• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

"Make Your Own Zelda Flipnote" Contest Results

Why would you do that? said:
Even though I disagree with him in that those games (specifically Spirit Tracks) are horrible, I agree with him in that, for someone getting back into the series, maybe he shouldn't play those games immediately.

But the PH/ST argument was already heavily argued in the past, so I won't get into my opinion here. But since it is fairly unpopular in the Zelda crowd, it wouldn't be the best game to play for the first time.
Click to expand...

Spirit Tracks is a step back in the right direction though. I have more respect for that game that Phantom Hourglass (click the link for the lines I draw in the sand here).

It's just as a Zelda fan veteran, they were such colossal step backs as far as I'm concerned there's no viable argument that could excuse how much they crippled in the name of making it easy for casuals. The whole philosophy of the design seems positively informed by it at every level.

Spirit Tracks seems to realize it had to provide a better mix, so dungeon design specifically improves (as does difficulty) so it was more enjoyable. But they had to go and fuck up overworld exploration with the trains.

uchihasasuke said:
shouldn't you avoid the new Wii bundles if you want the full functionality of the console? (this new model lacks GC BC and GC controller ports so he's getting less for the same price as a current wii)
Click to expand...

I assume he has a GCN, but if the only reason he's getting a Wii this late in the cycle is to play Skyward Sword you might as well save yourself money, no?




Back on topic specifically...



I made this one FLIPNOTE studio animation once of Zelda taking out his sword and accidentally skewering Kirby and then roasting Kirby over a fire like a marshmallow but I deleted it by accident :(
 
Amir0x said:
the third one is so impressive it blew me away. FlipNote Studio is the only superfluous non-gaming app I ever liked between DS and Wii, and they didn't include it in 3DS :(

*sniff*
Click to expand...
They are hardly working on the Wii U version "FlipNote Studio HD"
I Wish :(
 
Awesome. I wish they'd do something like this for Metroid... not like there's anything stopping people making Metroid flipnotes on their own, but still.
 
These are really amazing. I'm glad I didn't bother, since it takes me forever to animate more than 60 frames.

The oddball sidekicks and the grass cutting ones were my favorite. The four swords themed one blew me away.
 
Chavelo said:
ALTTP is awesome, that's why. And trust me, I just get so hyped up about SS, now. >.<



Haven't bought a Nintendo system since the N64. Not out of protest or getting butthurt, just... haven't really bought one, really. Kinda went to the PC realm and haven't looked back (had a 360 strictly for fighting games only, but that got stolen) D:

Got a DS laying around that I got on my birthday, tho. What should I get for it (Zelda-wise)?
Click to expand...
Get a Wii, get Twilight Princess, get Skyward Sword (and Wind Waker I guess)
 
Dat 3rd one. The tingle and side characters was the most entertaining though. Props to the breaking out of DS animation for concept and execution with a limited tool.

I've never used Flipnote since there's no way to get it for the DS Phat and DSlite but I always wanted to try. Hopefully Nintendo make a version for 3DS. They could add some cool 3D objects and layer options as well. :3
 
hateradio said:
I guess most people like Wind Waker's style. :p
Click to expand...
yep, I guess Japanese like that style better with the series. Also, I really liked the 4 Swords, Tingle and the 3D one. The one with consoles was seriously mind blowing, I wonder how long they made these animations...
 
Amir0x said:
There is only the ultimate truth here I am stating with regards to the embarrassing handheld DS games.

They're the easiest, infant catering casualtard Zelda titles ever created, with the simplest puzzles, the most bog standard linear dungeons where every puzzle solution is usually solved by reading a sign a room over, every key is held for about two seconds since it's usually in only a few rooms over, every enemy is so easy since tap to kill basically launches you across the screen at mach 10, the visuals are abominable DS molestation of the gorgeous Wind Waker style (a greek tragedy with that alone), the least memorable Zelda soundtrack, Temple of the Ocean King, horrible trace-a-line-go-to-sleep overworld, removing critical exploration, horrible train track train overworld (also removing critical exploration) the list is so extensive it's possibly endless.

People who like these games clearly like Zelda for reasons having nothing to do with anything even close to what has made Zelda games good in the past.

It has the worst dungeon design, the worst NPCs, the worst "story", the worst graphics, the easiest (and therefore worst) difficulty, the easiest puzzles, the laziest bosses


I seriously cannot ever see an argument in favor of these games that I cannot safely tell someone to ignore if they even remotely value what makes Zelda good.

For in depth inarguable truth regarding these games and why no one should respect them, click here.


________________________________________


Anyway, I love this FlipNote studio shit. I can do pretty cool short animations but I always get so lazy and end a project about 10% through my full vision. One day I'll have the patience to do something like the ones in the tribute.
Click to expand...

One of the few instances where your hyperbole is warranted. When you're right Ami, you're right!

And these animations are all extremely impressive.
 
Amir0x said:
Spirit Tracks is a step back in the right direction though. I have more respect for that game that Phantom Hourglass (click the link for the lines I draw in the sand here).

It's just as a Zelda fan veteran, they were such colossal step backs as far as I'm concerned there's no viable argument that could excuse how much they crippled in the name of making it easy for casuals. The whole philosophy of the design seems positively informed by it at every level.

Spirit Tracks seems to realize it had to provide a better mix, so dungeon design specifically improves (as does difficulty) so it was more enjoyable. But they had to go and fuck up overworld exploration with the trains.



