• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Did George Bush do any positive things?

Status
Not open for further replies.
His AIDs work was pretty great.
Also that reef reserve was a good thing too.
The initial response to 9/11 was pretty good.
If you can overlook the failures leading up to 9/11 and Iraq the response wasn't terrible.

Afghanistan was a failure.

New Orleans, FEMA being incompetent.

Regulations on the banks being lessened and economy crashed.

Glass-Seagal being repealed was also a huge, and I mean HUGE reason our economy took a huge hit(it was meant as a safe-guard to prevent another Depression, LOL)

Gitmo, Patriot Act.

Torture issues and the destruction of the torture convention in American values(military).

Making America not a leader in the world politics, and pushing our allies away from us(not just because he was in Iraqi and Afghanistan, he actually fucked up the relationships on his own).
 
Was the AIDs investment purely a humanitarian effort or was it a strategic play to offset rising Chinese aid & influence? This is the first I've heard of Bush's African efforts, but I've heard a ton about China & Africa.
 
another bad thing he did was the No Child Left Behind Act

It was essentially that the smarter(the best funded already schools) would get money funneled to them because they were on top. The schools that needed the most help got nothing because they were not even in the competition to begin with(scores being low because their parents had to work much harder to make less, and not having time to give the full effort that parents should give to help make their children succeed.)
 
What were his plans for NASA? It's a shame that NASA's presently been mostly gutted.

At least Gingrich would have gotten us that moon base.

After the Columbia explosion (which happened relatively early in his administration), NASA decided it was time to end the shuttle program. It was going to be replaced by the Constellation program, which would be a new manned moon program. NASA worked on it for 6 years, developing the rockets and capsule that would make the journey, they even had a successful test launch of the rocket prototype.

Obama came in, decided to continue with the retirement of the shuttle program, but also basically told NASA to forget about the 6 years of work on the Constellation program and begin on a very very vague program that MIGHT land astronauts on nearby asteroids. It was a very vague goal with no real direction. Bush's plan ended the shuttle program and woudl have had a replacement ready a few years later, only having Astronauts hitch rides with Russians for a few years. Obama's plan has no direction for any future manned flight programs, and calls for maybe selecting the type of rocket to be used later in 2015, rather than continuing the 6 years of work that went into the Ares rocket program for Constellation.

The Constellation program was the most focused manned NASA goal since the beginning of the Shuttle program, and while over budget and behind schedule (as all NASA things are) it was progressing nicely. I will say the one good thing about Obama's plan was a bigger focus on private firms going into space (though even a lot of this was well under way before he took office).
 
another bad thing he did was the No Child Left Behind Act

It was essentially that the smarter(the best funded already schools) would get money funneled to them because they were on top. The schools that needed the most help got nothing because they were not even in the competition to begin with(scores being low because their parents had to work much harder to make less, and not having time to give the full effort that parents should give to help make their children succeed.)

It was not a perfect program, but there were some positive results:

U.S. students have made significant gains in math since 1995 and score above average on international fourth- and eighth-grade tests in the subject, according to a study released Tuesday.


black and Hispanic students still had lower math and science scores than white students, but the gap between them generally shrank since 1995, except for the gap in math scores between white and Hispanic fourth-graders, which didn't change. Closing this achievement gap is a federal priority.

Science and Math scores improve in the U.S. 2008
 
The Papahānaumokuākea Marine National Monument

w7xw8.png


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Papahānaumokuākea_Marine_National_Monument

The Papahānaumokuākea Marine National Monument (or Papahānaumokuākea as it is commonly called) is a World Heritage listed, U.S. National Monument encompassing 140,000 square miles (360,000 km2) of ocean waters, including ten islands and atolls of the Northwestern Hawaiian Islands, internationally recognized for both its cultural and natural values as follows:

"The area has deep cosmological and traditional significance for living Native Hawaiian culture, as an ancestral environment, as an embodiment of the Hawaiian concept of kinship between people and the natural world, and as the place where it is believed that life originates and to where the spirits return after death. On two of the islands, Nihoa and Makumanamana, there are archaeological remains relating to pre-European settlement and use. Much of the monument is made up of pelagic and deepwater habitats, with notable features such as seamounts and submerged banks, extensive coral reefs and lagoons. It is one of the largest marine protected areas (MPAs) in the world."[1]

The area was proclaimed the Northwestern Hawaiian Islands Marine National Monument by U.S. President George W. Bush on June 15, 2006; it was renamed Papahānaumokuākea in 2007, and inscribed on the World Heritage list as Papahānaumokuākea on 30 July 2010, at the 34th Session of the World Heritage Committee, Brasilia.[2]
 
Afghanistan was a failure.

New Orleans, FEMA being incompetent.

Regulations on the banks being lessened and economy crashed.

Glass-Seagal being repealed was also a huge, and I mean HUGE reason our economy took a huge hit(it was meant as a safe-guard to prevent another Depression, LOL)

Gitmo, Patriot Act.

Torture issues and the destruction of the torture convention in American values(military).

Making America not a leader in the world politics, and pushing our allies away from us(not just because he was in Iraqi and Afghanistan, he actually fucked up the relationships on his own).

OK I agree with all this but OP asked about positive things.
 
After the Columbia explosion (which happened relatively early in his administration), NASA decided it was time to end the shuttle program. It was going to be replaced by the Constellation program, which would be a new manned moon program. NASA worked on it for 6 years, developing the rockets and capsule that would make the journey, they even had a successful test launch of the rocket prototype.

