• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Captain America vs. Master Chief

Status
Not open for further replies.
My God this again, OP should ad a disclaimer that points out that it was a fight voted on by fans. Sure a lot of things don't quite add up, but hey, what can you do.
 
Sinatar said:
2156798-cap_v_hulk_1.jpg


Hulk can shatter planets with his fists. Cap is fine fighting some nob in a power armor suit.
Click to expand...

Can we discount Ultimate Cap from this conversation, please?
 
doesnt mc armor weigh like half a ton yet he can run 105kph in it? a punch and captain america would go off flying

but its a fan voting anyway so whatever
 
Slayven said:
It's not about Cap's power it about his skill and experience. He literally fought just about everything and shown an amazing ability to adapt and overcome.
Click to expand...

At this point MC has probably killed something like a hundred thousand enemy combatants, most of whom have shielding of some kind and many of whom are vastly superior to MC in terms of equipment, endurance and tech. Cap physically cannot protect his whole body simultaneously and one of Chief's most common opponents are an alien whose entire body except for one small bit is protected behind an energy shield. Which he dispatches in seconds. If cap is running around at Chief he's going to get bullets to the leg. Unless he turned into superman while I wasn't watching, he's now on the ground, maimed and screaming in pain from having a dozen 7.62x51 NATO rounds embedded in his lower body. If he's not protecting his face, he now has bullet holes where a brain used to be. If he's not protecting an arm, his arm is riddled with bullets.

Even in a fistfight with no armor, Cap would at best be "comparable" with Chief's physical strength. With the power armor suit Chief has a significant advantage. He can move with superhuman speed, endless stamina, and punches extremely hard. You're the comics expert, can Cap punch hard enough to bend materials stronger than steel which are additionally protected by energy shielding capable of resisting explosions?
 
The assault rifle part was incredibly on point. Can't shoot accurately at the range at all, but as soon as Master Chief whipped out his pistol, Cap would have a bullet to the head. Halo 1 pistol is just THAT good.
 
Can the mods change the title to reflect the current 343 cat fight occurring over Donkey Kong?

Also, Master Chief basically got the CapAm serum, alongside metal bones and military training since 6 years old.
 
ThoseDeafMutes said:
At this point MC has probably killed something like a hundred thousand enemy combatants, most of whom have shielding of some kind and many of whom are vastly superior to MC in terms of equipment, endurance and tech. Cap physically cannot protect his whole body simultaneously and one of Chief's most common opponents are an alien whose entire body except for one small bit is protected behind an energy shield. Which he dispatches in seconds. If cap is running around at Chief he's going to get bullets to the leg. Unless he turned into superman while I wasn't watching, he's now on the ground, maimed and screaming in pain from having a dozen 7.62x51 NATO rounds embedded in his lower body. If he's not protecting his face, he now has bullet holes where a brain used to be. If he's not protecting an arm, his arm is riddled with bullets.

Even in a fistfight with no armor, Cap would at best be "comparable" with Chief's physical strength. With the power armor suit Chief has a significant advantage. He can move with superhuman speed, endless stamina, and punches extremely hard. You're the comics expert, can Cap punch hard enough to bend materials stronger than steel which are additionally protected by energy shielding capable of resisting explosions?
Click to expand...
Colbert-High-Five.gif


This man speaks the trurth.
 
ThoseDeafMutes said:
At this point MC has probably killed something like a hundred thousand enemy combatants, most of whom have shielding of some kind and many of whom are vastly superior to MC in terms of equipment, endurance and tech. Cap physically cannot protect his whole body simultaneously and one of Chief's most common opponents are an alien whose entire body except for one small bit is protected behind an energy shield. Which he dispatches in seconds. If cap is running around at Chief he's going to get bullets to the leg. Unless he turned into superman while I wasn't watching, he's now on the ground, maimed and screaming in pain from having a dozen 7.62x51 NATO rounds embedded in his lower body. If he's not protecting his face, he now has bullet holes where a brain used to be. If he's not protecting an arm, his arm is riddled with bullets.

