• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Pain & Gain is "just so wrong on every possible level"

Status
Not open for further replies.
I enjoyed the movie. I thought it was funny and I enjoyed the acting in it. I never really knew about this case to begin with so after watching this movie, I did some research on it. Man, it really is a fucked up story and it blew my mind that some of the scenes actually happened. It's insane.
 
This thread made me check out the movie.

Frankly, beyond whether it's appropriate, offensive and whatnot, what it is is yet another shitty Michael Bay movie. One thing Kermode is 100% on the money is that the man has no sense of humor. His idea of a joke involves penises, sex, tits, ass or a combination of all four. Without any semblance of wit or cleverness, of course. And since it's presented as a black comedy, it kinda fell flat for me. I think describing Michael Bay's film-making sensibilities as pornographic is about right. :lol Marky Mark does give an energetic performance, he did try his best.
 
This thread made me check out the flick as well. One thing it did for me though is made me appreciate Dwayne Johnson, the man has charisma and gave a great performance. And i have to say Mark Wahlberg was well cast as well.

I have to agree with what one poster said about "imagine if it was your mother or father that got protrayed like this" i dont know if the two people who actually died had children though.

But it is a little bit insensitive since most of the people involved are still alive. That said, i kinda liked it.
 
The best thing Bay has done in ages. He needs to stick to films like this instead of making lots of money wasting time with those shite Transformers movies.

I still, in all honesty, cannot understand why would someone dislike the Transformers movies. Unless you don't like transformers altogether. Pain and gain was pretty good too.
 
watching the preview would lead you to believe that its a straight comedy, but its not, there is some really dark shit in it. it had funny moments but i wouldnt call it hilarious. i would call it a great movie however.
 
This movie really is very good, there's a lot to get from it.

One thing not to get from it is anything related to any kind of true story. Just take it as "Michael Bay's friend read the NYT review of a book about a true story, then drunkenly related it to Michael Bay three months later at a party five years before Michael Bay made the movie based on his memory of that telling."

Watch it as a double-feature with Spring Breakers.
 
This movie really is very good, there's a lot to get from it.

One thing not to get from it is anything related to any kind of true story. Just take it as "Michael Bay's friend read the NYT review of a book about a true story, then drunkenly related it to Michael Bay three months later at a party five years before Michael Bay made the movie based on his memory of that telling."

Watch it as a double-feature with Spring Breakers.

God what the hell was that about? I put that on on a fridaynight with my friends to pre-booz before going out to party. We didnt even finish it because we all got down and depressed jesus...
 
It was surprisingly not bad for a bay film. I'd even say its his best. I'd personally give it 6 stars outta 10, because the dialogue is still very "bay"
 
God what the hell was that about? I put that on on a fridaynight with my friends to pre-booz before going out to party. We didnt even finish it because we all got down and depressed jesus...

Haha, someone didn't research Harmony Korine beforehand. Saw a ton of frat guys walk out of the theatre halfway through. What a polarizing movie
 
God what the hell was that about? I put that on on a fridaynight with my friends to pre-booz before going out to party. We didnt even finish it because we all got down and depressed jesus...

:D That is exactly not the right setting for that movie. Try and dig up Grantland's Girls in Hoodies podcast about it.

EDIT: or I could do it: http://www.grantland.com/blog/holly...odcast-spring-breakers-beyonce-and-real-world

I really like this podcast generally. I don't get a lot of female perspective on my pop culture podcasts, so this one is really refreshing. Recommended.

Haha, someone didn't research Harmony Korine beforehand. Saw a ton of frat guys walk out of the theatre halfway through. What a polarizing movie

Yeah that movie is not about "watch Selena Gomez and her teen babe friends prance around in bikinis" despite that totally happening a bunch.
 
It's a dark comedy but its not like the characters are portrayed as heroes or likable good guys. They are portrayed as bumbling sociopathic pieces of shit. When you think about it, is it honestly a whole lot different than, say, Goodfellas in a many ways? That movie (among many others) is also about real life assholes whose lives are romanticized in many ways. That scene in Goodfellas where they throw a guy in the trunk and stop at moms house for dinner before burying his body is funny in a very dark way too.

