Visualante
Member
UK law says this... Jesus what about human error? That's retarded.
deepbrown said:Well the act in question is the "trade descriptions act" - quote that to them if they give you any bother and they will have to fall in line, or will risk prosecution.
Well done all![]()
This is exactly right. I can't be bothered to explain it, so I'll let the BBC do it for me...McBacon said:That they can't go and take £40 out of your credit card, but they are well within their rights to cancel your order
After Argos withdrew its erroneous price-tag on the Internet of £3 for a television set, buyers are furious and talk of compensation - but do they have a point? The BBC's legal affairs correspondent, Joshua Rozenberg, explains.
A shopkeeper has a television for sale. He puts it in the window with a large sign advertising the price. A customer sees it in the shop window and offers to buy it.
The shopkeeper does not have to sell the television if he does not want to. At that stage there is no contract.
The shopkeeper is making what lawyers call an 'invitation to treat', an invitation to the customer to make him an offer.
So the customer cannot insist on buying the television at the advertised price. If the shopkeeper has put an unusually low price on it - deliberately or by mistake - he can refuse to do a deal with the customer.
Argos does not have to sell you a television for £3.
We are writing to inform you that the price for the following item was
displayed incorrectly at the time you placed the above referenced
order:
--------------------------------------------------------------------
Lair (PS3)
--------------------------------------------------------------------
Despite our best efforts, with the millions of items available on our
website, pricing errors can occasionally occur.
In our Pricing and Availability Policy (see
http://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/help/customer/display.html?nodeId=1040614),
we state that where an item's correct price is higher than our stated
price, we will cancel the order and notify you of that cancellation.
Your order has now been cancelled. If you still wish to purchase this
item, please place a new order online which will be charged at the
correct price, when we dispatch it to you.
McBacon said:The dream is over, guys
This is disgraceful.
I read many emails from your company on an internet forum stating the price will NOT be changed, and then I receive an email saying it has.
This is terrible customer service. I pre-ordered this product from you due to its price and you return be cancelling and saying "Oh sorry we made a mistake".
This isn't good enough; the service I have received here is not satisfactory in any sort of way and this is not the first time it has happened either. Call of Duty 2 Game of the Year edition back last year was put at a reduced price and you cancelled it, back then I decided to let it go as a one off but you have done it again, is it so hard to check your prices before they are submitted? Clearly you aren't trying your hardest.
Websites such as Game.co.uk and gameplay.co.uk guarantee the pre-order price you order it for unless it drops, then you pay the lowest price even it goes back up again, I consider that to be good customer service and very rarely find mistakes on their websites like this anyway.
Games are very expensive to purchase, you had a lot of orders for the two products this happened to (Folklore PS3 as well) based on the large amount of people I know ordered them from you, you have lot their custom for this game as well as mine, I shall make sure I go elsewhere for my games in future as I know I will receive a better service than you provide.
First one... then the other. Epic. :lolPsychotext said:I can't wait for the epic ranting when Amazon comes out tomorrow and announces the price was a mistake.
I would also enjoy the epic celebrations if Amazon wasn't to announce this was wrong.![]()
This has happend many of times yet people still think their going to get a bargin...$h@d0w said:This is a load of shit.
Several confirmations from customer advisors, then this crap.
dalyr95 said:But surely if you got a email saying they would honour the price, then turn around and cancel the price? Doesn't that go against their word?
Aretak said:This is exactly right. I can't be bothered to explain it, so I'll let the BBC do it for me...
It doesn't matter. They haven't taken your money, and aren't obliged to send you anything. There's no "action" to be taken, other than to perhaps badger their customer services in the hope they get so tired of you they'll offer you a £5 voucher or something as a goodwill gesture.dalyr95 said:But surely if you got a email saying they would honour the price, then turn around and cancel the price? Doesn't that go against their word?
The order confirmation e-mail is simply a confirmation that they have received your offer to buy the product, and contains the following information:Raist said:Case is slightly different here however. They do send you a confirmation of your order, with the said price, and they DO confirm they'll honour the price in an email.
Taking this example, that would make the shopkeeper say "oh, yes, the price really is £3, absolutely" and then retract it.
Now I guess it's not illegal, but that certainly is a very bad customer service.
Which is obviously conclusive.Please note that for items ordered from Amazon.co.uk this e-mail is only an acknowledgement of receipt of your order and your contract to purchase these items is not complete until we send you an e-mail notifying you that the items have been dispatched to you. For items purchased from third parties in Marketplace, zShops or Auctions, this e-mail confirms the completion of your contract to purchase those items.
This we agree on. People like this always, always spoil it for the majority. There were kiddies on the official PS3 forums boasting of ordering 10+ copies to sell.And I blame the greedy people how ordered several copies of the same game![]()
iapetus said:No. This price has been posted to all the deals sites in the UK and now is even reaching NeoGAF. They've probably had more orders for these games than there are PS3s in the country, mostly from people just planning to trade them in or stick them on eBay. There's not a chance in hell they're going to honour this one.
Aretak said:T
This we agree on. People like this always, always spoil it for the majority. There were kiddies on the official PS3 forums boasting of ordering 10+ copies to sell.
Keyser Soze said:The best those that ordered can hope for now is to write a email telling them you are disillusioned by there bad service and you would be hesitant to order from them again. If you do something that contains that wording it scares them and you will most likely get a voucher worth about £5.
iapetus said:Big shock.
iapetus said:I'm still sceptical, but slightly less so now. If they're sending out a lot of mails stating explicitly that the price will be honoured, then everything might turn out okay. I figure they owe me one for the amount of money I spent on my PS3 from them, so it's a good job I got my order in for this early.
Raist said:
The UK arm of Amazon is not based in France, and as such does not have to abide by French law. Their T&Cs regarding misprices are quite clear. If the law is different in France, I imagine that Amazon France's T&Cs are different.f@luS said:As a french customer buying on a foreign EU shop, its my own laws applying here (fr), and as such, they should send the games. The law is pretty clear , only a "ridiculous" (dont know how to translate it, in french its "dérisoire" ) price, can cancel an online order. Such a price is more like 1/10 of the real price, not 1/3 at all. They are just not respecting the law right here. Well fck them ^^
iapetus said:Like I said, still sceptical, and right to be. The people who got human-generated confirmations of the price might have a decent chance of getting something out of this if they push it, because there are sufficiently few of them that it's probably not worth the hassle of fighting it. The rest of us are shafted, because the sheer volume of orders would represent a huge hit to Amazon if they honoured them.
And they still owe me one for the profit they made on my PS3 preorder.![]()
Raist said:C'mon, this is Amazon, that wouldn't hurt them![]()
cjelly said:Going back on their word?
Legally? Fine.
Morally? Not so OK.
Yes, I completely agree. It just amuses how as soon as a company does something like this, and then send out e-mails confirming the cheaper price, and THEN change it, people cry 'It's illegal!' When it clearly isn't.iapetus said:If it's a misprice, it's a misprice. Why should the company virtually give stuff away (mostly to eBay profiteers) because some idiot in data entry pressed the wrong button?
cjelly said:Yes, I completely agree. It just amuses how as soon as a company does something like this, and then send out e-mails confirming the cheaper price, and THEN change it, people cry 'It's illegal!' When it clearly isn't.
Scary Euro man indeed.:loliapetus said:I also like the huge crowds of people threatening to boycott sites for not selling them goods at an obviously mistaken price.