Their Sega Rally score seems odd. Based on their typical reviews, scores of 6 and 7 are a VERY bad thing...yet the text doesn't convey that feeling. OK, so the visuals aren't up to next-gen machines, the career mode sounds a bit simple, and the load times a bit long (how long, I wonder?)...but the driving model sounds fine and the classic tunes are there. It sounds like there are no real complaints in regards to the core gameplay.
It could still turn out to be a good game. It almost seems like they just didn't care about it. Like it was some random Simple 2000 game or something...