ZeroGravity
Member
The game explicitly told them to burn the gift.
The game also explicitly says it's optional. So is it or isn't it? Is the game lying?"If I were you I would throw that present in the fire..." and "Optional: Destroy 1 gift" are pretty explicit
You could see them trying multiple times to destroy the gift, so they did know what they were doing, but the game holds them back because apparently the prompt to destroy it flashes by so quickly they missed it. Hell I did too, and wouldn't have noticed if I hadn't seen a screencap of it. I can't exactly fault them here - they did just about everything an average gamer would do in this situation to try and progress; the game held them back.