I GET IT. I TOTALLY GET IT NOW.
Now I realize the thread is hundreds of pages long and I know that probably all of what I'm saying has been touched on at least in parts, but I've been pondering this for a bit after checking out a couple pages and from my own first hand experience and knowledge of psychology. I might be Captain Obvious to some but it may be helpful to others to really see the whole picture, plus I just want to really synthesize this revelatory analysis into words for the sake of it.
People dig confident individuals. Not just girls, everyone. You want a job? Be confident. That is the running theme of this thread, and its probably been stated a 1.54 bajillion times. I don't know I've read maybe less than five pages. So to get in with a girl you have to be confident. Confidence is what eludes the helpless individuals.
I was thinking about this because I want to ask out the cute waitress at a new Japanese restaurant in town. My pal and I went there and she was very sociable and even told us when we could come back in and see her again. My friend said she was paying more attention to me than him, and when we went back yesterday, she was indeed playful and more focused on me. So I've decided that I am going to go back next week and ask this girl out. I talked to a friend of mine and asked him for any advice or suggestions, and as expected he said to just go for it. I explained to him that my natural inclination towards most things is analysis. I have the ability to act very naturally without thinking, its just depending on the import of the situation I have to fight against that careful and analytical nature.
And thats when it clicked.
The creep lurking around behind it all sabotaging everything is our idea of importance. As I realized this my friend commented along the same line of thought; he asked "And just how important is this to you?" I had just asked myself the very same thing and it was then that I realized, that importance instills fear and undermines confidence. When you place great import on it, and make the consequences important, you can sabotage yourself pretty badly. Many people in this thread looking for help are sabotaging themselves by placing this importance on these situations. The fact of the matter is that asking this girl out isn't important, I have nothing to lose, and she is a just a cute, playful stranger. The inexperienced place great importance on these things, because of just that. Their lack of experience. They don't quite know what they're doing, and they don't know that they'll ever be able to. So they try to learn and invest so much effort that it becomes important. And since it becomes important, they get nervous, and that radiates and interrupts them, and it becomes noticeable and their efforts are thwarted. Because this individual is inexperienced, he is more likely to attribute this failure to himself, whether it is the case or not.
The confident man doesn't sweat it because he is experienced, and he knows that if this doesn't go right its not necessarily because of anything he did, and the next opportunity is right around the corner. Additionally, he is just in general desensitized to the situation.
This is why bdizzle and others says such crude things like "when in doubt whip it out," and may suggest some outlandish things. He may not be literal, but the idea is to get bold, get fucked or get slapped, and get over it. The first time you see a gaping wound or a gorged body you might be squeamish or throw up. The first time your penis is sexually touched you might cream yourself. Inexperience is sensitivity, and sensitivity to a situation makes it difficult to work with. The only way through that is experience. You work in a hospital all day, and you'll become desensitized to blood and gore and such. You masturbate all day and eventually your dick won't care.
You get kicked in the groin all the time and eventually you won't feel it and you'll have a pelvis made of stone. It amazes me how these things work both physically and psychologically.
This is why they also suggest the small exercises to build confidence, like eye contact and the PUA bullshit. Practice, practice, practice. I studied under a professor who's expertise was expertise. He's spent his life studying why people are good at shit, and it always comes down to practice. To become a true expert you need about 10,000 hours deliberate practice or to have practiced over 10 years. And he was a force to be reckoned with in any discussion. He took other professors to task, and was an all around psychology badass. So I'd say he knows what hes talking about.
Anyway, so that's my thoughts for the day. As much as I may understand, doing it is always different. I don't know when that girl works other than lunchtime on Saturdays, so I gotta wait a week before I can make my move. Wish me luck, GAF, I'll let you know how it turns out.
Edit: additional nerdy thoughts/analogies i forgot to include:
Early on in life its ok to be a nervous bumbling fool, like in high school, because odds are the girls don't know wtf they are doing either and they are nervous and bumbling too. But because of the way society has shaped our roles, initiative is on the male most of the time. As a result, girls are forced into those situations more often, and then they're forced to become more experienced as time goes on. With most males, it is a matter of choice, and fear will keep many out of the battle. However, as you level up in other areas of life and find yourself in different situations, you will be an older and more mature person, but possibly behind in that area. Thus when you find yourself in such a situation later on you may be under-leveled to take on that high level monster because you lost your opportunity to grind (no pun intended) back in the beginner's area.