-
Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!
Is Sonic Lost World that bad?
- Thread starter Lingitiz
- Start date
It's actually okay. Not that good, but it isn't as bad as some make it out to be. The main problems are the level design in the 2nd half of the game (it's really hit-or-miss) & the boss fights. So in short....
- The Wii U/PC version is somewhat decent. I assume that the PC version has the patch that the Wii U version got, so I'd say it's a 6.5/10.
- The 3DS version, in my opinion, is hot garbage.
NinjaCoachZ
Member
It's a 6/10. It has the potential to be a good game but it's buried by some questionable design choices. As a curiosity it's worth checking out but at the end I found it a frustrating experience because it ultimately could have been so much more than what it was.
FWIW I feel like it's the mid-late portions of the game where things start to fall apart. At the beginning I was thinking it wasn't that bad, but by maybe world 4 was when the exhaustion started to set in.
Also the plot and dialogue are bad even by Sonic standards. Not even ironically bad like Shadow's game or Sonic Riders, it just feels half-assed.
FWIW I feel like it's the mid-late portions of the game where things start to fall apart. At the beginning I was thinking it wasn't that bad, but by maybe world 4 was when the exhaustion started to set in.
Also the plot and dialogue are bad even by Sonic standards. Not even ironically bad like Shadow's game or Sonic Riders, it just feels half-assed.
Jonneh3003
Banned
No it's a very good and an enjoyable platformer. It focuses less on speed and more on actual platforming which is really what I've wanted from a Sonic game since the original Adventure titles. It's heavily influenced by Super Mario Galaxy in it's level design and it's mostly for the better. My only real issue with it is the Deadly Six, they often interrupt levels which not only kills the flow but it also kills replayability.
The Wii U version is the one to go for as the Zelda and Yoshi levels are pretty special. It's a great game regardless as long as you know that there's a run button (certain reviews didn't seem aware in their video reviews).
The Wii U version is the one to go for as the Zelda and Yoshi levels are pretty special. It's a great game regardless as long as you know that there's a run button (certain reviews didn't seem aware in their video reviews).
Jonneh3003
Banned
I loved Act 2 where you roll around in a giant snowball. Was a really fun change of gameplay.
This, it's just a fun game.
I will say that Sky Road Zone 2 is one of the more stand-out levels from the 2nd half of the game.
Jonneh3003
Banned
Were controls really a bad part for you? I found them pretty precise and the level design seems aware of the advantages and disadvantages of the control scheme. The parkour system could have done with a tutorial or some forced explanation but it's not hard to pull off when you know how.
It isn't bad as Boom or Sonic 06 but it's nowhere near as good as Generation as the game has far too many problems like
-Needing to hold down the run button to make Sonic run, this makes jumping in the 2D section a pain as there is no build up in speed it's either slow or fast.
-The tubular level design just doesn't gel well Sonic's "speed"
-Parkour isn't taught well nor do any level take advance of it till the final world
-Some level just recycle levels designs.
-The grinding level is just annoying
-The Snowball level is mega annoying
-The game is less of a Sonic game and is more of a New Super Mario Bros game.
-The story is not well explain,
-Wisp are underused and just shoehorned in for no good reason. Nor are they explained why they are back.
-Ice staking in the snow level is annoying.
-Sonic is weaker in this game.
So if you're looking for a fast pace Sonic game you won't find it in Lost Worlds, it's a slow pace game with the gameplay just screeching to a halt at times.
Personally I say just pass on the game.
Meh, I only liked 3 songs throughout the entire game.
-Needing to hold down the run button to make Sonic run, this makes jumping in the 2D section a pain as there is no build up in speed it's either slow or fast.
-The tubular level design just doesn't gel well Sonic's "speed"
-Parkour isn't taught well nor do any level take advance of it till the final world
-Some level just recycle levels designs.
-The grinding level is just annoying
-The Snowball level is mega annoying
-The game is less of a Sonic game and is more of a New Super Mario Bros game.
-The story is not well explain,
you don't find out what Lost Hex is or what the Zeti are or what happen to them after you defeat them.
