Deus Ex Machina
Member
Good. Now if EA can please stop buying great development studios with original IPs and turn them into EA annually updated PoSs, I would be grateful.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
John Riccitiello steps down as CEO of Electronic Arts. [Resignation/Farewell Letters]
- Thread starter Wario64
- Start date
alexandros
Banned
Only the Dynamic Duo of Cliffy and Arthur can save EA now.
Everyone knows what's going to happen but I don't see why we can't celebrate probably the most hated man in the industry leaving.
Pachter twisting the knife....
So now even his statements are wrong? Not just his predictions?
RumblingRosco
Member
Pachter twisting the knife....
You know, I hate to use an already over-used meme, but fuck, dat ether. The Pach Attack was strong with that response.
Samir Sedlar
Member
I don't know if this is means a better or worse future, I don't know if this will change EA or not, but I truly hope for a return to shape.
I would love to finally see Dante's Purgatory -a sequel to Dante's Inferno- but this time without being a God of War knock off, and being different, there is potential there, and I don't think EA got any other hack n slash titles, right ?!
I would also love to see Dead Space returning to form, focusing more and more on Survival Horror rather than Action Horror, maybe Dead Space will be saved at last.
I wonder if the costumer treatment will change, cause this is a must.
I would love to finally see Dante's Purgatory -a sequel to Dante's Inferno- but this time without being a God of War knock off, and being different, there is potential there, and I don't think EA got any other hack n slash titles, right ?!
I would also love to see Dead Space returning to form, focusing more and more on Survival Horror rather than Action Horror, maybe Dead Space will be saved at last.
I wonder if the costumer treatment will change, cause this is a must.
Sure.
EA present : Battlefield 3
irector's Cut. Now with one more hour for the campaign!
Out this fall, right next to Battlefied 4!(Also not available on Wii U!)
1. Focusing on quality doesn't mean you will like everything.
2. Focusing on quality doesn't mean that they will always succeed.
3. Dante's "GodofWar" Inferno is in fact new IP, and ATVI does in fact milk stuff to death. No special glasses need to see both those facts.
maniac-kun
Member
Kadayi
Banned
Long overdue. He bet large on TOR and BF3 and neither really panned out for him. I was surprised he lasted this long.
Very interested to see who gets appointed, however I suspect there will likely be a considerable degree of rationalization by whomever is in charge in order to reduce overheads. I suspect we'll see a few studios get thrown under the bus and maybe some projects cancelled whilst they refocus. I suspect there will be an aggressive campaign to combat a lot of the negative publicity they've garnered of late.
Very interested to see who gets appointed, however I suspect there will likely be a considerable degree of rationalization by whomever is in charge in order to reduce overheads. I suspect we'll see a few studios get thrown under the bus and maybe some projects cancelled whilst they refocus. I suspect there will be an aggressive campaign to combat a lot of the negative publicity they've garnered of late.
alexandros
Banned
I'm scared of what may come next. I think Riccitiello's heart as in the right place when he began his tenure at EA, but his choices didn't really pan out.
Pachter twisting the knife....
LOL, he's got you there Brett.
BF3 didn't pan out? Last I saw it was well over 15M, maybe sneaking up on 20M. Pretty sure that TOR is what really hurt him.
He was aiming for the hardcore at first, and that tanked the company. I think that if things would have panned out like John was hoping for EA would still be putting out new IP's and wouldn't be as anti-consumer as they are now.
Jake Tower
Banned
Only the Dynamic Duo of Cliffy and Arthur can save EA now.
So perfect.
Great time to repost...you don't mess with Elastigirl!
part 2: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4f97gcfg5AI
And his deal making will be missed.
part 1: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G-ssoN6VcWo
part 2: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4f97gcfg5AI
And his deal making will be missed.
part 1: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G-ssoN6VcWo
Omegasquash
Member
I'm pretty sure that Pachter twitter was warming up to the replacement, nothing more. It was political.
re: the resignation...he did good, and he did not so good. IMO it was TOR that hurt 'em, but it makes me think that I should build a game studio, flood games, and get sold to EA.
re: the resignation...he did good, and he did not so good. IMO it was TOR that hurt 'em, but it makes me think that I should build a game studio, flood games, and get sold to EA.
As it's been mentioned before, no he didn't. Nearly all of the new IP games were in production before he took over as CEO. I think even Mass Effect and Dragon Age were in production before Bioware formed under Elevation Partners. Instead, he invested heavily in social games, which didn't really pan out, and two expensive MMOs that didn't pan out either. The only real successes under his watch were continuing franchises. Bringing back SSX and Medal of Honor both flopped.
I could have sworn that he did interviews where he was talking about doing new ips at EA. Then the company tanked and he changed his tune.
