• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Don't 3D printers pose a threat to LEGO?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Um most 3d printers do print in abs. A roll of abs plastic for an extruder printer could cost about $40 depending on the type of printer you have, you could probably print at least 100 or more Lego pieces depending on how you control your wall thicknesses and not waste material.
So that makes about $0.4 per piece. The LEGO set that was shown today costs about $0.12 per piece.
 
I think the only thing 3D printers are going to be dangerous for are things not in mass production. LEGO has no threat for that.

Costs would decrease as things are mass produced, so creating a single brick at home takes a long time and isn't going to be as cost productive as just going to the store and buying them.
 
Topical: a test print I ran to make sure the printer we have will work for my class this summer
YI9U14a.jpg
 
Topical: a test print I ran to make sure the printer we have will work for my class this summer
YI9U14a.jpg

You dirty communist! You trying to steal the food out of the Lego family children's mouths? I hope you think about what you need for the next 10 year's in prison!

This is pretty cool :) Do you have any pictures of the under-side? how rigid was it with the material you used... was it comparable to standard Lego plastic?
 
Not yet. I've tried printing parts myself but the accuracy and quality just isn't there yet. It could happen one day but I think the difference in quality will always differentiate Lego from 3rd printing and the competition
 
You dirty communist! You trying to steal the food out of the Lego family children's mouths? I hope you think about what you need for the next 10 year's in prison!

This is pretty cool :) Do you have any pictures of the under-side? how rigid was it with the material you used... was it comparable to standard Lego plastic?

The walls are flexible, but that's just kind of inevitable given how thin they are and the printing technique
vHNo1cO.jpg

wPU8xxF.jpg
 
Not going to be cheap

I mean is printing your own copy of a game of thrones cheaper or more expensive than a paperback?

Same thing here.

I'm curious if it will facilitate piracy of expensive, out of print sets. I mean, if the ROI is high, then the investment in printing the fakes would be nbd.
 
LEGO sell relatively cheap, mass produced but high tolerance and strength parts. They have a lot less to worry about compared to say, Games Workshop.
 
If cheap 3rd party knockoff don't pose a threat, and if high quality 3rd party blocks don't pose a threat, 3D printing sure as hell wont.
 
I know you are joking, but didn't the Lego patent run out a few years back, making this perfectly legal?

I'm not even sure how that would work. No law is ever going to exist that would stop you from, say, milling out a piece of plastic as a LEGO for your own personal use. They might be able to stop people from distributing actual 3D designs, but then where do schematics like this fall?
lego.png


This is the diagram that I worked from, and its 5-10 minutes of work to convert this into a 3D model if you know what you're doing
 
It will probably impact Lego sales quite a bit but cheap lego hasn't overtaken legos sales and would be a far cost effective alternative than printing each piece individually. 3d Printed lego would be a different type of plastic and poorer quality. 3D printer might be able to recreate a close replication of the lego shape but the factory quality lego is much higher quality.
 
3d printers can probably do decent and affordable imitation within 5 years but I see the problem being pad printing. It's not easy/cheap to get similar quality paint jobs on the parts.

I'd go with this. Printing and molding LEGO has gotten really impressive recently. Compare 2001 Bionicle

geek-%D1%81%D0%B0%D0%B9%D1%82-%D0%BF%D1%80%D0%BE%D0%B3%D1%80%D0%B0%D0%BC%D0%BC%D0%B8%D1%81%D1%82%D1%8B-%D0%BC%D0%BD%D0%B5-%D0%BD%D0%B5%D1%85%D1%83%D0%B9-%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BB%D0%B0%D1%82%D1%8C-425244.jpeg


to 2015 Bionicle

the_legend_begins_again_by_andrewnuva199-d827pf9.jpg

Almost (read: almost) worth the price.

EDIT: though Kopaka's mask redesign is Terra Bull
 
The tolerancing in 3d printers, at least for amateurs, isn't good enough for interlocking LEGO.

This is exactly the limiting factor. The tolerances achieved by Lego over the years would make even some aerospace companies jealous, and the consistency in those tolerances mean that old pieces work as well as new ones. 3D printers just don't have the resolution necessary to make pieces to the required tolerance. Will they someday? Certainly, but we're talking years from now.
 
Can you build a 3d printer FROM Lego blocks?

A very crude one maybe.

The current problem with the "printer that makes itself" is that there are certain electronic components necessary for all 3D printing techniques at the moment. You can print an enclosure or a shaft or a gear but not a working servomotor
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom