Support NeoGAF

[Skiesofwonder]

I hate birthday cake so cookie cake wins by default.

 

[ryan13ts]

I can't get enough of cookie cake. I'd slap someone's momma for some good cookie cake right about now...

 

[abstract alien]

Not going to lie, I love sweets. I'm talking desserts that are obviously too rich and sweet for their own good, I still love anyway. Cookie cake is the worst thing I've ever eaten. It's like one big piece of processed shit, and the creams/frostings they use are akin to nothingness. One of the worst things in human history. For years I kept trying it because it should be heaven on Earth by name. I mean, it's called a cookie cake.

Nope. Still awful, and getting worse each time I try it. The downfall of humanity as it stands right now.

 

[Sub_Level]

A lot of these types of sweet sound good until you eat them and feel like a beached whale afterwards. Really gotta watch your portions.

 

[HGStormy]

Not going to lie, I love sweets. I'm talking desserts that are obviously too rich and sweet for their own good, I still love anyway. Cookie cake is the worst thing I've ever eaten. It's like one big piece of processed shit, and the creams/frostings they use are akin to nothingness. One of the worst things in human history. For years I kept trying it because it should be heaven on Earth by name. I mean, it's called a cookie cake.

Nope. Still awful, and getting worse each time I try it. The downfall of humanity as it stands right now.

Quit stomping all over my dream :'( What else am I going to live for, if not cookie cake?!

 

[Rentahamster]

A cookie/ice cream cake is godlike.

 

[BigEvilTurtle]

Cookie cake is fucking gross.

Actually, cake is gross unless it's covered in hot chocolate syrup and ice cream.

 

[DJ_Lae]

I've never heard of it until now, somehow, but I wonder what the point is. Why ruin a cookie by making it even more sweet?

It looks like something that would be good for a couple of bites, I guess.

 

[Not a Jellyfish]

Why not just make a cake out of cookie dough?

This, it is the cookie cake I know of.

 

[triplestation]

But its not cake at all just a bigass cookie

You can't really compare sorry

There is no competition here

 

[atomsk]

 

[Icyflamez96]

But its not cake at all just a bigass cookie

You can't really compare sorry

There is no competition here

No competition cause cookie cake blows it out of the water.

 

[DavionStriker]

While I do agree that cookie cake is GREAT, I think ice cream cake has to take the title of GOAT.

 

[ryseing]

Great American Cookie cookie cakes are GOAT. Had one for my birthday ever since i can remember.

The best is leftover cookie cake with cold milk. MMMM.

 

[BumRush]

Also, as a bonus, the cookies are usually slightly undercooked...soooooooooooo good.

 

[BossLackey]

Disgustingly sweet. it's sugar in 3 or 4 different forms all together.

No thanks.

 

[Wthermans]

Yeah they are pretty good, however ice cream cakes still remains the champ.

Agreed. Love me some ice cream cake.

 

[FO-totality]

Yeah they are pretty good, however ice cream cakes still remains the champ.

aww yeah that's the stuff right there

 

[efyu_lemonardo]

Here's mine that I pretty much have to myself right now

AYOOOO

People are dying from Ebola while you eat that

 

[Ultimadrago]

Yep. Cookie cake is great.

Eat it warm, eat it cold, drink its liquid, eat with gold.

It's all good.

 

[Currygan]

never heard of it, but it can't beat the Victoria sponge

 

[Owensboro]

Yeah they are pretty good, however ice cream cakes still remains the champ.

I'd rather just have Ice Cream. Get that superfluous cake nonsense out of here.

Cookie Cake is the only thing keeping me from outright declaring that Pies > Cakes. Pies are better than cakes, but it's not a flawless victory.

*My face when I see a cookie cake at a party next to home-made ice cream.*

 

[DedValve]

I've never knew this was a thing. Where, where can I buy this so that I may devour it?

Instructions to cook? I NEED MORE INFO OP.

 

[anarckitty]

I may be considered a cookie cake snob, but the only ones that I will eat are from Great American Cookie Co.

Edit: They are infinitely better on the second day as well. I find them to be too soft on the day they're baked.

