Pinko Marx
Banned
Sharp said:
-
Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!
Music - Controversial Opinions
- Thread starter ThanksVision
- Start date
- Status
Simon Belmont
Banned
brianjones said:
How did you leave the Talking Heads off of this list? Oh, and Crowded House.
Pinko Marx
Banned
Sharp said:
I'm just gunna say okay pal and let you keep on doing your thing.
That thing being grossly misunderstanding what people say
brianjones
Member
Simon Belmont said:
im sure i forgot more.. dont know crowded house though
my point was the 80s was an amazing decade for music (possibly my favorite) and gets a silly bad rap based on stupid crap that was popular at the time.
These kind of threads are amazing.:lol
I enjoy listening to their songs from time to time. But they are not something I'd listen to on a album-to-album basis. They'd get boring fast otherwise.
Only if you have boring taste!
I don't think this is controversial.
Ironically metalheads are the least annoying music fans on GAF.
Simon Belmont
Banned
brianjones said:
Approved.
Check out Crowded House though, I'm sure you've heard some of the singles. Great songwriting.
Most Rappers are not actually musicians (and rap is one of the lowest form of music). They have no sense for chords and tones (although they often times have some sense for rhythm since they have to rhyme in the correct tempo). Its just them rhyming over a beat with samples that they stole from real musicians.
Radiohead make so fucking boring music. Even Coldplay is better.
90 % of Red Hot Chili Peppers songs before Californication is brain dead funk that lacks any attraction. Its bad melodies disguised in boring shitty aggressive slapping and the worst singing that sounds like pure shitty improvisation on the spot.
Most of Bob Dylans acoustic songs sucks ass and the only reason people like them is because of the lyrics or because they need simple music that only involves 1 instrument and they are the same people who cannot understand that 99% of all singer and songwriting is a very simple and dumbed down version of band music.
Prince is a stupid pervert who ruined his career with shitty experimental music that no one beside himself likes except every 20th song where he actually makes a normal song that a normal person can listen too.
Iron Maiden is really boring shitty metal from the 80s that got a completely undeserved revival in the 90s.
Born to Run is one of Bruce Springsteens most boring and pretentious albums.
99 % of all people with Led Zeppelin shirts would for themselves admit after listening to every Led Zeppelin song that 90 % of the songs are kinda unlistenable shitty melodies that are comparable to Red Hot Chili Peppers.
Baam...
Also i do not think one should judge an artist until you heard every album they recorded like 4 times
Radiohead make so fucking boring music. Even Coldplay is better.
90 % of Red Hot Chili Peppers songs before Californication is brain dead funk that lacks any attraction. Its bad melodies disguised in boring shitty aggressive slapping and the worst singing that sounds like pure shitty improvisation on the spot.
Most of Bob Dylans acoustic songs sucks ass and the only reason people like them is because of the lyrics or because they need simple music that only involves 1 instrument and they are the same people who cannot understand that 99% of all singer and songwriting is a very simple and dumbed down version of band music.
Prince is a stupid pervert who ruined his career with shitty experimental music that no one beside himself likes except every 20th song where he actually makes a normal song that a normal person can listen too.
Iron Maiden is really boring shitty metal from the 80s that got a completely undeserved revival in the 90s.
Born to Run is one of Bruce Springsteens most boring and pretentious albums.
99 % of all people with Led Zeppelin shirts would for themselves admit after listening to every Led Zeppelin song that 90 % of the songs are kinda unlistenable shitty melodies that are comparable to Red Hot Chili Peppers.
Baam...
Also i do not think one should judge an artist until you heard every album they recorded like 4 times
Dreams-Visions
Member
michael jacksonbrianjones said:
luther vandross
anita baker
marvin gaye
stevie wonder
johnny gill
madonna
nwa
run dmc
etc.
just lending some support.
Simon Belmont
Banned
Sealda said:
I believe you meant 'such' as opposed to 'so'.
Dislike Radiohead all you want, but saying Coldplay is better is going to make people think you're stupid, not edgy.
Dreams-Visions
Member
Nappuccino
Member
Dreams-Visions said:
Sounds like something my mom would listen too....
Pinko Marx
Banned
Your mom is cool as hell.Nappuccino said:
Sealda said:Most Rappers are not actually musicians (and rap is one of the lowest form of music). They have no sense for chords and tones (although they often times have some sense for rhythm since they have to rhyme in the correct tempo). Its just them rhyming over a beat with samples that they stole from real musicians.
Radiohead make so fucking boring music. Even Coldplay is better.
