I finished it. I liked it, definitely. It's no Sands of Time. In most ways, I don't know if it is even close. It's almost an entirely different game to me. It's the complete and total package in terms of presentation and I enjoyed the story. Cool game. Please go back to old style platforming for the sequel.
I got frustrated towards the end of the game since it becomes pad after pad after pad after pad, and those are the only times you DON'T get checkpoints. And those sequences are so lame when you string together 15 of them.
edit: The credits have that lame "text skipping" shit that Resistance 2 has. That is so weird.