First of all, any game reviewer taking issue with the politics expressed by the game they are reviewing and critisizing said aspects kinda makes me raise an eyebrow.
That said, the only thing verifiable about their not so flattering opinion of this game is their snipe on the graphics. They are worse than PDZ? First of all, the graphics were not a short coming of PDZ. Unless you want to jump on its art style, which is about the most subjective part of a game's graphics as you could get, PDZ had amazing textures, a solid frame rate and generally looked pretty impressive for a launch title. From what I've seen of AoT, it looks like a somewhat nice looking 2nd gen 360 title. Nothing outstanding. Nothing to scoff at. I can't see what he's talking about here that makes this game so disgusting looking. *shrugs*
Suffice to say, I think I'll be waiting for more credible sources before I totally write this one off.