Support NeoGAF

[Linkura]

^Milk and Cookies IS a great flavor but unfortunately it's quite rare in my experience. I've only seen it twice and both times I bought it.

I saw it at the grocery store yesterday. Maybe I'll pick it up next time I see it.

 

[Cooter]

Thank me later

 

[TerminalDogma]

Talenti are the best. But my friend, you haven't had their best flavor. Salted Caramel. I've had many, many talenti flavors hoping they'd surpass it, but I've been let down every time.

 

[riotous]

I like salted caramel but I prefer several other talenti flavors over it; cinnamon peach biscuit, banana chocolate swirl, caramel cookie crunch, caramel apple pie and vanilla chai.

Now that I think about it; I haven't had many talenti flavors that I don't like more than salted caramel. That's more of a praise of the brand than a knock on salted caramel; I do think it' the best to get as a secondary scoop to mix with something else.

 

[shadowkat]

Kawartha Ice Cream is godly.

 

[Fuchsdh]

Absolutely nothing beats this:

Oh man I forgot about this stuff. For a while I was downing a crazy amount of it, haha. It's brilliant.

 

[ForsakenLotus]

I've had their coffee ice cream, I think it had some chocolate chips or something, but I remember it being very good. Still like just play Haagen-Dazs coffee ice cream though.

 

[King Mystery]

YOU WILL NEVER EAT THIS ICE CREAM AGAIN, SICKENING RESULTS!

 

[TheFuzz]

I'd like to point out that this thread caused a WrassleGAF Civil War which I naturally won

I hope you're happy

Tip of the cap to you and Wrasselgaf, friend Bronson.

Spoiler

You're still wrong

 

[dragonzdogma]

Is blue bell onlyin texas?
Everyone knows that's the best ice cream.

Tilamook is catching up tho.

 

[Stronginthearm]

I try to not each much ice cream (because I'd eat too much) but my current favourites are the tesco brand cherry and vanilla ice cream and their mint and chocolate ice cream.

 

[eizarus]

Mint ice cream is like sparkling water.
Bad example but yeah I don't ever want to go near that stuff again. I'm happy with my Hagen Daaz Pralines flavour.

 

[zeemumu]

I prefer cookies n cream

 

[MiddeSummer]

Y'all are kidding me.

God-tier. It's Apple Pie a la Mode in a jar. Plus you can wash out the containers and use them to hold knick knacks.

But I'm willing to give that Graeters stuff a try if I ever happen upon it.

 

[p2535748]

I've been wanting to try these but fear they won't be as good as the pint. Opinions?

I know I've already chimed in on this, but I think they're actually better than the pint. First, I think they're the right amount of ice cream for a snack. Second, the shell around is quite good, not completely sweet, and adds a nice contrast against the vanilla ice cream. Third, they're individually wrapped, so you never get that issue of the leftover ice cream getting incredibly hard in the freezer, it's always the perfect consistency. Beyond that, it's just the normal Americone Dream with a thin layer of chocolate, so really what could go wrong?

I mean, to be clear, if you want ice cream straight, just get the pint, but as an ice cream related snack, they're fantastic, IMO.

 

[GoldenEye 007]

This stuff:

Is probably the best ice cream I've had.
It's at least up there. So good.
Edit: Idk what the best flavor is, but the quality is heavenly.

Graeters is pretty damn nice. I had their black raspberry and it was awesome. I usually dislike any sort of fruit related ice cream too.

 

[Hippopuncher12]

This stuff:

Is probably the best ice cream I've had.
It's at least up there. So good.
Edit: Idk what the best flavor is, but the quality is heavenly.

My dude! Cincinnati Ice Cream is best Ice Cream.

 

[eizarus]

I prefer cookies n cream

As someone's who's fasting.... I think you just found my kryptonite

 

[elshoelace]

Where my half baked bois at?

What I get now, that I don't live in an area I can get a half gallon of Blue Bell.

