Nope. P4 >>> The rest
Not really though.
Nope. P4 >>> The rest
It's kind of hard to compare them since Persona is so unique. It's basically like 70% visual novel.
Judging both games as just RPGs, Xenoblade is miles better. But that's not really what Persona 4 is.
In what world is Xenoblade better than Persona 4? lmao
The real one. Better battle system, better world, certainly better dungeons, amazing sense of exploration. Xenoblade is a great RPG. Persona 4 is a good RPG and a great visual novel.
Better battle system
Check the outtakes, I think that's where I saw it.What the. I've beaten the game three times and never seen this. Got any links to this on youtube?
Damn, I love seeing RPGs compared to Persona 4 It shows me which ones I should definitely play because they must be great.
The real one. Better battle system, better world, certainly better dungeons, amazing sense of exploration. Xenoblade is a great RPG. Persona 4 is a good RPG and a great visual novel.
Heads up that Persona 3 Portable is $10 on PSN. Persona 2 is $14.99
Can we at least agree that no JRPG in the last 5 years can hold a candle to either Persona 4 or Xenoblade Chronicles?
It's those two titles... and then everything else. (And I say that as an unabashed fan of Tales of Vesperia and Trails in the Sky.)
But... but... JRPG-enthusiast GAF should be all happy and sunshine and gumdrops.No, we can't agree.
Can we at least agree that no JRPG in the last 5 years can hold a candle to either Persona 4 or Xenoblade Chronicles?
It's those two titles... and then everything else. (And I say that as an unabashed fan of Tales of Vesperia and Trails in the Sky.)
The real one. Better battle system, better world, certainly better dungeons, amazing sense of exploration. Xenoblade is a great RPG. Persona 4 is a good RPG and a great visual novel.
The real one. Better battle system, better world, certainly better dungeons, amazing sense of exploration. Xenoblade is a great RPG. Persona 4 is a good RPG and a great visual novel.
Qualifications aside, Persona 4 is objectively a better game than Xenoblade.The real one. Better battle system, better world, certainly better dungeons, amazing sense of exploration. Xenoblade is a great RPG. Persona 4 is a good RPG and a great visual novel.
Better dundeons, debatable.
Qualifications aside, Persona 4 is objectively a better game than Xenoblade.
Persona 4 is FACTUALLY in every way possible a better game than Xenoblade and any other JRPG. And everyone will DEAL
Are you fucking kidding me. How can you even compare Xenoblade world design and dungeons to P4 town made of 4 tiny ass ugly screens and a bunch of ugly random generated dungeons.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H47ow4_Cmk0
Qualifications aside, Persona 4 is objectively a better game than Xenoblade.
They're both exceptionally good at what they do but there's little point in comparing them since they're so different.
Exactly. When it comes to exploration, both Persona 4 and Xenoblade are weak. Xenoblade has proper dungeons and aesthetically appealing open areas and vistas, but then side quests are boring, copy&paste fetchs/hunts.Definitely a better world, and better dungeons, but where is this amazing sense of exploration?
The world is indeed beautiful, but there really isn't much to discover in Xenoblade. Wandering around and looking for glowing white dots isn't what I would consider great exploration.
Just a big, beautiful, empty world.
The hell? Why has this become a Xenoblade Vs Persona 4 topic? While they are both technically JRPG's, the mechanics, style and setting are completely different. They may as well be different genre's since they both have quite different strengths and weaknesses.
Besides both are absolutely amazing games, and among the very few I would ever consider a ten out of ten. Comparing these two just feels wrong
Yeah, by pandering to the lowest common denominator with waifus and animu hijinks. Those are the things that make a better videogame.
Are people really arguing that Persona 4 has anything approaching a great battle system?
It's a good (great, even) game in other regards, of course, but it is incredibly dry when it comes to battling.
The real one. Better battle system, better world, certainly better dungeons, amazing sense of exploration. Xenoblade is a great RPG. Persona 4 is a good RPG and a great visual novel.
God damn GAF. More money spent. So this releases 20th November? And with Play Asia can i expect this before Xmas?
Yes and yes. If you order it now you can probably expect it the first week of December, or if you're lucky, around the 27th of November.
Objectively: impartially, neutrally, fairly, justly, without prejudice, dispassionately, with an open mind, equitably, without fear or favour, even-handedly, without bias, disinterestedly, with objectivity or impartialityYour misuse of the word "objectively" really brings your well-made point home.
Not to get caught up in this silly debate, but disagree here. I'd take P4's battles over just about any RPG out there (Except Witcher 2).
Ninthing defense force out in full I see... Xenoblade is mediocre crap, just because you guys didn't have crap to play on doesn't mean is the best thing EVAR! offline mmorpg is so cool guys, it is not cliched at all, the battle system is so cool and the dialogue doesn't make me tear my ears and stab my eyes at all!