 

[Faiz]

Cookie cake isn't terrible but it usually just makes me wish I had a good actual cookie instead.

 

[GulAtiCa]

I LOVE cookie cake. Esp the big one from Target. Mmmmm

 

[Icyflamez96]

While I do agree that cookie cake is GREAT, I think ice cream cake has to take the title of GOAT.

Umm, why do people keep separating the two? Ice cream + cookie cake >>>>>>>> all

 

[Icyflamez96]

I've never knew this was a thing. Where, where can I buy this so that I may devour it?

Instructions to cook? I NEED MORE INFO OP.

Sams Club has good ones. That's the one I posted in the OP... The one I have says "Daily Chef" on the box. It was around $18

 

[Icyflamez96]

Another year...

 

[Zombine]

Cookie Cake with too much frosting is pretty gross. Still the best cake though.

Another year...

Hope you enjoyed your day!

 

[Icyflamez96]

Cookie Cake with too much frosting is pretty gross.

When I get tired of it I just wipe it off and it's good as new.

Hope you enjoyed your day!

Thanks! I did

 

[Bacon]

Cookie Cake with too much frosting is pretty gross.

Yeah the frosting makes it disgusting. Just give me the cookie

 

[Log4Girlz]

American struggle cake

 

[Zoolader]

Not as good as a cookie. Not as good as a cake. They are an abomination.

 

[LyleLanley]

Cookie cake is bad and not good.

 

[Zombine]

Yeah the frosting makes it disgusting. Just give me the cookie

I think it's more of a thing with the grocery store bought cookie cake. At least locally, the cookie is amazing up until the crust, which is lined with this gigantic pile of white icing. Too sweet and stomach ache inducing.

You know what I always get instead of a cake? A lemon meringue pie.

 

[AllIsOneIsNone]

Cookie cake is a big cookie with icing on it. That's not always a bad thing.

 

[Brianimaniac]

One of the best things about cookies is the way the edges crisp up more than the center area when you bake them. If you bake up a giant-ass cookie, you're decreasing the amount of edge and fucking the whole thing up.

 

[Strangelove77]

Dude, that's just a giant cookie.

 

[Icyflamez96]

One of the best things about cookies is the way the edges crisp up more than the center area when you bake them. If you bake up a giant-ass cookie, you're decreasing the amount of edge and fucking the whole thing up.

While it's true that the edges of a cookie are usually better because of that reason, a good cookie will taste delicious all the way through. Luckily, all of the cookie cakes I've had taste like a good cookie.

 

[SoulUnison]

Yeah, but... cake.

This is like saying the best hamburger is two sandwiches.

 

[C00kie M0nster]

Cookie cake is where it's at. I buy them religiously. I eat them endearingly. I savor them eternally.

 

[The Technomancer]

I disagree if only because the cookies are so regularly terrible. Its got that weird spongy density of store baked cookies I can't stand

 

[Icyflamez96]

Yeah, but... cake.

This is like saying the best hamburger is two sandwiches.

Well to be honest, most cake I don't really like that much. Every cookie cake I've had is delicious.

This almost makes me think that cookies are just better than cake, but most cookies I come across aren't really too notable either.

 

[outunderthestars]

Cookie cake is where it's at. I buy them religiously. I eat them endearingly. I savor them eternally.

This post made my night.

 

[Admiral Woofington]

Ah no


Tres leches wins for life.

 

[Chibot]

Cookie cake is amazing. Someone in my family makes one every year on my birthday. The only thing I would add to the OP is sprinkles- you have to try sprinkles on top of the icing.

 

[Afrodium]

OP, you're straight up wrong. The best kind of cake is a cookie? The fuck out of here. If I want some cake I'm gonna eat some cake and not a big-ass Tollhouse with some frosting on the edges.

 

[GulAtiCa]

Another year...

That looks delicious!!

 

[Icyflamez96]

OP, you're straight up wrong. The best kind of cake is a cookie? The fuck out of here. If I want some cake I'm gonna eat some cake and not a big-ass Tollhouse with some frosting on the edges.

Goes to show how gross most cake is.