands from one square to its maximum number of squares immediately. So farming takes overall less time, especially when you upgrade your tools. The same goes for chopping down trees: it only takes one swing and you're done, compared to the multiple swings of Animal Parade. At some point in the main story, you receive access to "tiered farmland," which is a massive space where you can plant lots of crops and then have the local spring water everything for you immediately. It's a beautiful sight.

Mining is completely overhauled to be more convenient. You simply have a large room with three mining 'spots' that you hit with your hammer, along with any randomized goodies laying on the ground. As you upgrade your hammer, you'll get access to more of the spots, and each time you hit the spot, you'll receive an item. Compare this to Animal Parade, in which you you were never certain if anything valuable would come out of a rock (and sometimes you received something annoying like poison gas) and even when you found ore, the "refining" process might give you crap in return. In ANB, there's none of this guesswork: you don't have to refine ore, you simply get the gem or material that comes out of the mining spot. And if you don't like what you receive, you can simply reload your save at that point and try again (thanks to the fast loading).

Lastly, town customization means that you can eliminate unnecessary running. In Animal Parade, you had to run all the way across town if you wanted to buy things or talk to people. Here, you can move your preferred people just outside your farm, within a few seconds of walking. Combined with the map on the lower screen that tells you everyone's current location, it's easier to reach people and thus build friendships - and it's generally easier to build friendships because the faster farming and plentiful natural materials gives you quicker access to gifts.

Those are some of the more important changes, I feel. Overall, my fiancee is enjoying the game a lot, and she's played quite a few Harvest Moon games before. If you have a GameStop nearby, you might consider picking up a used copy and seeing how you like it before committing yourself.
 
My personal favorite is still the first on SNES.

Seriously, its like subsequent titles only did bring more linearity or non-important features or extra stuff to do that we don't necessarily care.

Absolutely. OG Harvest Moon is best Harvest Moon. I played the living crap out of it and haven't been into any revision since.
 
Magical Melody was the last one that was magical to me. . .It's the last one that's been able to expand and try new things but still managed to captivate me without over complication and whatnot.
 
For Magical Melody, which version is better


GameCube or Wii?

Gamecube is the better version because Wii version's bad controls and the lack of being able to be a girl.

But those don't affect me, so I prefer the Wii one solely because I'll be able to play it on my Wii U! And Wii boxes look cooler.
 
The Wii ones were pretty good. Tree of Tranquility or Animal Parade. I liked that they had both male and female options.

Try the Rune Factory spin-offs if you want more RPG like elements and battling.
 
I'm really enjoying A New Beginning on 3DS, and FoMT was the last one I played.
I was in the same boat, but I just sold A New Beginning. It really lacks the charm of (More) Friends of Mineral Town, and I suspect that's due in large part to the fact that the town is entirely customizable. The town in FoMT felt like an actual place and I really enjoyed following the different characters throughout their day; A New Beginning just feels lifeless in comparison. I'd definitely be interested in a Vita Harvest Moon game that looks visually similar to Magical Melody, but for now, I think I'm just going to conclude that this is a series that was best in 2D.
 
In order of the ones nearest and dearest to my heart:

1. HM64
2. SNES
3. FoMT
4. The rest of them suck (I've played all of them and most are just horrible compared to 1-3)

Jury's still out on New Beginning. I like it so far.
 
I was in the same boat, but I just sold A New Beginning. It really lacks the charm of (More) Friends of Mineral Town, and I suspect that's due in large part to the fact that the town is entirely customizable. The town in FoMT felt like an actual place and I really enjoyed following the different characters throughout their day; A New Beginning just feels lifeless in comparison. I'd definitely be interested in a Vita Harvest Moon game that looks visually similar to Magical Melody, but for now, I think I'm just going to conclude that this is a series that was best in 2D.

Friends of Mineral Town was just a remake of Back to Nature. And I like the isometric view in Harvest Moon a whole lot more than the straight on views. And the pseudo 3D models in Back to Nature are so much more charming. And dat music is ruined by GBA.
 
I looooove FoMT, I could never get into N64/PSX one...

The best harvest moons imo though are the Rune Factory games. At least the original DS and the first Wii one. Tides of Destiny was pretty miss for me, but that's because they decided to take the harvest moon out of it...
 
1. HM64
2. HM:BTN
3. SNES
4. HM: AWL



I'm looking for new games to curb my needs, so I am going to try to find Harvest Moon Magical Melody for GameCube and Harvest Moon 3DS.
 
Get the fuck out of here with that Harvest Moon shit. You're a grown ass man! It's time for you to get a taste of this fucking shit right here:

rune-cover.jpg


Now listen up, cause here comes some real talk for your ass!

In Rune Factory 3, not only can you farm and do everything you can do in a Harvest Moon game, you can do it BETTER and HARDER.

Rune Factory 3 has 9, count em' 9, kawaii bitches for you to romance, date, do quests for, marry, and fight monsters with. This is more moe than Harvest Moon could ever handle. Wait monsters?

That's right bitch. In Rune Factory 3 you can fight monsters. Also, there aren't any farm animals in this game mother fucker. You have to TAME. SOME. FUCKING. MONSTERS. And they work on your farm! You can even ride them! Did Harvest Moon ever let you ride an ogre through town? It's no wonder every lady in town wants your nuts when you come rolling up on the back of a fucking Minotaur.

This isn't your old man's Harvest Moon. This is some straight-up RPG shit. You level up, get equipment, do it all. Speaking of equipment...

Did Harvest Moon ever let you craft fucking fire swords and poison battle axes? I didn't think so. Rune Factory 3 does. You can also craft armor, accessories, learn to cook, and whole lot of other shit.

This game also has a story. Does your Harvest Moon have a story? Oh, save your grandpa's farm? Fuck that shit. In Rune Factory 3, you play a dude who is half monster and has to unite monsters and humans once and for all by murdering all the monsters.

The short of it? Get outta here with your Harvest Moon. Make way for Rune Factory 3.
 
Top Bottom