90 % of Red Hot Chili Peppers songs before Californication is brain dead funk that lacks any attraction. Its bad melodies disguised in boring shitty aggressive slapping and the worst singing that sounds like pure shitty improvisation on the spot.
Most of Bob Dylans acoustic songs sucks ass and the only reason people like them is because of the lyrics or because they need simple music that only involves 1 instrument and they are the same people who cannot understand that 99% of all singer and songwriting is a very simple and dumbed down version of band music.
Prince is a stupid pervert who ruined his career with shitty experimental music that no one beside himself likes except every 20th song where he actually makes a normal song that a normal person can listen too.
Iron Maiden is really boring shitty metal from the 80s that got a completely undeserved revival in the 90s.
Born to Run is one of Bruce Springsteens most boring and pretentious albums.
99 % of all people with Led Zeppelin shirts would for themselves admit after listening to every Led Zeppelin song that 90 % of the songs are kinda unlistenable shitty melodies that are comparable to Red Hot Chili Peppers.
Baam...
Also i do not think one should judge an artist until you heard every album they recorded like 4 times
p. terrible post but the bolded is sort of obvious, they're vocalists and they aren't playing any instruments. But listen to something like this; rappers can be amazingly talented in the way the manipulate language
Pseudo_Sam
Survives without air, food, or water
Dave Matthews Band > other popular jam bands (REM, Phish, ect.)
Carter Beauford = best drummer in the business
The Arctic Monkeys are the best thing to ever come out of Europe music-wise
Bob Dylan has a terrible, terrible voice and as a result a mediocre music career
John Mayer is a guitar god and should be mentioned right alongside the others (Clapton, ect.)
Carter Beauford = best drummer in the business
The Arctic Monkeys are the best thing to ever come out of Europe music-wise
Bob Dylan has a terrible, terrible voice and as a result a mediocre music career
John Mayer is a guitar god and should be mentioned right alongside the others (Clapton, ect.)
Nappuccino
Member
ATF487 said:
My main hip hop acts are the Roots, Aesop Rock and the Beastie Boys.
Mostly because there's some real music going on in most of their tracks.
GremlinFool
Member
MBDTF>>>Late Registration>Graduation=808s>>>>>College Dropout
ThanksVision
Member
Pseudo_Sam said:
Nvm this takes the cake
I can't stop fucking laughing:lol :lol
ThanksVision
Member
Yeah this thread is pissing me off. I understand opinions, but some of these posts are insane.
"Kanye West has no talent... I've only heard like 3 songs though"
"Kanye West has no talent... I've only heard like 3 songs though"
Pinko Marx
Banned
Timber said:
My man! I was just about to recommend him El-P.
Nappuccino said:
Love the Roots. But sampling is sort of its own art form, it can be so daunting...the Avalanches used samples from a lot of different sources to create a really cool pop album, but the amount of detail it required is just ridiculous
this thread is less entertaining on atease though, no one wants to shit on the classics
blame space
Banned
My Chemical Romance is good.
DUFFMCWALIN
Member
AmenBarberetti said:
brianjones
Member
James Woods
Banned
Fergie and her tits are the only redeeming thing about BEP.
Sunglasses At Night is a fantastic 80's song and one of the best from that era of great music.
Sunglasses At Night is a fantastic 80's song and one of the best from that era of great music.
goldlion054
Member
James Woods said:
I thought this was supposed to be a controversial thread? Cause everything you say is spot on
Pinko Marx
Banned
Timber said:
I was gunna type something in response to this, but I decided against it. Instead, I'll just :lol
James Woods
Banned
Salazar said:
INXS > NOFX
Take that, thread!
HappyBivouac
Member
Jazz as a genre is both more compositionally interesting and more expressive than most of the work produced by the classical titans of the past several centuries.
HappyBivouac
Member
Sharp said:
Well then the same could be said about every other opinion expressed in this thread.
Kong Fisso
Banned
Metallica should've kept Dave.
Morrissey is tiresome at best. I'm not a fan or anything, but poor Marr.
I reckon that about 10 % of Bob Dylan's fans actually like his music. The rest just decorate their itunes library with it.
Glam Pantera was totally rad, serious.
Morrissey is tiresome at best. I'm not a fan or anything, but poor Marr.
I reckon that about 10 % of Bob Dylan's fans actually like his music. The rest just decorate their itunes library with it.
Glam Pantera was totally rad, serious.
Pinko Marx
Banned
I'm convinced nobody actually LIKES In An Aeroplane Over the Sea. They just say they do to troll me and to fit in with a certain kind of crowd.
blame space
Banned
Salazar said:
- Status