Support NeoGAF

[Parallax]

With a few exceptions, New Batman Adventures just seemed like a step down in quality across the board. The animation and character designs weren't as good and the stories weren't that great either. Technically that era of the series did help user in the Worlds Finest animated film - the Batman v Superman we deserved.

Growing pains holds the whole series up. But i agree on the quality taking a hit. I hate what they did with bruce

 

[brawly]

All-Star Batman is best Batman

edit: seems I was late on the joke. Oh well, can't be posted enough.

 

[SpacePirate Ridley]

Yes, TAS is perfect, and not only with Batman, but the majority of the characters and stories. And the best Batman music. Shirley Walker, we miss you
That and the brave and the bold. Although that is more of a silver age Batman, but thats ok for me.

 

[Unspeakable Evil]

I like what Scott has done with the character.
.

Come to think of it. Its kinda sad how we don't see a the Batfamily a lot in more media.

 

[Sephzilla]

Yes.
That and the brave and the bold. Although that is more of a silver age Batman, but thats ok for me.

Brave and the Bold feels like a logical extension of the Adam West universe, and that's 100% okay. Also, Brave and the Bold has the best Aquaman

 

[Zelias]

Yes, absolutely. Some interpretations come close, but TAS Batman is the GOAT.

 

[DrunkShogun]

GOAT cartoon.

Still can't believe Bruce banged Barbara though. One of the oddest things to come out of that universe.

This is still one of the dumbest things they did. Just as dumb as Arkham knight

Spoiler

Tim drake and Barbara

.

 

[SamuelSupreme]

Easily. Theres no questioning it. When I read comics its Hamil and Conroys voices that I hear.

 

[SpacePirate Ridley]

Brave and the Bold feels like a logical extension of the Adam West universe, and that's 100% okay. Also, Brave and the Bold has the best Aquaman

Yup.
Both different Batmans (TAS and BATB) but both are great in their own merits.

 

[SonicMegaDrive]

With a few exceptions, New Batman Adventures just seemed like a step down in quality across the board. The animation and character designs weren't as good and the stories weren't that great either. Technically that era of the series did help user in the Worlds Finest animated film - the Batman v Superman we deserved.

My biggest gripe with the New Adventures (other than the ugly, jarring changes to the character designs) was that it seemed like they sort of 'flattened' the dimensions of the personalities most of it's characters. Where in 'Batman: TAS', the characters, both heroes and villains, seemed more layered and fleshed out and made to be more human, 'The New Adventures' seems to take a few steps back in that regard. I recall an episode where Two-Face was the villain, and he's taken over Gotham's TV stations to announce to the people that he's threatening to spread gas to poison everyone. But at no point in the episode is any of the relationships or character build-up from the previous show mentioned. Like Harvey's friendship with Bruce, his struggles with his duality, or his fiance. He's been reduced to villain-of-the-week status. You could substitute Two-Face for any other gangster and it wouldn't make any difference.

The show is still really good for what it is, but on the whole it just feels really dumbed-down compared to the previous series. I was really disappointed by it when it first aired.

I also really dislike Batman in the show. He's just a grump now. Batman could be grumpy in the old show, but he had so much more personality. I can't see the Batman of 'The New Adventures' featured in "Beware the Gray Ghost", one of my favorite episodes of the original series.

 

[Lights and Waves]

Yes it's the GOAT and true canon of Batman.

 

[The Lamonster]

Yup.
Both different Batmans (TAS and BATB) but both are great in their own merits.

Yup. Both are so damn good and in totally different ways. And yet, both shows feature genuine Batmans; true to the character.

 

[Sephzilla]

I also really dislike Batman in the show. He's just a grump now. Batman could be grumpy in the old show, but he had so much more personality. I can't see the Batman of 'The New Adventures' featured in "Beware the Gray Ghost", one of my favorite episodes of the original series.

Yeah, I actually kind of forgot how cheerful Bruce/Batman can be at times during TAS. Like, he's not afraid to smile once and a while and crack some jokes with Robin. New Adventures Batman feels grumpy and senile in comparison.

 

[Lights and Waves]

GOAT cartoon.

Still can't believe Bruce banged Barbara though. One of the oddest things to come out of that universe.

