• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Favorite Ben & Jerry's flavor?

Status
Not open for further replies.
jimmy-fallon-unveils-new-tonight-show-inspired-ben-jerry-s-ice-cream-flavor.png


Yea, this is basically the best new flavor.
 
Core is just a way for them to make more profit by giving you less ice cream. The speculoos core I tried last year was delicious though. I just don't eat that much sugar anymore.
 
Cherry Garcia is some of the best ice cream I've ever had.

After seeing this thread I've went to Ben and Jerry's website. It depresses me how many mind blowing flavors that they have that I absolutely want to try, and have no idea where to find them.
 
mr jones said:
Cherry Garcia is some of the best ice cream I've ever had.

After seeing this thread I've went to Ben and Jerry's website. It depresses me how many mind blowing flavors that they have that I absolutely want to try, and have no idea where to find them.
Click to expand...

Target and Wal-Mart have a good selection of flavors but I guess it depends.
 
blackflag said:
Actually it's my favorite too, surprised it's still Target exclusive.
Click to expand...

Definitely. Just now, I ate about a third of a carton of this stuff. Just magnificent. Not sure why they don't expand it to other stores either. It's easily better than all of the other peanut butter ice creams they've released, which is really saying something.
 
mr jones said:
I live in Targetland and I've NEVER seen Raspberry Swirled, Coffee Coffee BuzzBuzzBuzz, or New York Super Fudge Chunk. I'd seriously buy those every week.
Click to expand...

The coffee and super fudge are gas station/convenience store staples. I only ever see them in that sort of place.
 
This was one of my favorites while it was around. Thankfully I stocked up my freezer before they disappeared. I still have a few left.

JFtF6c4l.jpg
 
this thread makes me sad. in Canada we only have a handful of flavors most of which are just slight variations of each other.
 
It used to be Chubby Hubby but it's not as good since they changed the pretzels. Phish Food has always been up there. I haven't had the chance to try a lot of the newer flavors, though.
 
big_z said:
this thread makes me sad. in Canada we only have a handful of flavors most of which are just slight variations of each other.
Click to expand...

Yeah, I've started noticing this myself after Safeway has thrown them into the Monday deals. You basically have a bunch of chocolate ice creams with various nuts and fudge and caramel/toffee thrown in, or different flavours of cookie dough.

Last two I tried were If I Had 1,000,000 Flavours and New York Super Fudge Chunk. They were good, but way too much crap thrown in them and not enough ice cream.
 
I got the cherry garcia the other day and enjoyed it. I like chocolate flavor in small volume and not when it's overwhelming, that's one of the reasons why I didn't get the half baked flavor. Anyone got any flavor recommendations that has no chocolate/fudge or very little of it? I was thinking of op's milk and cookies and the banana split. I got the cheesecake flavor before.
 
I tried the Peanut Butter Core the other day. It was good, but not as good as Salted Caramel Core. Peanut butter cookie chunks in it were bland.
 
Can't say I'm feeling the love for American dream. It's alright but the waffle pieces don't taste as great as the doughs in Tonight and Milk and Cookies. And somehow it manages to be even worse for you than the other ice creams in terms of sfat and calories.
 
I can't believe nobody has posted this one yet.

Strawberry Cheesecake was my front runner for a long time until I tried this, and now it's a very hard decision between the two for First place.

This is SO freaking good. If you haven't tried it yet- go do yourself a favor and go get some, right now. XD
BoomChocolatta_closed.png
 
Peanut Butter Cup.

Peanut Butter Ice cream and loads of peanut butter cups? And *not* in chocolate ice cream either? Legendary :D

Then again, I've yet to try many other flavors. Eventually :3
 
Chunky Monkey gets my vote.

But I'm itching to try that Cookies & Milk one or the Karamel Sutra flavor given the responses in this thread.
 
To be honest, I'm not a fan of the CORE flavors.

Yesterday I bought the Salted Caramel CORE. We'll see how it works out. But, previously there just hasn't been enough of the "core" part, leaving the rest of the ice cream a bit too plain considering how dense the flavors usually are.

I typically just prefer the caramel, fudge, cookies, or other fillings to be swirled in. That way you get a pretty consistent scoop. Even if you try to parse out the "core" you still kind of lose out on that consistency in the end.
 
Rash said:
To be honest, I'm not a fan of the CORE flavors.

Yesterday I bought the Salted Caramel CORE. We'll see how it works out. But, previously there just hasn't been enough of the "core" part, leaving the rest of the ice cream a bit too plain considering how dense the flavors usually are.

I typically just prefer the caramel, fudge, cookies, or other fillings to be swirled in. That way you get a pretty consistent scoop. Even if you try to parse out the "core" you still kind of lose out on that consistency in the end.
Click to expand...

usually scoop out the core so that there is always little bit of it to mix with the rest of the ice cream. The core is too strong on its on, so it seems like theres just enough to scoop out a bit and kinda mix it all up then.

Caramel core is amazin
 
Hi again! So I did as suggested and wrote a complaint about the cookie core (or rather, lack thereof) and got a letter with coupons in the mail which was nice. Used it to get this:

iZ5mgJX.jpg
Click to expand...

I'm not an ice cream dude - I prefer hot desserts - but OMFG this is amazing. MUCH better than my cookie core experience. Even though I love speculoos cookie butter, there was so little of it and the vanilla ice cream was really bland. That said this cheesecake ice cream is damn good and the brownie chunks just melt in your mouth.
 
My all time favorite was Wavy Gravy. The bastards stopped making it like 15-20 years ago. I forget what flavor the ice cream was, it might have just been vanilla. But it had these layers of of caramel swirled through it. And some kind of nuts. All I really remember is that I couldn't get enough of it.

Askani said:
Same. The price point is ridiculous so I don't buy it.
Click to expand...

You get what you pay for maing.
 
I swear this thread pops into my head every time I pass the frozen aisle

Picked one up that I hadn't seen before today, took a quick taste test and yep that's good stuff.

FullSizeRender.jpg
 
samsveds said:
Cookie Dough always, every time! The one with bananas and chocolate is good too, was it chunky monkey? Don't really remember the name.
Click to expand...
Was Chunky Monkey but they have a Bob Marley themed one out at the moment called Satisfy my Bowl. Same thing I think, just chocolate peace signs.
 
Every time I see one of these junk food threads I literally cry at the amount of flavours of everything the US has compared to the UK. That tonight dough flavour looks game changing.

I am going to starve myself for a month before I go to America again.
 
Why do I always come into these food threads when I'm low on food/cash in between paychecks? Lol

I've always heard that phish food is good, but looking through this thread karamel sutra, and americone dream look pretty choice as well.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

whats the best tasting sparkling water flavor
25
498
mopspear replied
Melon cream bun recalled over foul odor after durian flavor mix-up
26
610
Miyazaki’s Slave replied
Matt Damon & Ben Affleck on Rogan
2
52
1K
Toots replied
Your favorite monster as a kid?
2
92
674
roosnam1980 replied
Your favorite Bond girls?
2
53
1K
navii replied
Top Bottom