I assume he has a GCN, but if the only reason he's getting a Wii this late in the cycle is to play Skyward Sword you might as well save yourself money, no?




Back on topic specifically...



I made this one FLIPNOTE studio animation once of Zelda taking out his sword and accidentally skewering Kirby and then roasting Kirby over a fire like a marshmallow but I deleted it by accident :(
Click to expand...


Stop trolling DS Zeldas, this is not even the right thread.
 
The 3rd one is seriously crazy awesome. It's kind of scary how talented these guys are. I suck in comparison. T_T
 
Well this should get them some ideas on making a Zelda anime...

That third clip/Four Swords one had awesome movement and shading. Crazy.
 
Ginko-Mogh, PumpkinG and Cheval's are the best. LOL @ Tesuka's comments for Jimmy's flipnote (he's obviously never seen the internet troll/rage faces!)
 
Amir0x said:
ok, here's what to do.

1. Avoid all the Zelda DS games. They're the worst Zelda games since the CD-i titles and it'd instantly leave a sour taste in your mouth.

2. Get a Wii for the $150 dollar christmas deal (comes with NSMB Wii).

3. Buy Zelda: Skyward Sword Bundle with Motion+ Controller Included


And you will profit, oh trust me you will! Don't let yourself miss out on Skyward Sword!
Click to expand...
And get WW and TP.

How can you not say that!

And if you have a Lite, get the minish cap on GBA if you can.
 
Boney said:
And get WW and TP.

How can you not say that!
Click to expand...
That $150 Wii with NSMB can't play GC games. It's the same thing as the European model. You're better off getting the bundle with Mario Kart now.
 
jackdoe said:
That $150 Wii with NSMB can't play GC games. It's the same thing as the European model. You're better off getting the bundle with Mario Kart now.
Click to expand...
Then you get that version.
 
Anyone else notice how the Japanese flipnotes favoured the pigs, while the US ones favoured the Cuccos?

While the EU ones favour the bow and arrows (WTF?!)
 
Nuclear Muffin said:
Anyone else notice how the Japanese flipnotes favoured the pigs, while the US ones favoured the Cuccos?

While the EU ones favour the bow and arrows (WTF?!)
Click to expand...
at least they didn't favour Ooccas
 
Of the European entries, I liked Cheval's the most. Great action, and funny punchline. A few of the North American entries had really good drawing and animation, like Pickles and Vokyous. The Japanese entries were all around better though, not surprisingly :P
 
Stupidly awesome. I can't believe people can do stuff like this. But then again, I can't draw on paper, so it's not hard to believe that I can't believe it.
 
Kazerei said:
Of the European entries, I liked Cheval's the most. Great action, and funny punchline. A few of the North American entries had really good drawing and animation, like Pickles and Vokyous. The Japanese entries were all around better though, not surprisingly :P
Click to expand...

Yeah, the JPN ones are usually the best, but the EU ones are usually not far behind (with US bringing up the rear)

There's a few good EU ones, but overall I'm disappointed in them. I feel ashamed to call myself a brit lol!
 
I'm not sure if I like Darkhart or Vokyous the best amongst the US winners, but Cheval is the best European one, though PumpkinG was good too.
EmCeeGramr said:
oh my god watch chrille's
Click to expand...
That's one bitch'n Goron.
 
Pretty cool that Nintendo put these on the eshop. The US ones aren't as good as the Japanese ones but they're still entertaining. Well done flipnote artists and well done Nintendo for once.
 
Why would you do that? said:
But the PH/ST argument was already heavily argued in the past, so I won't get into my opinion here. But since it is fairly unpopular in the Zelda crowd, it wouldn't be the best game to play for the first time.
Click to expand...

Are they really though? GAF hates them sure, but GAF do as GAF do. Haven't experienced the hate anywhere close outside of this forum.
 
Japan has insanely superior animation, but there are some cool ideas in other regions

Loved Europe Cheval's, but the best ones are definitivaly the 4 swords, DS, takoyaki and the arrow/pig ones from japan
 
Cheval is the best from the Europe lol!
Vokyous, Thomas, Inkwolf and Skye are the best on the US side.
But I'm disappointed with the US and Eu selections ... at least the US was by far better than Eu on arvg.

They need a Korean selection, I'm sure that would be the best lol!
 
Just discovered this today. I haven't seen the JP entries yet, but holy bejeezus Darkhart's video is badass, easily the best of the NA entries. Giulia<3's is probably my favorite of the EU videos, Samurai Link is pretty sweet.
 
Holy shit at Cheval's. Amazing and hilarious. I wish I had nearly that much talent. Did Flpnote ever take off here on Gaf? I know when I first got it I spent ages making a few animations I could be proud of. Was there a thread?
 
Really great stuff! I completely forgot about the competition, so I didn't enter anything. Bummer :(

I hope they release the 3DS version of Flipnote soon. I really want to get back into it, but my DSi is kinda busted.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

What starts to make a game - AAA, in your opinion? Simply in your own eyes, not by official AAA tag
2
83
978
Ainem Enamas replied
  • Poll
What if Capcom makes their own console?
Poll  2
93
874
BennyBlanco replied
Jez: MS sources tell me that the longer-term goal for Game Pass is to make it more flexible. A sort of "pick your own plan" formula is on the cards.
Rumor 
40
170
cireza replied
Make your own Star System for GTA VI
9
544
cripterion replied
How do you legally put your own games on an emulator?
2
82
1K
Setsuna Mudou replied
Top Bottom