Dante's Inferno might have been greenlighted by him. So there you go.
partyphone
Banned
to be fair to Pachter the stock market behaves irrationally. So it's probably a good time to buy EA stock. Then you dump it as the price goes up when they announce a new CEO.
Sure.
EA present : Battlefield 3
Now with one more hour for the campaign!
Out this fall, right next to Battlefied 4!(Also not available on Wii U!)
$50.
Lactose_Intolerant
Member
Pachter twisting the knife....
David Goldfarb has really had a fuck the world attitude lately in public. It is pretty funny.
1. Focusing on quality certainly doesn't mean going from Sim City 4 to the disaster that is SimCity 2013. It also doesn't mean that their Wow wannabe TOR gets to be released in the sorry shape it did.
It also doesn't mean transforming your popular games into ATM with microtransactions.
2. I'll certainly give you that.
3. When your new IP is more tired than the milked to death Guitar Hero you know something is wrong.
Might as well be happy with how MSFT handled Rare while you're at it!
partyphone
Banned
Imagine a bunch of headless chickens running around spraying blood and shitting all over everything.
Or pay just $39.99 per hour you spend on the campaign!
Pachter twisting the knife....
No he's just continuing being wrong 100% of the time. Basically EA is doomed.
But EA hasn't done that in years and Ricci still got fired.
Sure you can, 6 months to a year later after the original launch date.
Pachter twisting the knife....
Wonder why he got sacked if EA is in good shape.
Pachter twisting the knife....
LOL at Goldfarb's response.
EA at one point was willing to take risks. The recession tanked them though and they kept tanking for a while after that. Then they started up hard with the nickle and diming shit.
They made that rails shooter that reviewers loved but consumers never cared about.
Riccitiello didn't even have to make games for Nintendo to be cursed, just promise them at some point.
partyphone
Banned
Even if those risks had paid off better they'd just be milking those franchises right now.
That's pretty much what they did, I mean Dead Space is pretty much milked along with the other properties.
I have no idea why they didn't try to milk dante though.
You mean the Dead Space game no one ever asked for that wasted Eurocom's time?
POWERSPHERE
Banned
They made the Skate games under his leadership. That makes him the best.
TOR was a huge risk, and a huge failure, and now all the leads associated with it are going from EA.
Jibbajabbawockky
Member
Its not even that- Medal of Honor: Warfighter was one of the most risk averse titles you can think of and it flopped horribly.
TOR shouldn't have been a risk. Star Wars is one of the largest franchises in the world. An MMO should have been money in the bank, but they screwed the wooki badly on that one.
Professor Renegade
Banned
Hindsight is always 20/20 as they say
But if you look at the money WoW was bringing in, and you take Bioware and slap on the popular and always relevant Star Wars intellectual property together, then you cannot really blame Riccitiello for helping green light such a project, in theory it makes perfect sense and a license to print money for years to come
If anything i blame more Bioware for that game than EA, they just did not create a compelling MMO, and lord knows (and the stats do show) that people gave that game a chance, the game it self was just not good enough.
Its not like Riccitiello green-lighted some batshit crazy 200 million dollar 3D platformer based on the ALF license.
But if you look at the money WoW was bringing in, and you take Bioware and slap on the popular and always relevant Star Wars intellectual property together, then you cannot really blame Riccitiello for helping green light such a project, in theory it makes perfect sense and a license to print money for years to come
If anything i blame more Bioware for that game than EA, they just did not create a compelling MMO, and lord knows (and the stats do show) that people gave that game a chance, the game it self was just not good enough.
Its not like Riccitiello green-lighted some batshit crazy 200 million dollar 3D platformer based on the ALF license.
Indeed, playing it safe and continuing to try and chase after the COD crowd is the worst strategy any publisher can employ going forward and has been for the past few years. If anything, more risks need to be taken with bold new ideas that can get people excited again for something different. Somebody needs to step up to the plate, but it sure as hell is not going to be EA. That much is pretty evident, I think.
I would say the risks he took were things like running into Steam, CoD, WoW, Zynga, and others head on with expensive projects and acquisitions.
Some of those worked out well, others not so much.
While he did turn the company around quite well financially, he also lost a lot of money on bad bets at the same time.
Having him leave now puts the new CEO in a fiscal year that should largely be a cakewalk given their line-up seems to consist of their annual sports games, EA MMA, Battlefield, Dragon Age, and Respawn's title, and thus starts them off on a good foot.
It wasn't a total waste of time. Eurocom developed a decent engine out of the deal that was later used in Goldeneye.
ToR was a much larger risk than it needed to be due to poor management of the budget and the project in general.
I guess financially it was a huge risk but to me taking the star wars IP and making a WoW clone wasn't a risk at all. I think the only thing that went wrong is it came out when people were done with WoW clones and pay to play MMOs. They simply took too long to release it.
speculawyer
Member
Well that certainly did not benefit EA at all.