Ned Flanders said:The LHW division matchups for the forseeable future SHOULD look like this:
Rampage vs UFC notable: Would have been Jardine if not for Alexander, Griffin if not for Jardine, Bonnar if not for steroids. Rampage destroyed the legend yet again, and needs a mid-profile challenger (a la Chuck vs Babalu) to tide him over before his next big-time showdown. My nominee then becomes....Michael Bisping! Undefeated, on a streak, ready to graduate to the next level. In all honesty, he should have one big-time warm-up fight before a title shot (a la Rashad vs Tito), but its really Dana/Silva's fault that hasn't happened already. Bisping has good visibility among the UFC fanbase/TUF crowd, and is a relatively exciting fighter. If he won, he'd at least be a charismatic champion (and a great draw for UK audiences), and if he lost, he'd still be in the mix as far as contenders go.
Liddell vs Houston Alexander: Lets be clear here. Chuck doesn't need or deserve to be coddled, and Chuck doesn't want to be coddled. Alexander either becomes a bonafide star/contender with a win over the Iceman, or Chuck returns to show a dangerous fighter how dangerous he's always been. Think about it; if Chuck loses to Jardine, he's pretty washed up having been beaten by a guy who just got made into a human mop a couple months ago. But if he losses to Alexander, well then maybe he just got caught by the latest up and coming phenom...nothing to be ashamed of.
Shogun vs Tito: Every UFC fan knows what Tito is made of...for better or for worse. What better measuring stick for the talent of the latest dangerous Pride import than one of the UFC's most familiar faces? This way we can finally see if Tito is done-done as a legitimate force in the LHW division. Good exposure for Shogun, good test for Tito. Win-win for both fighters.
Lyoto vs Griffin: Last chance for Griffin! If Lyoto finishes him, he gets a contender match followed by a title shot. If Griffin wins, he buys himself another fight in the UFC. Again, more exposure for Lyoto against a UFC notable, and a redemption shot for Griffin against an undefeated fighter with a number of quality wins.
Babalu vs Evans: The Ortiz draw was a sidestep for Evans, leaving him in limbo between "Great TUF fighter" and "legitimate UFC LHW contender". Babalu is a seasoned veteran on the level of a Tito, and a guy who desperately needs to get back on the winning track against quality opponents. So Evans isn't relegated to fighting mid-level guys again, but he's not immediately made a contender after a mediocre performance. Win-win again..
Henderson should go down to middleweight, fight a contender (hell he should have fought Ace for the number one contender spot), then go on to fight Silva for the title in the fight the entire world wants to see. I know he's perfectly capable of banging with the big boys (in fact I dare say that Dan is more comfortable fighting bigger, slower targets in the LHW division), but I just don't think having him there, vs Rampage in his first fight no less, is anything anyone is really clamoring to see. Either he gets beat and people (people being your average UFC fan who knows nothing about MMA outside of the Octagon) wonder what the hell the big deal was about him, or Rampage loses and everyone considers him a gimmicky champion who got lucky against Golden Boy Chuck. Its a matchup of great fighters, but its not a "great matchup", if you know what I mean.
I don't think Tito would want to step in the cage with Shogun. Tito has everything to lose and little to gain. Would it be a great victory if he won? Sure, but I think most MMA fans in the U.S. don't know who Shogun is yet. I'd love to see the match-up, but I don't know if it makes sense for Tito, unless it's the pre-cursor to a title match.