 

[hitme]

This is my local jam, but I think you can also get it in some supermarkets.

It's so damn good.

My dude. Better than Humphrey Slocombe IMO.

 

[Arsenic Yellow]

For people posting halo top, have you tried Enlightened? Very similar macros but much creamier and less "airy". Their birthday cake, mint chocolate chip and chocolate peanut butter are amazing. Blows halo top out of the water.

 

[geomon]

YOU WILL NEVER EAT THIS ICE CREAM AGAIN, SICKENING RESULTS!

I knew it was Breyers. Shit is gross!

 

[water_wendi]

Moose Tracks. They have some weird Dr. Pepper thing going on and have several different manufacturers.

 

[GoldenEye 007]

I knew it was Breyers. Shit is gross!

Didn't they recently change their formulas to basically stop using just simple ingredients? I thought I remember that in the last few years. They can't put ice cream on the box anymore I think.

 

[BumperLips]

Low in calories.
High in brotein.
Not the best tasting, but the best macros.

I recently had the red velvet and thought it was great.
Like that it can get a bit frozen so it doesnt start melting immediately after scooping it out.

Picked up this Ben and Jerry's yesterday. It's great except for the core. It's a little weird. Not too terrible but kind of meh compared to the rest with peanut butter cups.

 

[water_wendi]

YOU WILL NEVER EAT THIS ICE CREAM AGAIN, SICKENING RESULTS!

It doesnt melt? Water separated from it? Mold grew on it? i dont know what i was expecting but it was worse than that.

edit: its funny that i would expect a person that would make that kind of video to also put out videos about how mold doesnt grow on McDonalds beef or fries and claim its unnatural. "THE REGULAR HAMBURGER DECAYS LIKE FOOD SHOULD!"

 

[Reptars Revenge]

Bogo at Publix for Talenti is the best thing ever.

 

[A.J.]

I had this recently and it was super good.

 

[I am Christina Aguilera]

Talenti is really good, but put me down as another voice saying that Turkey Hill's mint chocolate chip (the green kind with the small Baskin-Robbins-style chocolate slivers in particular) is even better:

 

[Fuchsdh]

Didn't they recently change their formulas to basically stop using just simple ingredients? I thought I remember that in the last few years. They can't put ice cream on the box anymore I think.

Some of their products are ice cream, some are frozen dairy desserts because they don't contain enough milk fat to qualify as ice cream in the US. It's not all their products.

 

[Matticers]

These are heavenly.

 

[Stuggernaut]

Even better... go here and eat it.

https://www.google.com/maps/place/T...3b93c57067a899a!8m2!3d45.484531!4d-123.844351

 

[davidwhangchoi]

i like the little brownie in my 99 cent frozen banquet meal. it tastes like ice cream pudding.

 

[soundahfekz]

Cmon OP get on my level

If you don't get cho ass......

 

[Laekon]

Is blue bell onlyin texas?
Everyone knows that's the best ice cream.

Tilamook is catching up tho.

Blue Bell, the brand that knew it's product/facilities were contaminated with listeria for years before an outbreak killed 3 people? Sounds like a brand that would be popular in Texas. Wouldn't want consumer safety getting in the way of a corporations freedom.

 

[hateradio]

Fatty fatty two by four, couldn't fit through the kitchen door

Jerk!

Talenti gelato is legit. Went through a phase where I definitely gained some pounds exploring their line. Really good Mint Chip, agreed. Caramel Cookie Crunch, Caramel Apple Pie and Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip are the truth too.

That looks good. 😥

 

[Falchion]

Talenti's Salt Caramel is really good, never had the mint before.

 

[rokkerkory]

I gained a few lbs reading this thread. Off to the gym i go.

 

[HiResDes]

Does anyone make a good Peanut Butter ice cream? I don't mean like peanut butter chunks or pieces but actual peanut butter flavored ice cream?