• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Giant Bomb GOTY 2014 - Destiny Has Brought Us Here

I'm loving the discussions but Alex is talking disproportionately. Like dominating all the conversation. I only listen to the Bombcast really so I don't have any context for who he is but I wish the core Bombcasters (Jeff, Brad, Patrick, Vinny, Dan I guess) we're talking the most.
 
I don't know if it's just me but the discussion/nominees/arguments this year all feel kind of weak and uninspired in comparison to previous years.

Too many cooks perhaps, or maybe the year was just pretty boring, even by non-giant bomb standards.
 
Yeah, Alex really is speaking a ton. I'm normally an Alex hater, so I thought I was just imagining it during Day 1, but even during Day 2 he just comments after almost everyone's comments.
 
Gotta say the skits this year are the best they've ever done. More gold today.

Also I don't think mordor should have been consider for best debut.
 
I don't know if it's just me but the discussion/nominees/arguments this year all feel kind of weak and uninspired in comparison to previous years.

Well this year was probably the worst year since I got back into gaming in 2006. A million people throw the "you have to expand your tastes" defense out but if you have to do it that often with many people it just shows that many audiences were underserved this year. Even the smaller games were sub par in aggregate in my opinion.

For me the only saving graces this year were The Thalos Principle and Bayonetta 2 on the big side and 80 Days on the small side.
 
I'm loving the discussions but Alex is talking disproportionately. Like dominating all the conversation. I only listen to the Bombcast really so I don't have any context for who he is but I wish the core Bombcasters (Jeff, Brad, Patrick, Vinny, Dan I guess) we're talking the most.

Alex is just as much of a "Bombcaster" as all the others. He's fine.
 
Alex can articulate a point well and he's way less negative / smarmy than he used to be, I enjoy his arguments and am glad he got his portion of the conversation.
 
I'm loving the discussions but Alex is talking disproportionately. Like dominating all the conversation. I only listen to the Bombcast really so I don't have any context for who he is but I wish the core Bombcasters (Jeff, Brad, Patrick, Vinny, Dan I guess) we're talking the most.

Alex does the most reviews and therefore plays the most games. He has the most to say.
 
Alex can articulate a point well and he's way less negative / smarmy than he used to be, I enjoy his arguments and am glad he got his portion of the conversation.

Yeah, I haven't really even noticed that Alex is dominating the conversation, if that's something he's doing.
 
Alex is just as much of a "Bombcaster" as all the others. He's fine.

I didn't mean for that to sound mean - I guess he's just not registered in my brain as much as the others. I'm terrible for putting names to voices but I know and recognise all the others easily. Either way he talks too much.
 
I'm listening to the second day of the GOTY podcasts - at what time approximately does the story discussion end? I'd like to avoid spoilers.
 
I didn't mean for that to sound mean - I guess he's just not registered in my brain as much as the others. I'm terrible for putting names to voices but I know and recognise all the others easily. Either way he talks too much.

If you consumed more of GiantBomb's content, besides just the Bombcast, then you'd have a much better grasp on the whole crew. He doesn't talk too much.
 
I'm listening to the second day of the GOTY podcasts - at what time approximately does the story discussion end? I'd like to avoid spoilers.

54.20

Just checked out Jeff and Samantha Kalman's lists.

Apparently a lot of people skipped out on DA Inquisition this year.

It's an extremely long Bioware RPG, the third in a series. I think people overestimate the interest in that game. Also, I'm getting more and more bummed out the more I play DA: I, there's just so many boring quests and I don't really like the main story :( Maybe I should install Baldur's Gate 2 again.
 
Loving the giant bomb coverage of goty. I really wish I liked Mordor more because seeing it so high on everyone's list makes me feel like a horrible person.
 
Did not expect to see Final Fantasy XIV represented in any way. Xavier Woods would've made me a fan for simply including it, but putting it as his #1 was completely unexpected and amazing. I think I'm in love.
 
54.20



It's an extremely long Bioware RPG, the third in a series. I think people overestimate the interest in that game. Also, I'm getting more and more bummed out the more I play DA: I, there's just so many boring quests and I don't really like the main story :( Maybe I should install Baldur's Gate 2 again.

No, I agree with you, the campaign has issues. But in this weak year, it still does enough right things to earn a spot on a top 10 list.
 
Only people that would be willing to fight for it are Patrick and Alex and Alex holds literally no sway over GOTY discussions. Patrick will sell it out if they offer him Alien: Isolation in the top ten in a heartbeat.

There's also Jason but beyond those 3 I can't see anyone else supporting it for GOTY so I don't see it winning, it'll probably be second place on the list.
 
I remember Alex saying he was a bit frustrated last year doing it over Skype and feeling like it was hard to voice his opinions, so maybe he's just making up for that.

His arguments have been pretty sound so far, in my opinion.
 
Only people that would be willing to fight for it are Patrick and Alex and Alex holds literally no sway over GOTY discussions. Patrick will sell it out if they offer him Alien: Isolation in the top ten in a heartbeat.
Alex was the one who kept on pushing for Last of Us for GOTY. sure he lost battles (Mario 3D World) but he won the freaking war last year.
 
I'm listening to the second day of the GOTY podcasts - at what time approximately does the story discussion end? I'd like to avoid spoilers.

If you haven't played Alien Isolation, skip when they talk about it in the Day 3 podcast, unfortunately can't tell you the exact minute.
 
The Day 3 recap video might be one of the best videos done for goty. I really enjoyed Jason's segment and the entirety of SingStar. I might need to go download it now.
 
Top Bottom