• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Nintendo charges $0.50 to register minors on Nintendo Network

There's actually a best practice for this, since many other services do it.

- Charge as little as possible (8-20 cents, for example)
- When the charge goes through, give the user that much in credit

As long as the user purchases /anything/ going forward, it's effectively a 0.00 fee.

The best policy is no CC required (assuming it's required for everyone and not a walkaround by selecting 18).

It's not like they're not selling Nintendo points in stores. So why should people be required to put a CC on file? Steam and Sony have already both been hacked in the past. MS wouldn't let you remove a CC at various times. I don't think the industry has demonstrated proper care in the past and don't deserve this privilege if you don't want to hand it to them.
 
What about this idea is awesome? What will it even accomplish? It's literally nickle and diming, but I guess this proves that Nintendo fans will literally support anything that Nintendo does.

More generally:

Someone on GAF will defend anything, no matter how stupid. This is just another example.
 
What about this idea is awesome? What will it even accomplish? It's literally nickle and diming, but I guess this proves that Nintendo fans will literally support anything that Nintendo does.

Or haters will just hate, even if its over $0.50, and can't wait to show their elitist selves as the "rational" people in these forums, lets not go that route. The non-refundable part is unnecessary, I agree. But as for what it will accomplish, it gives greater parental control over the minors, and it is also a way to preserve their "family friendly" image while giving the rest of us the freedom from the stupid FC system they had last gen.

At least that's how i see it.
 
No. Because it's stupid. Either the parent is setting up the account and therefore doesn't need to see a .50 cent charge on his CC to see that an account has been setup for his child. Since, you know, it's redundant.

Or the child is setting up his own Wii. In which case he's incentivized to lie about his age and say he's 18.
EDIT: Unless the OP is misleading and everyone is getting charged. Then it's still stupid, but slightly less. CC should not be required to set up an account. MS' abuse with this shows how it can get out of hand when they decide you can't remove it.

Which leaves Nintendo as the innocent party ....and the kid as an evil, lying, demon seed whose parents should pay more attention.
 
I'm going to assume the people who love it love the roguish audacity of it rather than they love the idea of unnecessary nonrefundable charges that are ultimately easily circumvented.
 
It's not expensive enough to be a big deal for parents, yet it is enough to keep spam accounts from being created, aimed at minors. This is a good thing.
 
My bank won't let me pay a 50 cent charge on my credit card online.

Minimum is a dollar.

I would actually have to buy something else to make the payment.
 
What about this idea is awesome? What will it even accomplish? It's literally nickle and diming, but I guess this proves that Nintendo fans will literally support anything that Nintendo does.

How is this nickel and diming? If it was nickel and diming Nintendo would have added a fee for everyone to make an account. This is just adding control so minors don't make accounts.
 
Paypal charges like 2 cents to a card when they set it up, so I guess this is kinda like that. It makes sense, but paypal also refunds those couple cents.

Can't wait for people to flip out over it.
It makes sense?

Congrats on being the first person to try and justify the stupidest thing I've seen from a gaming company in years
 
FIFTY CENTS?!


r0luV.gif
 
Quite a few companies do this, but they refund the amount.

There's actually a best practice for this, since many other services do it.

- Charge as little as possible (8-20 cents, for example)
- When the charge goes through, give the user that much in credit

As long as the user purchases /anything/ going forward, it's effectively a 0.00 fee.

Yup. It's pretty shitty that Nintendo just takes the money. 50 cents isn't anything to get worked up about, I just hate the idea.
 
I can't wait until the "Account Activation Fee" column shows up in their next financial report.
I'm sure reaction by quite a few people would be very different if this fee was thought up and charged by Activision.

I really can't see a string of posts loving Activision charging an arbitrary fee.
 
This is absolutely brilliant.

Basically eliminates the fake ages put in for verification as it requires a credit card. That way, the company is off the hook if something happens online. Smart business decision and I fully expect Microsoft and Sony to follow suit as well.
 
Just to put my own opinion out there, the 50 cents isn't an issue for the individual user. As a whole though, I personally think its exploitative and unjustifiable, for two reasons

1) Many other companies have done the same thing, without the customer losing any money at all in the long run
2) Over the years and millions of accounts, Nintendo will make a lot of unearned money for absolutely nothing.

Imagine if Sony, MS, Steam or Nintendo hiked the prices up of every item on their stores by just 1 cent. It'd have very, very little impact on me financially, but it would be vaguely disgusting for its transparent long-term exploitation of its userbase
 
Sure, $.50 is nothing to flip your shit over, but its the principle. There's no reason for this.

This principle isn't something to flip your shit over either, considering it's going to effect 0% of the people on this message board because nobody uses parental control features. It's weird, it shouldn't happen, but you shouldn't lose sleep over it either. If you want to get outraged about something, then get outraged about people paying an annual fee for P2P multiplayer on a 7 year old console and the ridiculous hoops you have to jump to remove your credit card from their service.
 
That's really the only thing I'm arguing about. If they refunded it I wouldn't have a problem.
This is to prevent people to create fake under 18 accounts. That's why it's not refundable. I'm guessing kids won't be able to interact with adults unless it's changed in the Parental security. Some are thinking about it the wrong way actually.
 
This is just adding control so minors don't make accounts.

Why can't the minors just say they're 18? The only way this would work would be for Nintendo to charge 50 cents for every account.

Edit: Also why is there even a problem if kids can make their own accounts? Just make it so they can't purchase anything!
 
Perhaps games companies should do something like this on a game by game basis too, so if a kid gets hold of an 18 or M rated game for instance, their parents will have to put their credit card details in and a pay a small fee to allow them to play it.
 
Top Bottom