Even in a fistfight with no armor, Cap would at best be "comparable" with Chief's physical strength. With the power armor suit Chief has a significant advantage. He can move with superhuman speed, endless stamina, and punches extremely hard. You're the comics expert, can Cap punch hard enough to bend materials stronger than steel which are additionally protected by energy shielding capable of resisting explosions?
Click to expand...
None of them Cap's skill and experience. Halo's enemies line up to get shot. It's like bragging Cap took down Hydra platoons.
 
Okay, how did Captain America drop down from a plane without a parachute?

Why did Captain America drop down from a plane without a parachute?

Actual video is fine. Good action and they did a decent job with the ridiculous costumes they were given. I did find it LOL-worthy how Master Chief forgot he had a pistol.
Slayven said:
Cap been free falling for years. Parachute would only slow him down.
Click to expand...
What the fuck.
Can Crusher said:
MC is a killa, who did Cap ever killed?
Click to expand...
Knowing comics, probably half the cast of Marvel.
 
A Human with a modified body and an adamantium shield against a modified human in an armor that beats tanks and its shield generator could probably be some small nuke.


We don't need references of comic book or halo games to see who would win this. Of course the authors came up with more and more hilarious wins by Cap ( Oh god the Ultimate version is such a joke) and in Halo 4 the master chief survives a blast that turns humans around him to skeletons in a split second.


But I highly doubt Cap could win this. Especially if MC would have some of the newer weapons out of the Halo arsenal.


Adamantium shield? Say hi to the Binary rifle, or the beam rifle, with its absurd auto aim he'll win
 
pants said:
tsk tsk. people always underestimating cap.
Click to expand...

In this thread I only see people under estimating MC. Cap would have literally no chance.

MC basically is Captain America, except he started as the most physically gifted human in the world, the received the serum and various physical modifications to make him 10-20x stronger than the absolute peak human. Then he puts on armor that's like Stark's plus 500 years. Then they give him a sentient AI that actually interfaces between his armor and his brain.
 
ThoseDeafMutes said:
Cap physically cannot protect his whole body simultaneously and one of Chief's most common opponents are an alien whose entire body except for one small bit is protected behind an energy shield. Which he dispatches in seconds. If cap is running around at Chief he's going to get bullets to the leg shield. Unless he turned into superman while I wasn't watching, he's now on the ground behind you, maimed and screaming in pain from having a dozen 7.62x51 NATO rounds embedded in his lower body kicking Chief's helmet off his head like a cosmic linebacker. If he's not protecting his face, he now has bullet holes where a brain used to be Chief's gun, which he is snapping in half. If he's not protecting an arm, his arm is riddled with bullets fist is pulverizing Chief's visor.
Click to expand...

fixed that up a little
 
Can Crusher said:
MC is a killa, who did Cap ever killed?
Click to expand...
Barond Blood

3492022-baron.jpg


El_Chino said:
Line up? Lol. You must not know about Elites.
Click to expand...
Elites ain't no Rhino
y5iqomh.jpg

Seth C said:
In this thread I only see people under estimating MC. Cap would have literally no chance.

MC basically is Captain America, except he started as the most physically gifted human in the world, the received the serum and various physical modifications to many him 10-20x stronger than the absolute peak human. Then he puts on armor that's like Stark's plus 500 years. Then they give him a sentient AI that actually interfaces between his armor and his brain.
Click to expand...
Stark plus 500 years?
Seriously? that Mjornir armor is not even in teh same time zone as the Silver Centurion let alone Stark's recent shit.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

  • Poll
Peppermint vs. Spearmint
25
624
Zacfoldor replied
  • Poll
Darth Maul vs. Rey.
2
55
518
John Marston replied
  • Poll
Superman (1978) vs Batman (1989) vs Spider-Man (2002)
2
81
1K
MrCunningham replied
Forget Captain America, Twisted Metal Season 2 Teaser Is Here!
13
1K
trikster40 replied
KCD2 vs F1
6
553
Catphish replied
Top Bottom