-Wisp are underused and just shoehorned in for no good reason. Nor are they explained why they are back.
-Ice staking in the snow level is annoying.
-Sonic is weaker in this game.
So if you're looking for a fast pace Sonic game you won't find it in Lost Worlds, it's a slow pace game with the gameplay just screeching to a halt at times.
Personally I say just pass on the game.
Meh, I only liked 3 songs throughout the entire game.
Mischifer6
Banned
Actually enjoyed the game, believe it or not. There are a few levels that are harder than they should be, due to weird game design, but it's actually pretty good. It's a 7/10 for me.
Its one of the better 3D Sonics on the market.
The game has issues with its level design towards the end and its controls can be hit and miss to some people (Ex: People either love or hate the run button).
But from what I saw of the game, its a good game
.
The visuals look great and pop, the music is great like most Sonic OST's, the core gameplay is a nice mix of SA1 and Sonic Unleashed, the levels look like they were ripped from the Genesis era and a good deal of the level designs are strong.
Its just that after Frozen Factory, the quality starts to drop and as a result, people either start hating the game or feel underwhelmed.
Lava Mountain is a case of a really weak final world for example: one boss rush, a harder version of Tropical Coast Act 3, another boss rush mixed with a platforming level, then a weak final boss (ripped right out of Sonic Colors). That leaves a bad impression but the game as a whole is good.
The game isn't great like Colors or Generations but its still a solid game. In many ways, its like Unleashed if you didn't have the Werehog; you have a game that experiments and tries new things frequently but the games core is still present, not hindered with unneeded gameplay changes. You still get those gimmick levels, but they take up one/two spots for each level.
Overall, Lost World is a good game that has a few issues but due to being a step down from Generations and Colors, people have a harsher tone toward the game.
The game has issues with its level design towards the end and its controls can be hit and miss to some people (Ex: People either love or hate the run button).
But from what I saw of the game, its a good game
.The visuals look great and pop, the music is great like most Sonic OST's, the core gameplay is a nice mix of SA1 and Sonic Unleashed, the levels look like they were ripped from the Genesis era and a good deal of the level designs are strong.
Its just that after Frozen Factory, the quality starts to drop and as a result, people either start hating the game or feel underwhelmed.
Lava Mountain is a case of a really weak final world for example: one boss rush, a harder version of Tropical Coast Act 3, another boss rush mixed with a platforming level, then a weak final boss (ripped right out of Sonic Colors). That leaves a bad impression but the game as a whole is good.
The game isn't great like Colors or Generations but its still a solid game. In many ways, its like Unleashed if you didn't have the Werehog; you have a game that experiments and tries new things frequently but the games core is still present, not hindered with unneeded gameplay changes. You still get those gimmick levels, but they take up one/two spots for each level.
Overall, Lost World is a good game that has a few issues but due to being a step down from Generations and Colors, people have a harsher tone toward the game.
MR ARCADE FOREVER
Member
The enemies are beyond terrible
I'm weird in that I actually preferred the 3DS version, but thats because I enjoyed the variety and more responsive controls.
The Wii U/PC version had controls I hated. They were overcomplicating something which should have been far simpler. (Its Sonic FFS)
They're both still mediocre Sonic titles though. Generations was spot on.
The Wii U/PC version had controls I hated. They were overcomplicating something which should have been far simpler. (Its Sonic FFS)
They're both still mediocre Sonic titles though. Generations was spot on.
FrostuTheNinja
Member
Still my favorite 3D Sonic game by a country mile.
As for trial and error design, is everyone referencing that one stage with
.
Snowball stage is shit, though,
As for trial and error design, is everyone referencing that one stage with
the robot dragons that pop up as the screen scrolls?
Snowball stage is shit, though,
It's been a while, so I'm don't remember the details, but the way he handled and jumped felt really bad, turning, accelerating, keeping momentum, it was all pretty bad. Oh and the lock-on was atrocious. It just didn't feel right and I honestly didn't think the levels were made with it in mind. Parkour was OK I think, nothing special. Oh and those fucking powers, good lord. what a pile of shit.
