I can't always understand what made people enjoy something to the extent that they did.
i have this game. i've played through it once already, pirated it years ago, and i bought it recently because i played through
DMCV and kept seeing people bring this up. plus i had rewatched the Senator Armstrong speech and found it oddly prophetic in a
MGS2 way. tbh i don't really take the gameplay of these action games that seriously, and whether one has a better combat system than the other isn't really a concern. MGSR has a lot of QTE, it has a lot of button mashing, and the stealth sections suck, but it is still a ton of fun to play, and i love it.
i never thought
MGSR was that hyped tbh, that the parry system was weird and awkward, and yes, people were shitting on Kojima and anything related to Metal Gear years before. was there widespread hype for this game? it seems to me it got a decent reception but wasn't treated as the second coming by most. sure there were a few, there are always fanatics. it seems counter-productive to want to seek those people out for some kind of debate, when they are probably the most biased, most aggressive people to talk with. then again maybe you are looking for arguments, i dunno, that's cool too.
what drew me to the game in the first place? the style. the bad screamo hot topic metal. the OTT presentation. i grew up with
Contra and
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles,
The Revenge of Shinobi, i remember back when games were really weird and pulpy, really stylish, unexpected in a way that TV and movies were not. this made games special to me.
Super Mario Bros. was amazing not just cos it played well, but because of the bizarre & surreal subject matter. here, Raiden is introduced, riding in a limousine with the President, his name, Mr. Lightning Bolt. that is so silly and rad i can't not love it.
MGSR captures this feeling for me, this unashamed, pulpy, hyper 80s action style. it is ninjas. it is robots. it is jumping from missile to missile (something they used to do in
Contra games). there is something inherently cool in the subject matter. it is impossible to explain to a younger generation, like explaining rap to the parents of the 80s, or rock n roll to the parents of the 50s.
DMC has that style too, so OTT. like in
Final Fight, the bonus screen where you destroy a car with your fists in under 60 seconds. i don't care if it's unrealistic or silly. it could be in a Chuck Norris movie or something. it is fucking badass.