I agree with this pretty much. The marketing of the movie as some Bad Boys style buddy action/comedy gives a different impression of what's actually in the movie. There's no real attempt at making the Sun Gym gang sympathetic.
 
I was really confused with this movie as well. It goes into ridiculous Natural born Killers territory around halfway but only after Bay has made us like the antiheroes and despise the jewish columbian asshole who didn't deserve the money. Then when you actually find out it's a true story it just becomes even more confusing. The Rock and Armageddeon were fine films..this shit sucked.
 
It's impossible to portray something like this in a humorous way without offending people who are close to the real events. It just simply can't be done. The moment you decide to make light of someone's murder, people are going to get offended. It's inevitable.

That said, I loved the movie, but I love Michael Bay, so yeah.
 
On an intellectual level I kinda agree with all the criticism of the movie but I'll be damned if I wasn't really entertained.
 
Hey, Judge Alex from the TV show was the one who did the trial for these assholes.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alex_Ferrer#Sun_Gym_Gang_murder_trials

lhjx4lt.jpg
 
It's a frankly terribly shot and very very average.. the story would've been cool and interesting in the right hands but it ended up just quite boring and overly long, but Kermode has overreacted massively.
 
Movie was fantastic, had no idea it was going to bean oddball, dark comedy and ended up enjoying the hell out of it, as did the rest of my family. The Rock was fantastic.
 
What was that movie with Kenny Powers where the guy had a bomb strapped to him and it was like a comedy even though it was based on an actual thing?
 
This movie really is very good, there's a lot to get from it.

One thing not to get from it is anything related to any kind of true story. Just take it as "Michael Bay's friend read the NYT review of a book about a true story, then drunkenly related it to Michael Bay three months later at a party five years before Michael Bay made the movie based on his memory of that telling."

Watch it as a double-feature with Spring Breakers.

I don't get comments like this...

Are you trying to down play the fact that events like Schiller's actual survival after multiple murder attempts failed, Griga's wife's horse tranq OD, the chopping up of the bodies and the subsequent return of a Chainsaw that required Motor Oil... are you trying to say these more outrageous moments did not happen and were actually nothing more than part of the "story Michael Bay heard while drunk one day"?

I mean, say what you will, and i certainly understand the reasoning behind the added humor beats, and the more sympathetic homicidal leads, and the ending, etc, its a movie after all, but at the same time, You can't deny that many of those outragous moments still occurred similarly to there depictions in the film.
 
I just watched it, LTTP

I loved the movie. I am a Michael Bay hater and I love this movie.

Sorry for real people that it may affect because of it being a true story but damn it is entertaining seeing dumb criminals out dumb themselves
 
Movie would have been fine if it were fiction. As it is it goes to great lengths to remind you over and over that the events actually happened.
 
I went into it knowing it was a true story. Terrible, terrible, terrible choice to make light of someone's attempted murder like this and then glorify the people who did it.

It's even worse that the film kinda sucks.
 
The only thing I was really confused about was Marky Mark's love life.

Like, you see him at the beginning and he feels sorry for himself and doesn't get to hook up with this one really attractive client at the gym. Okay, I guess that's a bummer. But then midway through the story, you find out he actually has this hot stripper girlfriend who's convinced he's a CIA operative? And she's... even hotter than the attractive client. So why was he depressed again? Seems like he's got a good thing going.

And then he just hands his stripper gf over to The Rock. And that confused me as well. That doesn't seem like something a normal person would do.
 
I went into it knowing it was a true story. Terrible, terrible, terrible choice to make light of someone's attempted murder like this and then glorify the people who did it.

It's even worse that the film kinda sucks.

Glorify them? You must have seen the wrong movie.
 
It's still one of my favorite movies of 2013. I expected nothing from it and I got an amazing performance by Dwayne Johnson. I had mixed feelings while watching it because I knew about the actual story behind it, though.
 
I really liked the movie, but yeah, it was kinda wrong.

Where does that leave us though?
Should we feel bad whilst simultaneously acknowledging the film was good?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom