I'd love to see a RPG in a normal, modern setting, without magic, saving the world, steampunk a MC who has or gets superpowers and all those stuff. Kinda like GTA just as a RPG.
A setting I want is the option to mute all other players in PS3 and XBox Live.
A setting I would like to see is a World War 2 shooter, from the perspective of the Germans. Since game developers are pushing the limits of what they can get away with on the offensive side (Laura Croft rape), why not let us play as the bad guy for a change? I actually think it would be very interesting to play as a protagonist in an unstoppable army that eventually falls apart and becomes a desperate battle for survival.
Actually I even wanted to mention PE, exactly what I'm looking for except use of magic/powers. Instead of using fire spells just gimme a flame thrower. Basically I want a RPG in a normal modern setting without any supernatural bullshit or cringe-worthy bigger than life storyline.
Funny you say that. There was this old PC/DOS game called "Jones" I played around with back in the day. It wasn't exactly an RPG in the sense of battles, skill trees, etc. But you had to find a place to live, work, pay rent, eat, etc. It wasn't the greatest sim on the market or anything, but was a genuinely interesting concept. Check it out sometime.