• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Properly capturing retro console footage via Elgato (I'm a first timer)

Hey all. So for the past few months I've been experimenting with the Elgato Game Capture HD device for the purposes of taking screenshots for my gaming blog. I'm new to the whole recording thing, so naturally there's some things that've gone wonky.

Lately I've been attempting to capture footage/screens of older, non-HDMI games (mostly on Gamecube/Wii), which for Elgato requires some external devices. Unfortunately, most of my recordings look rather...inadequate, to put it kindly. I've posted a couple screens below alongside their respective capturing devices, with Zelda: The Wind Waker as a model.


Elgato's own Analog Video Adapter provided the above shot. Reduced to the size within the quote, it's fine, but the problem lies in how the TV display is outputted to a far blurrier resolution (click on the screenshot to see it's normal size and you'll see what I mean).


Elgato's own site recommended the Hosim AV to HDMI converter, which renders the game far brighter than it should be. Far from ideal too, and I actually hadn't noticed that lone black bar to the left until just now.

For clarification, I've been using my HD Vizio TV for play while recording on a HP Pavilion laptop, and the Sony Bravia television upstairs produced the same results. At college I did use my own computer (Windows) when recording Majora's Mask (on Wii VC), which from what I recall had good quality too but we're planning to use that comp for my own office upstairs, so unless the problem lies in the computer of choice I'm not sure I can move it willy-nilly.

I suppose what I'm asking is it possible to take cleaner shots/footage while also maintaining good picture quality on the TV? I've noticed the recording lags a few seconds behind, so looking only at the computer screen is no good. I've fiddled around with the settings and have yet to come up with a solution, so I'm open to whatever advice some of you may have (barring purchasing another recording device; I have money to throw around, but I don't think I want to drop another couple hundred bucks unless it's absolutely necessary).

For the record, I have captured footage for Wii U games as well and stuff like bloom is practically absent whereas jaggies are more apparent. I can provide screens of Smash Wii U if it helps.
 
You're going to want to be recording with component cables in progressive scan for GameCube and Wii games if you want any semblance of quality.

As for Wii U games I recommend knowing the native resolution of the game so let's say Smash Bros Wii U (1080p, 60fps) or Bayonetta 2 (720p, 60fps) and recording to whatever they natively run at and then go from there.

Edit: Also overscan is something you're going to have to deal with for Wii and GameCube games (or any SD console really), nothing you can do about that just have to remove the black bars in either the video editing or photo editing phase (whatever you plan on doing)
 
I would rather get a different capture device as I never trusted the Elgato, but I'll talk about some things with your pics. Is your 1st pic taken with composite? Composite is a no no if so, go svideo at least because composite is blurry.

AV to HDMI Converters tend to have issues, but being that bright is ridiculous. Might have to get a different one like a Portta or something.
 
Might consider a home theater receiver. I have an Onkyo that will happily bring composite and component up to HDMI (with scaling to 1080p). I can't say the quality would be much better than what you're already getting but don't forget that the source material is pretty low resolution with older games.
 
You're going to want to be recording with component cables in progressive scan for GameCube and Wii games if you want any semblance of quality.

As for Wii U games I recommend knowing the native resolution of the game so let's say Smash Bros Wii U (1080p, 60fps) or Bayonetta 2 (720p, 60fps) and recording to whatever they natively run at and then go from there.

Edit: Also overscan is something you're going to have to deal with for Wii and GameCube games (or any SD console really), nothing you can do about that just have to remove the black bars in either the video editing or photo editing phase (whatever you plan on doing)

Guess I'll have to look into components, then.

I'm okay with overscan/black bars so long as they don't stand out like they do in the second shot.

I would rather get a different capture device as I never trusted the Elgato, but I'll talk about some things with your pics. Is your 1st pic taken with composite? Composite is a no no if so, go svideo at least because composite is blurry.

AV to HDMI Converters tend to have issues, but being that bright is ridiculous. Might have to get a different one like a Portta or something.

Yeah it's compositive; didn't know they were so bad for this, lol. I'll check into your other suggestions.

Might consider a home theater receiver. I have an Onkyo that will happily bring composite and component up to HDMI (with scaling to 1080p). I can't say the quality would be much better than what you're already getting but don't forget that the source material is pretty low resolution with older games.

I'm aware of that, but at the very least I just want my screenshots to look presentable, LOL. I'll look into Onkyo if the other suggestions don't work out.
 
I do XRGB Mini to capture card for best results but that will set you back a few hundred. :-/

This will give you very crisp results, however. Far better than any cheaper option.
 
I know this isn't quite what you're looking for, but the WiiU has HDMI on it, and can play WiiU, Gamecube, and Wii games. Might be worth shelling out the $200-$250 for a refurbished WiiU from Nintendo so you can have perfect digital out instead of the $100-$150, or whatever it is for the analog to digital converter.
 
I know this isn't quite what you're looking for, but the WiiU has HDMI on it, and can play WiiU, Gamecube, and Wii games. Might be worth shelling out the $200-$250 for a refurbished WiiU from Nintendo so you can have perfect digital out instead of the $100-$150, or whatever it is for the analog to digital converter.

I thought the wii u couldn't play gc games just wii.
 
Guess I'll have to look into components, then.

I'm okay with overscan/black bars so long as they don't stand out like they do in the second shot.

They're really easy to remove with a free image editing program like Gimp if you only care about screenshots (all you need to do is use the crop tool), looks a lot more professional with little effort:
http://www.gimp.org
 
Just bought some component cables for Wii and it should arrive by Saturday. I'll update this thread by then with some results.

They're really easy to remove with a free image editing program like Gimp if you only care about screenshots (all you need to do is use the crop tool), looks a lot more professional with little effort:
http://www.gimp.org

Thank you, I'll definitely keep that in mind.

I know this isn't quite what you're looking for, but the WiiU has HDMI on it, and can play WiiU, Gamecube, and Wii games. Might be worth shelling out the $200-$250 for a refurbished WiiU from Nintendo so you can have perfect digital out instead of the $100-$150, or whatever it is for the analog to digital converter.

Well as mentioned in the OP I already own a Wii U...LOL. I'll check the Wii games to see if they look any better (Xenoblade had the same problems seen in the shots I provided).
 
Top Bottom