Alice, no contest. Of course I haven't played the other games, but I loved the original American McGee's Alice. Madness returns was good too.
The original was done in a time when we still had AAA pc exclusives and this was one of them. A 3rd person platformer from one of the guys who made the doom and quake maps.
Was on Quake 3 engine, and was so unique and disturbing. Was a great game and character.
Sucks that I can't play either on Steam Deck as EA has removed the games from steam, and I no longer have a cd/dvd rom drive to access my original disks.