• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

GAF, is the Gear VR worth it?

Peterthumpa

Member
I'm almost pulling the trigger on a Rift but never tried VR before. Is it safe to say that the Gear VR is a cheap alternative to make my decision easier (or maybe even change it) or is it a lot inferior to the Rift making such comparison useless?
 
It's serviceable but Vive and Rift will obviously be much higher quality. Though in think there is an app called VRidge that lets you play Oculus games on your Gear
 
I've got a Gear VR and a Vive and I'd say pass on the gear. It's novel, but you'll tire of it quickly I think. I used it for a few days and never picked it up again. I'd say let your first VR experience be a top of the line one.
 
If you already have a compatible Samsung phone and the 100 dollar price tag won't break you then you really can't go wrong.
 
It is fucking dope if you consider the fact that it's portable and it actually does a good job at displaying 3D content that matches your head rotation. Where it falls apart compared to the Rift (and Vive) is the lack of positional tracking. If you're used to the depth cues from parallax it's kind of hard not to miss it, plus no leaning in or backing away from whatever is in your view. Even the limited tracking cone of the DK2 was enough to show the difference between observing a space and occupying a space.

Tl;Dr If you're not used to tracked VR the GearVR is pretty sweet. Even if you are used to tracked VR the GearVR is still pretty fun. Certainly beyond the Google cardboard shit.
 
I think the Gear VR is awesome. It's a great entry level experience into VR, if you have a capable phone.
 
Do you have a GS6 or better? Definitely. Buy it, play around for a few hours, sell it and buy a Vive. The hardware will sell you on the promise of VR, and you can move on to even better experiences.

I actually bought a used GS6 just to have the hardware lying around. It's a really neat piece of tech, and really easy to toss in a bag for showing friends, long flights, etc. I also love how much effort Carmack has put into the concept.
 
I think if you're interested in the tech, it's probably more than serviceable. It'll also be the one with the most content from my understanding. Now whether you consider it meaningful content is debateable. I don't think you'll get the same feeling of "presence" or "immersion" as the Vive, but I imagine it probably hits close enough to satisfy the general public. It's a low cost entry and I'd say if you have the interest and the means, go for it.
 
For the price? 100% yes.
 
I tried it in a Samsung shop in London and was so underwhelmed it threw my entire anticipation for VR in the gutter.

Immersed? I felt nothing more than I was looking at a smartphone from three inches away with some tracking attached.

One of the following is true... either:
Gear VR isn't real VR
The demo I had was totally borked, or
VR is utter crap.

Hoping it was the second one, but...
 
I've only really played around with the note 4 version before and I thought the cinema app was neat. It was too blurry though since I could not wear my glasses together with the headset :(
 
Get the real thing. Getting a shoddy cheap alternative will make you sour on VR as a whole. That's exactly what happened to me.
 
I have the Gear VR. It's amazing for porn, which is the only thing I use it for. Sadly, it has completely soured me on VR for games and non-porn video. I was originally stoked for PSVR, but not anymore.
 
It's pretty nice as an intro to VR but my phone(Note 4) overheats super fast so you can't play very long
 
Not only is the entry price very low and the performance surprisingly high (I thought it was going to be nothing more than an attempt at a gimmick that only sort of worked like VR, but the immersion is rich and the visual quality can be quite high for just being a cellphone split in half,) but my guess is that you might use Gear VR on a regular basis more than Oculus or Vive or PSVR ... if VR ever amounts to anything.

Having it be as simple as slapping your phone into a headset and go is wonderful, versus every other solution where you have to clear out a standing space and wire up your head and check your wireless controllers for battery and make sure you never step out of the sensor spot. The hassle of VR in first-gen PC/Console iterations feels like something I'd never use but for only AAA amazing experiences, whereas Gear VR. I'd pull out and slap together whenever I heard a cool 360 Youtube video was out or when a neat game was getting buzz five minutes checking out. Even the controller is right there on the side of the gadget; you can get so much done with that one little touch-button. The wireless, sensorless experience is VR for me, and all of these big devices we're getting are half-steps.