Obama came in, decided to continue with the retirement of the shuttle program, but also basically told NASA to forget about the 6 years of work on the Constellation program and begin on a very very vague program that MIGHT land astronauts on nearby asteroids. It was a very vague goal with no real direction. Bush's plan ended the shuttle program and woudl have had a replacement ready a few years later, only having Astronauts hitch rides with Russians for a few years. Obama's plan has no direction for any future manned flight programs, and calls for maybe selecting the type of rocket to be used later in 2015, rather than continuing the 6 years of work that went into the Ares rocket program for Constellation.

The Constellation program was the most focused manned NASA goal since the beginning of the Shuttle program, and while over budget and behind schedule (as all NASA things are) it was progressing nicely. I will say the one good thing about Obama's plan was a bigger focus on private firms going into space (though even a lot of this was well under way before he took office).

QCPN0.gif


I'm not even American, and I love NASA.

Maybe Obama knows something we don't. Land on asteroids?

-armageddon.jpg
 
Wait, if it was bipartisan, why didn't it pass?


edit: By the way, the Iraq/Saddam side of his presidency always seem to have originated from Cheney's cohorts more than anything else. Ultimately Bush supported him, yes, but if I recall correctly there was an enormous amount of discussion/tension in his team prior to the invasion.

this is true, after the intial effort in Iraq bombed hard and the Surge (which Cheney/Rumsfeld were against) worked, those clowns thankfully got sidelined. There's a scene in I think his memoir where Cheney wants to bomb Iran after he's been discredited and Bush asks the rest of the room if anyone agrees with Cheney, and like no one raises their hand.
 
Wait, if it was bipartisan, why didn't it pass?

Bipartisan opposition -- the bill split the Republican caucus, which is still mostly hardline on immigration, and picked up some Democratic nays as well.

http://www.govtrack.us/congress/votes/110-2007/s235

Some of the Democratic nay votes are probably tactical (to avoid a vote that would be dangerous for them in the campaign and wouldn't matter in any case), but some, such as Byrd's, clearly aren't. On a pure majority vote it might've had a chance with the White House whipping, but for cloture...
 
This happened in 1999 under Clinton's watch, not Bush.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gramm–Leach–Bliley_Act

ah, more reasons to dislike Clinton.


MSNBC citing Bush as doing something positive is not credible? Because MSNBC is full of well known bush lovers.

It's MSNBC, they don't really have that great of credibility.


It's just as credible as a Foxnews story that praises Obama

Which I also, would ask for a different source.
 
He had some good stuff and some bad stuff, I honestly think if it wasn't for the two wars he'd be remembered as a decent president. Not great or anything, but he had some positive impacts.

If it wasnt for this god awful terrible shitty painful disaster thing this president did, he wouldnt have been so bad

apply to anything about any person who did anything ever

fact is that he did do it
 
If it wasnt for this god awful terrible shitty painful disaster thing this president did, he wouldnt have been so bad

apply to anything about any person who did anything ever

fact is that he did do it



So did LBJ , but people still rank him as a top 5 or 10 president.
 
He was the last hope for manned space exploration (on the US's part, at least).

That's kind of funny and stings at the same time.
 
To be fair, his initial initial response to 9/11 was to hide for like three days. I'm pretty sure he did not make any kind of a statement until Thursday or Friday.

Huh, looks like I remembered this speech wrong:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x7OCgMPX2mE

I remembered it happening sooner than three days later. Guess not.

I am not an American, but everyone in Canada was horrified. I have to say that speech originally sent chills down my spine. I thought it was great. You kind of have to relive the moment to feel it again.
 
He threw a goddamn strike at Yankee stadium in a goddamn flak jacket in the first game after 9/11.

Best thing any modern president has done.
 
We all know about the stupid shit he (or at least Cheney and his administration) is responsible for. Multiple wars, financial meltdown on his watch, PATRIOT, illegal surveillance, etc.

Did he do anything positive? Or useful? Or just generally good?

George-W-Bush-Oct11-01-Legacy.jpg

Aside from giving SNL and Will Ferral a shit ton of material to work with, NO!
 
How many of them returned home?


Hostile deaths: 47,359

Non-hostile deaths: 10,797

Total: 58,156 (including men formerly classified as MIA and Mayaguez casualties).

Highest state death rate: West Virginia--84.1. (The national average death rate for males in 1970 was 58.9 per 100,000).

WIA: 303,704 - 153,329 required hospitalization, 50,375 who did not.

Severely disabled: 75,000, 23,214 were classified 100% disabled. 5,283 lost
limbs, 1,081 sustained multiple amputations. Amputation or crippling wounds to the lower extremities were 300% higher than in WWII and 70% higher than in Korea. Multiple amputations occurred at the rate of 18.4% compared to 5.7% in WWII.

MIA: 2,338

POW: 766, of whom 114 died in captivity.

Draftees vs. volunteers: 25% (648,500) of total forces in country were draftees. (66% of U.S. armed forces members were drafted during WWII)
Draftees accounted for 30.4% (17,725) of combat deaths in Vietnam.

Reservists KIA: 5,977

National Guard: 6,140 served; 101 died.

from other link I posted
 
The very, very sad truth about Bush is, as much as I hated him during his 8 years, he is so much better then the current crop of GOPers it is ridiculous. Bush wasn't very talented, wasn't very smart, and made extremely bad decisions, but he wasn't insane like the current GOP is.
 
The very, very sad truth about Bush is, as much as I hated him during his 8 years, he is so much better then the current crop of GOPers it is ridiculous. Bush wasn't very talented, wasn't very smart, and made extremely bad decisions, but he wasn't insane like the current GOP is.
Yeah. After Obama won... it's just been like a downward spiral into more and more craziness.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom