beelzebozo said:
that list seems pulled straight from a film school syllabus. where's the personal touch? where is your idiosyncratic admiration for a director that other people are largely indifferent to? i mean, it's like, i can tell you that i like orson welles, but it tells you so little about my particular film tastes. particularly when you like ALL the classics which as i say seem pulled from a "good directors" list.
I was largely going for directors that pretty much anybody could agree with as a means of pointing out that there's really nothing wrong with my taste, rather evidently. Is a list really going to give you a sense for my personal relationships to those films, though? Plenty of people like a lot of random directors, but without explication, it doesn't necessarily tell you anything about a person's tastes. Still, Woody Allen and Werner Herzog and especially James Cameron are not necessarily film school choices, so I fail to see how the list is lacking in personality completely.
My random admirations tend to be more for individual films that for directors' overall filmographies: "Forbidden Planet," "Children Shouldn't Play with Dead Things," "Speed Racer," "You, the Living," "Trainspotting," "Shoot the Piano Player," "Before Sunrise" and "Before Sunset," and so on. I generally dig old B science fiction movies, westerns, and noirs, and I love to veg out with a good stupid comedy sometimes (such as Zoolander and Wayne's World, which I know you are a big fan of).
I don't actually think all of the classics are good, as well, which I think is also a valuable tool for getting to know a person. Film-GAF has long been pestering me over the fact that I think Hitchcock and Godard are overrated, which I think speaks to something of me (though I could defend such on less personal grounds, as well).
I guess I just feel like I'm stuck in a corner, here. If I say that Spielberg's not a very good director, I get called a snob with poor taste. If I list a bunch of directors I admire and demonstrate that I very clearly don't have poor taste (though I do hate discussions of "taste" when it comes to the subject of criticism), I get called a snob again and accused of waving some sort of film dick around when I'm just responding to an insult that somebody lobbed at me! I go into threads and express admiration for Spider-Man 2, the first two Terminator movies, Alien and Aliens, Batman Begins, Speed Racer, and a hell of a lot of other Hollywood blockbusters while simultaneously shutting down a number of "artsy" directors who I haven't seen produce anything of real value (such as Lars von Trier), yet people still think I'm some pretentious asshole when, in fact, that is simply not the case. I think I'm a good film critic, but that's not the same thing at all.