• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

GAFBusters - Are gun standoffs rational?

Status
Not open for further replies.

ant_

not characteristic of ants at all
It's a classic movie scene, the bad guy and the good guy both have guns drawn on each other. In a more interesting situation, the bad guy has his gun pointed at a third target - usually someone of interest to the good guy. The situation doesn't matter, it just has to be a gun standoff.

Main question is - Why don't they just shoot?

Say the good guy just shoots at the bad guy, will the bad guy have a quick enough reaction time to even shoot back/shoot the hostage? Usually in these scenarios they are maybe 20-30ft away from each other. And usually in these scenarios NIETHER of them shoot. This has always bugged me.

Let's get some stats in here -

Average speed of bullet - 320 m/s
Average reaction time of a human - 0.2 - 0.25 seconds
In 0.2 seconds, a bullet will travel about 64 meters, or 209 feet.

WHY DON'T THEY JUST SHOOT, GAF?
 
mexican-standoff.jpg
 
Unless there is a a good sniper, it is some what realistic. What most people dont take into account is the fact that, not many people are going to be able to shoot a handgun and hit the intended target who is hiding behind a hostage at that great of a distance. Meanwhile the bad guy literary has a gun to the side of the target at a "cant miss" distance.
 
Good guy doesn't trust his aim to hit the bad guy and not the 3rd target. Bad guy does not ultimately want to harm the 3rd target to that extent.
 
Because:
A) in that situation most will not do the calculation in their head
B)In a life-or-death scenario, even a 98% chance you'll survive is not good enough.
 
In a movie, usually not. In real life, brandishing a weapon is a warning so it makes sense when it happens to people who are pissed off but not angry enough to kill someone.
 
I find it most annoying when one person has a gun drawn, has the other guy dead in his aim at near point blank range, and he allows person 2 to draw a gun or knife or punch him in response.

Movie/television logic is broken. Most people (cops especially) will gun your ass down if you reach for anything when they have a gun drawn on you, itchy trigger fingers are much more common than steely resolves.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom