Diversity of opinion should be celebrated. This sounds eerily like an "ethics in game journalism" request. Should everyone else demand a re-review if a white male reviewer reviews games with white male protagonists which don't reflect our emotional resonance to these characters? Because that's basically what you're asking.
Bingo.
I for one welcome reading why a game is valuable to someone of a different background to me (I'm a white male, btw), and I think judging a game solely on its game mechanics and content rather than how people react to it is silly, anyway.
A game is a product of everything that goes into it: its visuals, its audio, its writing, how the player interacts with it, and so on. Part of a game being successful is how all of these things elicit a response from the player.
In fact, really, it's impossible to judge a game without assessing the emotional response to it. When a game's gameplay sucks, players get annoyed. When its story is poorly-written we respond appropriately. If the the graphics suck it is offputting, and terrible audio is annoying. On the flipside, good gameplay can make us happy, or it can be thrilling, or it can make us feel like we were challenged. Good graphics inspire awe in us, while an amazing story produces "the feels" (as much as I hate that term), whether that's a positive feeling or a more negative one we are moved all the same, while a great game soundtrack is something we hum, whistle and sing over and over.
All of these are emotional responses, and there is no objective way to quantify them. The whole process is entirely subjective depending on one's tastes and background.