But how much will you actually use Gear VR? Not sure. It didn't convince me it was something I couldn't live without, though I didn't check out nearly enough good software for it. I started to feel that every game was going to be about looking at something and clicking on it, be it a shooter or a puzzler or what have you. And the limitations are there, it's still only as powerful as a phone (and the resolution may bother you, though for my eyesight the crosshatching went away with time.) More complex VR implementation give you more body awareness and more sensors to detect motion and action, and as the sense increases, the experience improves dramatically (...until you step out of the Lighthouse's sensor space and the game grinds to a halt because the controller is out of camera range.)

I think board games especially will be awesome with Gear VR. I played the RTS Tactera, and though the demo had general point-and-click simplicity, it seems awesome to have the landscape laid out in front of you. Relaxing VR games that you can play on your couch like strategy games (especially online with friends, getting to each other through voice chat and avatar representation) could be strong on Gear VR. Racing might also be a lot of fun (provided you get a controller.) Top-down games where you're just looking at the gameplay from your own angle (like Lucky's Tale, though that's too high-spec for Gear VR) may suck you in more than you think. Being in a set space really offered long-term experience that may be Gear VR's specialty; you don't have to go anywhere in the VR world to enjoy it, in fact having just a little game space that you recognize as you sit in it may be just as much fun and may be something you'd spend more time doing since it serves a recognizable purpose. I don't always want to be "immersed in an intense world of enchantment" for hours on end; Gear VR has a wow-factor, but it also works really well for the short bits of time where you just want to kick back for a bit and play a game or check out something cool.
 
Echoing the sentiment in this thread, it's pretty good for VR porn, decent for non-porn 3D videos/photos, and meh for anything else. Get it if you're interested in VR porn or looking for something you can demo to other people without having to sit them in front of your computer.
 
I have a Gear for my Note 4.

After I put a fan on the front of it (And set the brightness to minimum), I can run it till my 10,000MaH battery dies without it overheating.

Like all the VR platforms, there's not much content, but I quite like it.

Gunjack is cool, Smash Hit is amazing.
Minecraft just released its VR version, if that's something that might interest you.
 
99$ isn't so easy on the wallet.
A month ago every Galaxy S7 came with a GearVR for free, they just keeping giving it away.

Now every Galaxy S7 purchase comes with a 10$ GearVR offer. If it's the case then go for it!

For 99$ i have a harder time recommending it, though i only saw a brief demo with it so my experience is lacking.
 
It's pretty amazing if you get a Bluetooth controller with it. The games that don't utilize a controller are gimmicky. But there are some amazing experiences with one. Dreadhalls, and Mine craft in particular.
 
Honestly just get a google cardboard if you want to try low rent VR. Cardboard and Gear have more in common with each other than either does with real VR like Oculus / Vive.
 
I think most people here that are disregarding gear haven't used it the way it's meant to be used. With a controller there are many amazing apps that really give a real sense of what vr is about. Most people who grab the gear never bother buying a controller so they experience a limited library of software without much to do.
 
Gear VR is great for showing off VR quickly and easily to friends or family. They literally just hold it up to their face and it works, no cords or computers or etc. But on a personal use level it's pretty limited. There's a few great games (Smash VR, Adventure Time) but not enough to justify the $100 price tag. You could probably just get a google cardboard for a few bucks that fits your phone and try some of the google apps in 3d. The quality is pretty decent for such a cheap investment.
 
I've used my friend's Gear VR with a S6 and the Assassin's Creed video experience thing was awesome. Can't see too many uses for it outside porn but the price is right if you already have the phone.
 
VR isn't doing it for me. You can't just jump in and play. There is such a routine you've got to get into just to have a game session.
 
I've used my friend's Gear VR with a S6 and the Assassin's Creed video experience thing was awesome. Can't see too many uses for it outside porn but the price is right if you already have the phone.
I've been playing minecraft exclusively on it since it came out.
I played a ton of minecraft before but going back to non vr seems like a big step down.
 
It's fantastic for the price,it's obviously not going to compete with Rift or Vive.But it's a great entry point,there's quite a few decent apps and games you can experience right now.
 
Don't bother OP with the lesser options (smartphone). The experience isn't comparable. The jump from cardboard to Vive for me was immense. Save your money and buy the Rift when you can.
 
Don't bother OP with the lesser options (smartphone). The experience isn't comparable. The jump from cardboard to Vive for me was immense. Save your money and buy the Rift when you can.

To be fair, Gear VR is much better than Google Cardboard too.
 
Top Bottom