-
Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!
Disney is struggling to cast its live-action Aladdin.
- Thread starter torre_avenue
- Start date
This almost sounds like a convenient story to allow Disney to back away from Guy Richie. Put it in pre-production hell, everyone can part ways without losing face, 6 months later restart with a different director/team.
The moment King Arthur bombed (critically and financially), everyone was wondering....
The moment King Arthur bombed (critically and financially), everyone was wondering....
The Emperor
Member
Guys you have all missed the most obvious option, he was right under our noses
Zayn Malik
Half-pakistani and can sing and dance and speak fluent english. Fits the disney criteria since they don't seem to care that Alladin is Arabic.
Plus this will make the music marketing very easy for Disney.
tehehehe
Zayn Malik
Half-pakistani and can sing and dance and speak fluent english. Fits the disney criteria since they don't seem to care that Alladin is Arabic.
Plus this will make the music marketing very easy for Disney.
tehehehe
yeah I'm confused that there's not one ME guy sitting in someone's theater department or troupe that doesn't fit the bill for this
Had to google her. Best googling of the week.
xDUMPWEEDx
Banned
Aladdin
Genie
Genie
UnemployedVillain
Member
Guys you have all missed the most obvious option, he was right under our noses
Zayn Malik
Half-pakistani and can sing and dance and speak fluent english. Fits the disney criteria since they don't seem to care that Alladin is Arabic.
Plus this will make the music marketing very easy for Disney.
tehehehe
I mean Nolan got Harry Styles to act so...it's not impossible
victreeb3l
Member
Aamir Khan as Aladdin
John Harker
Definitely doesn't make things up as he goes along.
Aladdin
I was scrolling by too fast and thought this was a picture of Nathan Fillion
xDUMPWEEDx
Banned
Kumail or Nathan as Aladdin would be hysterical.
thecouncil
Banned
Omar Sharif would be the perfect Aladdin.
Besides the fact that he died 2 years ago, what's the hold up?
Besides the fact that he died 2 years ago, what's the hold up?
Sho_Nuff82
Member
2000 actors and they can't find anyone decent looking who can sing as well as Hermoine or Bard?
Sounds like overkill, perhaps because they're looking for a newcomer with sequel potential. Reminds me of the Spiderman: Homecoming casting.
And_Gignac
Member
Cast Zayn and be done with it.
The Book of One Thousand and One Nights is all over the place with locations.
:shrugemoji:
The Real Abed
Perma-Junior
This is like the one and only live-action Disney adaptation I'm looking forward to. But I'd much rather they find the right people, and not whitewash it, than pick a completely wrong cast.
Take your time, Disney. I want this done right.
Take your time, Disney. I want this done right.
lightskintwin
Banned
Singers becoming actors happen all the time.
kunonabi
Member
Mulan is the only i want since the original was a giant waste of the premise.
The Emperor
Member
Whtiney Houston did it too
My old headshot from like 8-9 years ago. I have drama/musical theater experience.
Do I do it GAF?
Look at this suave motherfucker.
You look like the Karate Kid.
The Hamburglar
Banned
Riz ahmed is a decent actor but looks nothing like a middle easterner or even what Aladdin would look like.
Aladdin can fight, amir can't.
Aladdin can fight, amir can't.
*looks up pictures*
I think Disney has forgotten what Jasmine looks like.
Just cast Jake Gyllenhaal as Aladdin and be done with this farce, lol
Yeah I'm surprised this has been largely glossed over.
Bornstellar
Member
There is some irony in that a large number of ME peoples are fair-skinned (being one of the more racially diverse areas in the world), but casting someone with that look would probably have push back because they wouldn't look stereo-typically middle-eastern.
Still, Disney should take its time to get this right.
Still, Disney should take its time to get this right.
UnemployedVillain
Member
True, I'm not saying he was the first case, just a case where people were surprised at how he didn't completely suck
What? The Egyptian film industry is one of the largest in the world. What are you talking about?
Warm Machine
Member
I went to a university performance of Carmen and half the male cast was Chinese and there was one black guy. Spanish it was not. I've been to full pro operas with mostly white casts that take place in Egypt.
I think this is a little silly how far people are willing to take this. Yeah a big movie should be able to find people but barring people from roles because of their ethnicity not lining up exactly is purity test level nonsense. We wouldn't have gotten Ben Kingsley Ghandi with such exacting standards.
Gods of Egypt was silly as hell in the other direction and came off looking like a 2 hour long Iron Maiden album cover. There should be a balance to be found there somewhere.
With Will Smith it is 99% probably that the genie is a big blue CGI thing and he is just doing the mo-cap and VO.
I think this is a little silly how far people are willing to take this. Yeah a big movie should be able to find people but barring people from roles because of their ethnicity not lining up exactly is purity test level nonsense. We wouldn't have gotten Ben Kingsley Ghandi with such exacting standards.
Gods of Egypt was silly as hell in the other direction and came off looking like a 2 hour long Iron Maiden album cover. There should be a balance to be found there somewhere.
With Will Smith it is 99% probably that the genie is a big blue CGI thing and he is just doing the mo-cap and VO.
lightskintwin
Banned
I know Tom Hardy was originally Guy Ritchie's pick for Jafar but got pushback from the internet for it, and I think they backed down from that choice.
Theater is much different than Cinema. Theater plays to a small audience. Films play to a huge global audience and have far more impact in that regard.
Theater is much different than Cinema. Theater plays to a small audience. Films play to a huge global audience and have far more impact in that regard.
Foxy the Fox
Member
Really?
Tom Hardy? Why not Jason Statham? There's definitely going to be someone in here with a cockney accent, might as well go all the way.
HP_Wuvcraft
Banned
Yeah. I'm puzzled as to why he was not instantly cast, as Disney always cast the safe but good talent.
krackerjack
Member
Kim K as Jasmine 
Holy fuck his son looks exactly like him! I mean, yeah I expect some resemblance, but that's just uncanny.If Shah Rukh Khan was 30 years younger...
Shame his son isn't an actor.
perfectchaos007
Member
Kim K as Jasmine
Kylie Jenner tho
lightskintwin
Banned
krackerjack
Member
I want Coke not Diet Coke!
the story was set in a far away locale, not the characters. If you can't pronounce Arabic words without having a non middle eastern accent, you shouldn't be playing these roles. Otherwise what is the point? Just get Hispanic actors and be done with it. It would piss me off less that way, then for them to go, "well they look foreign, and they speak a foreign language too...ok close enough!"
Yeah, it's ridiculous. At this rate I wouldn't be surprised if Ryan Gosling got the role.
Aladdin is supposed to be some sort of teenage heartthrob.
Fuck it, I'm in. Give Tilda every role too lol.When in doubt...
Is the Middle Eastern TV/films like many latinamerica TV where many of the main actors are white/Caucasian and don't fit American expectations of brown and black Latinos?