They fixed the life system at least.
Linkstrikesback
Member
Everything technically works, but it's never makes good use of any of the platforming mechanics and the level design is mostly crap.
Yeah, it's decent but a wasted opportunity. Worth playing and then forgetting about.
Jonneh3003
Banned
It looked pretty damn sharp on Wii U and had Nintendo themed DLC levels for free. I can't imagine it being much better on PC.
For sure, was really disappointing in that regard.
Shotgun Kiss
Member
I played it at a Eurogamer a couple of years ago, and I was left with no desire to ever play it again.
To me, there's little difference between a mediocre game and a shit game. I don't have time for either.
To me, there's little difference between a mediocre game and a shit game. I don't have time for either.
PC version is basically just the Wii U version at higher res, no real major differences visually.
Higher res sounds good though. Does it support 1440p or 4K?
LordOcidax
Member
I like it, a lot. IMO
CaptainLoveline
Member
It's a pretty garbage game, no matter what you play it on. Sluggish mechanics, poor controls and a "me too" planetoid gimmick makes for some bad execution gameplay wise. It hasn't even got anything worthwhile in the story and the soundtrack is meh at best.
Is it the worst game? No, far from it as we've already witnessed with 06 and Boom, but there's significantly better 3D Sonic games already out.
Is it the worst game? No, far from it as we've already witnessed with 06 and Boom, but there's significantly better 3D Sonic games already out.
The Technomancer
card-carrying scientician
Its pretty bad. The controls sort of work well in the first few levels designed around them, but then the level design falls off a cliff
Admiral Woofington
Member
It's a 6/10 scenario. Think Sonic Unleashed.
When the game does something good, the game does it really well. When the game does something bad, holy shit it's BAD.
The good:
The difficulty is pretty high, most of the time it's the good kind.
The music as with most Sonic games is pretty darn good.
Visually pleasing, plenty of variety in the settings.
Level design is mostly consistent.
Parkour system isn't perfect but a nice addition.
The bad:
Wisp powers are shoehorned in pretty badly.
Gimmick levels are terrible (Snowball level, Stealth level)
Some of the worst boss fights in video game history
Forget the story, skip all the cutscenes.
When the game does something good, the game does it really well. When the game does something bad, holy shit it's BAD.
The good:
The difficulty is pretty high, most of the time it's the good kind.
The music as with most Sonic games is pretty darn good.
Visually pleasing, plenty of variety in the settings.
Level design is mostly consistent.
Parkour system isn't perfect but a nice addition.
The bad:
Wisp powers are shoehorned in pretty badly.
Gimmick levels are terrible (Snowball level, Stealth level)
Some of the worst boss fights in video game history
Forget the story, skip all the cutscenes.
Considering how latter patches fixed the former (no more forced motion controls) and the latter can be skipped (like you said), the issues mainly stem from the gimmick levels and the boss fights.
The gimmick stages could be worse (snowball is sorta like Monkey Ball, the flying levels (as odd as they are) could control a lot worse, and the stealth level isn't too bad (as the controls are still the same)) and the boss fights are way too easy (or to hard, with Sky Road Act 4 highlighting how the game badly doesn't explain its mechanics well).
Zomba13
Member
Depends on what is meant by that bad. It's not 06 bad. It's not good though. Daytime Unleashed, Colours and Generations are leagues better than Lost World.
It's nice and colourful though with a nice piece of music or two and the story is actually pretty entertaining. It's was just a chore to play through though. The entire parkour like system didn't really flow and felt clunky and Sonic felt super slow even when holding the "run" button.
Didn't play Boom but out of those listed I'd say it's only better than 06 and Sonic 4 ep1 (and ep2 for that matter).
It's nice and colourful though with a nice piece of music or two and the story is actually pretty entertaining. It's was just a chore to play through though. The entire parkour like system didn't really flow and felt clunky and Sonic felt super slow even when holding the "run" button.
Didn't play Boom but out of those listed I'd say it's only better than 06 and Sonic 4 ep1 (and ep2 for that matter).