Tbh I kind of love this and it makes sense. I don't think Bruce is that much older than Barbara in this universe. Once Dick graduated college and it was just Barbara, Tim, and Bruce, it kind of made sense that there'd be some romance there.

 

[NealMcCauley]

GOAT cartoon.

Still can't believe Bruce banged Barbara though. One of the oddest things to come out of that universe.

Growing up I thought it was weird that one of the episodes had Barbara flirting with a just-not-getting-it Bruce, and then in Beyond there was a conversation between her and Terry that confirmed something was going on. Definitely not expected.

 

[SonicMegaDrive]

Yeah, I actually kind of forgot how cheerful Bruce/Batman can be at times during TAS. Like, he's not afraid to smile once and a while and crack some jokes with Robin. New Adventures Batman feels grumpy and senile in comparison.

He feels like a caricature of the old Batman. I remember reading about why they did it in an old issue of Wizard - they thought making Batman monotone and deadpan all the time would make the show 'darker'. Well, it didn't, really. It just made it feel more like a show for kids with less human characters.

 

[Arnie7]

Grant Morrison's and Frank Millers Batman is GOAT.

 

[RangerX]

Nah Dennis O'Brien and Neal Adams Batman run is the best.

 

[Lights and Waves]

Poison Ivy's re-design and the 'Holiday Knights' episode made The New Batman Adventures worth it tbh.

 

[Mengy]

Is TAS version of Batman the best version of Batman?

The simple answer is yes, easily.

 

[SonicMegaDrive]

Nah Dennis O'Brien and Neal Adams Batman run is the best.

I grew up reading the O'Neil/Adams Batman stories. I strongly recommend the TPB 'Tales of the Demon' to everyone. Those were the original comics by Denny O'Neil that were the direct inspiration for the Batman: TAS two-parter, "The Demon's Quest" with Ra's al Ghul.

 

[cr0w]

I'm partial to the Grant/Breyfogle and Starlin/Aparo eras.

Never got into TAS. I'm one of those weird people that can't connect with cartoons, no matter how great they are.

I also have a really big soft spot for the weird ass Moench/Jones era and their callbacks to the EC horror comics. The Scarecrow arc in particular was brilliant.

 

[FyreWulff]

I'm partial to the Grant/Breyfogle and Starlin/Aparo eras.

Never got into TAS. I'm one of those weird people that can't connect with cartoons, no matter how great they are.

Close your eyes and open them every 10 seconds and pretend it's a comic book

 

[Blackage]

seriously

you go from this

to this

what were they thinking

In their defense they also came up with that amazingly badass Scarecrow design.

 

[cr0w]

Nah, I'm good. I didn't even get into cartoons as a kid. They do nothing for me.

 

[blazenumb1]

Of course, easiest question I will answer all day.

TAS is the best version of Batman

Spoiler

and the Joker

in cartoons or the movies.

 

[FyreWulff]

Also, personally, Batman Beyond took a bit to get going but I thought it was a well done bookend on the TAS canon.

And even though it's Terry's show, the episode with Bruce hearing the voices was such a good one for his character.

And then the lazarus pit episode

Spoiler

they had to tug on the strings with the one where Bruce is made young again

 

[Kacho]

Of the different versions of Batman I've been exposed to over the years nothing has come close to matching the tone and execution of TAS. They were able to shift from dark and serious to more lighthearted and fun without it being jarring or distracting. TAS has been the definitive version of Batman in my eyes for two decades. Kevin Conroy's voice is a big part of that.

 

[creatchee]

Best version of Batman.

Best version of Joker.

Best animated series ever.

 

[Slayven]

Flashpoint Joker and Earth 3 Jokester are the GOAT Jokers

 

[SpacePirate Ridley]

Wholeheartedly agree. Beautiful animation and character design, as well as genuinely one of the most faithful adaptations of the character. Still baffles me that they followed this up with a dark-tone CGI thing to even less success.

B:TBAB and Scooby Doo: Mystery Incorporated are two of my greatest cancellation woes.

Scooby Doo Mystery Incorporated wasnt cancelled. It had a sotry ark and an ending. And a rather good ending at that. It was mistreated, but not cancelled.

One of the best Batman TAS scenes.

