Support NeoGAF

[IbizaPocholo]

A commentated playthrough of Ghouls 'n Ghosts.

Summary

• 00:01–02:39: The commentary introduces Ghouls 'n Ghosts (1988) and explains several hidden mechanics, including deterministic chest contents, armor-dependent item patterns, and why the game's seemingly "unfair" rewards actually encourage learning through repeated play rather than random chance.
• 02:39–06:42: The presenter praises the game's exceptional pacing, noting that each stage constantly introduces new enemies, set pieces, and mechanics instead of reusing content excessively. They criticize deceptive elements like collapsing rope bridges while highlighting memorable encounters such as Red Arremer (Red Armor) and the vertical elevator sequence inspired by shoot-'em-ups.
• 06:42–10:56: Arthur's rigid jump physics are defended as an intentional design choice that enables precise mid-air aiming. The discussion also examines invisible chest triggers, arguing that while they rewarded discovery in arcades through shared player knowledge, they reduce replayability because they rely on memorization rather than readable level design.
• 10:56–15:52: Boss design, especially Omay, is praised for rewarding strategy over reflexes. The video explores Red Armor's sophisticated AI, discusses what constitutes "fairness" in difficult games, and concludes that although Ghouls 'n Ghosts contains randomness, it remains consistently beatable on a single credit by highly skilled players.
• 15:52–18:29: The commentator argues that the game's delayed punishment system—where mistakes often have consequences several seconds later—is central to its appeal, forcing players to think ahead rather than react instantly. The infamous second loop is presented as an arcade feature that extended value for skilled players instead of simply padding difficulty.
• 18:29–20:51: One overlooked innovation is the introduction of slopes, which were technically demanding for 2D platformers of the era. The speaker explains the programming challenges involved and notes that Yuji Naka studied the Mega Drive port's slope implementation, knowledge that later influenced Sonic the Hedgehog.
• 20:51–27:30: The second loop introduces the Psycho Cannon, a powerful weapon that changes combat dynamics. The commentary also examines enemy design, arguing that intelligent enemies with multiple behaviors create richer gameplay than simple moving hazards, while praising the game's humorous presentation (such as Arthur's boxer shorts) for making failure feel less frustrating.
• 27:30–30:31: The scoring system is criticized for exploitable loopholes that undermine score competition. Modern rewind features are also criticized, with the argument that they diminish the game's intended emphasis on foresight and learning rather than undoing mistakes after the fact.
• 30:31–34:41: The ending reflects on Ghouls 'n Ghosts as one of the finest games of the 1980s, praising its refined mechanics, remarkable variety, and lasting game design. The presenter concludes that its challenge, humor, and thoughtful systems remain impressive nearly four decades later, finishing with a humorous confession that the entire commentary was recorded while wearing only underwear.

 

[Disco Dave]

Thanks for the post bro. I love videos like this that give a glimpse at the mechanics behind the game. Ars Technica have a "War Stories" series that delves into video game development and overcoming technical hurdles. The article on Crash Bandicoot is fantastic and worth a watch

 

[NeoIkaruGAF]

What is this "Red Armor" nonsense? The story goes that "Arremer" is a western rendition of "Arima", the last name of a Capcom employee who allegedly looked like the Red Arremer.

I always hated the way GnG determines what's in a chest. So many magicians just in the first level.

 

[Holammer]

Pretty good commentary with a worryingly sexy narration, even if it's a guy recording it in his underwear.
Lots of interesting tidbits like how Yuji Naka wanted to work on the Megadrive port because of the then innovative slopes in the game.
24:57 mentions an interview with Tokuro Fujiwara where he said they deliberately avoided having zombies in the game because they turned into a common enemy type in other games. Ironic as he would later produce Resident Evil.