• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Completely unofficial NeoGAF podcast ratings thread

Must Listen:
Player One

My second favorite:
PC Gamer Podcast

I'll listen to any of the others but they don't tend to interest me that much, and especially not 1up yours.
 
EternalGamer said:
I"m curious as to why the CAG podcast is so popular. It seemed alright the half dozen or so times I've listened to it, but nothing all that interesting. Lots of "filler" material.
Click to expand...

I dunno, the CAGcast was the really the first podcast I ever listened to, and I've been a CAG for a long time. I'll admit that I haven't listened to one in a few weeks now, but they've always been pretty good.
 
Must Listen:
1UP Yours
Player One Podcast
CAGcast

Worth a listen:
Kojima Productions Report
Playstation Nation (for the PS3 owners)
 
I only listen to 1up podcasts anymore.

Also the Bungie podcast...oh wait...that was just an empty promise.
 
1. GFW Radio
2. 1UP Yours
3. Legendary Thread
4. EGM Live*

Yeah I basically only listen to the 1up network podcasts..
 
Games related podcasts currently sitting in my itunes (no particular order)

1UP Yours
Retronaughts
CAGcast
Penny Arcade
EGM Live
Evil Avatar
Game Theory
Gmer Andy Live
Gamerscore Blog
Gamepost Hotspot
GFW Radio
Insomniac Games Full Moon Show
Joystic
Legendaary Thread
PC Gamer
Player One
Gamespot UK
Xbox 360 Fanboy
Major Nelson
 
Nothing is a must listen for me these days...but here's what I think is worth checking out:

1UP Yours - fell off big for me after Luke left, it's just not as much fun. I still listen every
week, and I can't wait until they hit a stride again.

Player One - good bunch of guys

Because of this thread I'll check out the CAGcast.
 
Listened to ******* podcast for the first time.

So bad. Never again.

The only positive was they list the different segments and what time they start on the download page

All podcasts should do this.
 
Dizzan said:
Listened to ******* podcast for the first time.

So bad. Never again.

The only positive was they list the different segments and what time they start.

All podcasts should do this.
Click to expand...
Just checking for filters, is that Joy-stiq?

Haven't listened to that, the topics always seem outdated. Ah well, they featured my show in the Rodeo, so it's all good for me.
 
Fast Karate for the Gentleman (they don't review games every show)
NPR's Press Start
4 color rebellion (on a long break, wonder when they'll come back)
 
Must listen:
CAGcast

In this podcast, I can actually hear the difference between the people on it (since they're only 2, never change, and have very different voices, VERY).

Also, because of that the podcast is far more personal, and most importantly: They don't always talk about video games. I mean, I read all the news here on GAF and on the websites, why would I want to hear it again in a podcast?

Also, the host lives in Tokyo, the other guy in New York. Since they don't see each other every day, they have a lot of interesting stuff to talk about on the podcast. One time they also let their wifes talk to eachother, I mean, I can never see that happening on 1upyours/IGN etc...
 
Must
All Games Interactive

I can't believe more people haven't listed AGI it's like a daily Video game show with shows on Fridays lasting upto 8 hours.
I thought you were all hardcore.

Worthy

1 Up yours (Still enjoyably without Luke)
Wiik in review (The only decent place to get Wii news)
 
Must:
GFWradio, 1upyours

All the other ones I like have been listed already, except for The Fanboys, whom I find very funny on occasion.
 
Xrenity said:
Must:
1upyours
Player One
GafCast

Worth:
GFW Radio
Retronauts
Click to expand...
My list changed a bit over time. Don't have/make that much time for podcasts anymore. And I like GFW radio much better than I did then.

Must:
GFW Radio

Worth:
Player One
 
So much love for EGM, yet they suck when they don't have a guest.

It would be so awesome if we could have the news from 1UPYours, the guests from EGM and the community stuff from GAFcast.
 
The best:
GFW
Classic 1Up yours
Giant Bomb
Geekbox

Good ones:
1UP Yours/Listen up
Retronauts
Rebel FM
A Life well wasted
Idle Thumbs
 
Must:
1UP Yours
Bombcast

Worth:
IGN - Podcast Beyond

aside: has the hotspot been better? I stopped after gersmanngate. Brenden Sinclair couldn't holdup my interest.
 
I could only ever listen to the 1up yours podcasts. Everything else was too "showey". Id rather just listen to 4 or 5 drunk dudes sit around talking about games. I dont want "segments" and crap.

I tried the bombcast but Jeff's voice irks me a bit.
 
Ledsen said:
Er, where is Idle Thumbs on that list? It's not even on there? What the hell? No other podcast comes even close, so... it must be some kind of conspiracy :(
Click to expand...

Hint: Examine the date of the original post
 
ice cream said:
The best:
GFW
Classic 1Up yours
Giant Bomb
Geekbox

Good ones:
1UP Yours/Listen up
Retronauts
Rebel FM
A Life well wasted
Idle Thumbs
Click to expand...
not only do you bump a 2 year old thread, you, you post podcasts that dont even exist anymore
 
i just noticed on the front page from a post OnkelC made that he's banned..... what's the story there?
 
Should we make a new thread or is it possible to save this one?

Just to try and make it relevant, here is my current rotation in order of appreciation. Oh how things have changed! :D

  1. Idle Thumbs
  2. Bombcast
  3. ListenUP
  4. Gamers With Jobs
  5. CAGcast
  6. J-stiq
  7. RebelFM
  8. In-Game Chat
  9. Gamespy Debriefing (Remains to be seen, but hopeful)

Greg Ford, where have you gone?!?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Unofficial Paper Mario PC port is in the works
11
326
Grenseal replied
2025 | NeoGaf GOTY Voting thread (Round 1)
2 3
129
3K
Topher replied
  • Locked
2025 | NeoGaf Game of the Year |OT| Finalist voting thread | VOTING OVER
2
57
3K
Miyazaki’s Slave replied
  • Locked
Crimson Desert messes up save file completely for this player!!
12
289
Bitstream replied
Resident Evil Requiem has an impressive 70% completion rate on Steam, 67% on PlayStation
Analysis Platform 
34
307
Spukc replied
Top Bottom