This warms up my heart.

 

[Shake Appeal]

Grant Morrison's Batman is the best Batman, and it's not close. TAS and its related movies are the best depiction of Batman outside of comic books, though.

 

[thequestion]

GOAT cartoon.

Still can't believe Bruce banged Barbara though. One of the oddest things to come out of that universe.

Yeah I when this was revealed in the cartoon, I felt...weird inside....in a bad way.


Btw what comic is this panel from?

 

[Birbo]

Love TAS. It gave us Mask of the Phantasm, which is by far my favorite Batman movie.

GOAT scenes:

Please. I need it to be different now.

Joker's reaction to his impending death.

First time putting the Bat suit on.

 

[Rooster12]

The whole show is a perfect example imo of how not to do Bats correctly as well. Always getting beat up... almost gets his mask exposed in every other episode. All the villains are now fighting monsters. Penguin knocks out Batman. Penguin! you've never heard a 6 year old and a 32 year old say "Cooooooome ON!!!" in perfect sync like we did.

He does get knocked out/beaten up by random thugs quite often though.

Miller/Morrison/Waid are the ones who tried to change that and instill the Batgod philosphy into the comic world

 

[watership]

The whole Timmverse is many of the best representation of DC heroes I've seen. Superman and Batman for sure. I love their take on Flash/Wally West. Wonder Woman especially is exactly how I love the character. BvS'
wonder woman hurt my brain. "I've shunned the modern world for 100 years and but hey, Bruce Wayne, this file is encrypted" just make my head hurt.

 

[LiK]

Pretty much.

Every character is perfect including the VO. Man, the casting director is a genius.

 

[BKatastrophe]

GOAT cartoon.

Still can't believe Bruce banged Barbara though. One of the oddest things to come out of that universe.

Bruce and Barbara doing the dirty and having an assumedly short attempt at a genuine romantic relationship made sense to me. Getting pregnant, though? That's the dumbest fucking thing there is.

 

[Penguin]

Come to think of it. Its kinda sad how we don't see a the Batfamily a lot in more media.

I think because beyond Dick and Babs, it gets really weird with their origins and background.

Jason dies and comes back to life

Damian is his son... through rape

Steph and Cass are legacy characters

And really just a packed... packed roster for a loner

 

[ViewtifulJC]

Pretty much.

Every character is perfect including the VO. Man, the casting director is a genius.

Andrea Romano is the unsung MVP of so many productions. DCAU, Avatar the Last Airbender, Boondocks....

 

[Bizazedo]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hgWBvRmP1bc
Batman Vs Clayface is so good.

I loved the Clayface episodes.

The music / themes for individual characters are so good, to. Clayfaces is top tier imo.

 

[Parch]

Never got into TAS. I'm one of those weird people that can't connect with cartoons, no matter how great they are.

I'm the opposite. I stopped reading superhero comics because I was constantly disappointed and found animated superhero shows to be considerably more entertaining.

 

[BKatastrophe]

Andrea Romano is the unsung MVP of so many productions. DCAU, Avatar the Last Airbender, Boondocks....

She really is. It'll be upsetting when she retires

 

[Village]

Dick grayson batman is

 

[Cwarrior]

best batman along with justice league batman.

GOAT cartoon.

Still can't believe Bruce banged Barbara though. One of the oddest things to come out of that universe.

Erased this from my memory also, this was super dumb.

 

[Rooster12]

The whole Timmverse is many of the best representation of DC heroes I've seen. Superman and Batman for sure. I love their take on Flash/Wally West. Wonder Woman especially is exactly how I love the character.

Gonna have to watch some episodes again. I don't remember anything significant about WW in the show at all. Even Timm said he didn't quite know what to do with the character.

 

[Kouichi]

Most definitely. Second goes to Brave and the Bold Batman.

 

[slightconfuse]

if we are talking bruce wayne then probalby. morrsions version is up there. but batman in general is the GOAT Dick.

Also best robin

 

[Strangelove77]

I kind of prefer the second/later art style.
It's a style I like. Even the weird Joker eyes/Mr. Peanut Penguin.
I also think all the females got an upgrade. The females were more attractive in that style.

 

[Sweetjebus]

TAS ?