MvCSpiderman
Banned
There's polarizing opinions on modern 2D and 3D Sonic. But I believe you can have real discussions by having something more objective included in the conversation.
Below you will find the consensual game reviewer averages of modern 2D and 3D Sonic games on MC.
3D games
Sonic Adventure 2 - 89%
Sonic Adventure (GC)- 57%
Sonic Adventure 2 (GC)- 73%
Sonic Adventure (XBL)- 48%
Sonic Adventure 2 (XBL)- 60%
Sonic Heroes - 72%
Shadow the Hedgehog - 45%
Sonic the Hedgehog - 46%
Sonic Unleashed - 60%
Sonic Colors - 78%
Sonic Generations - 77%
Sonic Lost World - 63%
Sonic Boom - 32%
Sonic Forces - 57%
Storybook Sonic and the Secret Rings - 69%
Storybook Sonic and the Black Knight - 54%
2D games
Sonic Advance - 87%
Sonic Advance 2 - 83%
Sonic Advance 3 - 79%
Sonic Rush - 82%
Sonic Rush Adventure - 78%
Sonic Rivals - 64%
Sonic Rivals 2 - 60%
Sonic 4 part 1 - 72%
Sonic 4 part 2 - 61%
Sonic Colors 2D - 79%
Sonic Boom Shattered Crystal - 47%
Sonic Boom Fire and Ice - 62%
Sonic Mania - 86% (87% plus)
In the end they don't seem too dissimilar from each other. I think one could conclude that both 2D and 3D Sonic reflect on the franchises quality equally. Whether that's good or bad thing is up to the observer.
Below you will find the consensual game reviewer averages of modern 2D and 3D Sonic games on MC.
3D games
Sonic Adventure 2 - 89%
Sonic Adventure (GC)- 57%
Sonic Adventure 2 (GC)- 73%
Sonic Adventure (XBL)- 48%
Sonic Adventure 2 (XBL)- 60%
Sonic Heroes - 72%
Shadow the Hedgehog - 45%
Sonic the Hedgehog - 46%
Sonic Unleashed - 60%
Sonic Colors - 78%
Sonic Generations - 77%
Sonic Lost World - 63%
Sonic Boom - 32%
Sonic Forces - 57%
Storybook Sonic and the Secret Rings - 69%
Storybook Sonic and the Black Knight - 54%
2D games
Sonic Advance - 87%
Sonic Advance 2 - 83%
Sonic Advance 3 - 79%
Sonic Rush - 82%
Sonic Rush Adventure - 78%
Sonic Rivals - 64%
Sonic Rivals 2 - 60%
Sonic 4 part 1 - 72%
Sonic 4 part 2 - 61%
Sonic Colors 2D - 79%
Sonic Boom Shattered Crystal - 47%
Sonic Boom Fire and Ice - 62%
Sonic Mania - 86% (87% plus)
In the end they don't seem too dissimilar from each other. I think one could conclude that both 2D and 3D Sonic reflect on the franchises quality equally. Whether that's good or bad thing is up to the observer.
Last edited: