• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Sin City 2 is finally happening.

Status
Not open for further replies.
to be fair, shoot 'em up was incredible

Shoot em Up was incredible because of how ridiculous and over the top it was. It was basically a movie that took every cliche, turned it to 11, and then circled back around and turned it back to 11 again. It was so stupid and over the top that it was genius.
 
Is Rodriguez tired of wasting his time with that Spy Kids crap? :P Seriously, enough with that.

Since the original:

Dead - Brittany Murphy
Career is dead - Clive Owen, Bruce Willis, Rosario Dawson, Elijah Wood, Alexis Bledel, Devon Aoki, Nick Stahl, Marley Shelton, Michael Madsen, Josh Hartnett, Jaime King
Crazy and stoned - Mickey Rourke
Vanished to parts unknown - Benecio Del Toro, Jessica Alba
Banished to TV land - Michael Clarke Duncan, Carla Gugino
Still a boss - Rutger Hauer, Powers Boothe
Had a meltdown - Frank Miller

Do not want.

When you put it like that...lolz

I guess too little too late. Clive Own btw wouldn't even have a big part in this since IIRC he has a difference face in the other stories, or something like that.
 
Since the original:

Dead - Brittany Murphy
Vanished to parts unknown - Benecio Del Toro, Jessica Alba

Britttany's character isn't really going to make an appearance, so she doesn't really matter.

Benecio Del Toro's career is going to be made or broken by how good Star Trek 2 is.

Alba still is a big name, though, just because she's still pretty.
 
Britttany's character isn't really going to make an appearance, so she doesn't really matter.

Benecio Del Toro's career is going to be made or broken by how good Star Trek 2 is.

Alba still is a big name, though, just because she's still pretty.

Del Toro won't be in Star Trek 2. He bailed. :\
 
Does it matter what happened to the actors in the first movie? I haven't read the comics, but I understand that they're mostly unconnected short stories. They could just go with stories about other characters if they can't get the old actors.

Sin City had a bunch of actors who were relevant in 2005, so just do the same thing again and get a bunch of actors who are relevant today for Sin City 2.
 
Dead as disco.

tumblr_lb545uHPP81qapzdmo1_500.png
 
Why does it matter if their careers are dead? Doesn't make them worse actors. It's not like baseball where you are passed your prime. If anything it will just make it easier to get them.
 
hmm not sure i can get excited for this one... the first was great and innovative, i hope this won't just be more of the same... then again how can it not?

I assume they are going with the same esthetic?
 
Isn't Frank is a nut now? The film will probably full of Muslims blowing themselves up and american flags everywhere.

I feel bad for Frank. He legitimately lost his mind, and understandably so. He was actually IN Manhatten while 9/11 happened.

To add insult to injury, he was writing the sequel to DKR. Here is a sequence in DKR from 10 years before where Gotham (aka New York at night) starts to descend to anarchy. Note the plane.

Click for big.

Click for big.


So. You wrote a story where a city descends to chaos and a plane ramming a building causes things to get worse.

10 years later You start writing the sequel in Manhatten. And TWO planes slam into the buildings next door and the city (and the country) descends to madness. AND Miller's a lapsed Catholic.

The human mind can only take so many coincidences before it breaks down and starts seeing patterns in the insanity. I can't say what HE felt, but I'd probably feel that God himself was giving me a goddamn message. And so would most of us, in that moment of mental collapsing. "How did I predict this? Is my work imitating life? Am I going insane? Is the world telling me something? Is God punishing me? Is God warning me? WHAT DOES THIS ALL MEAN?" etc.

Miller's complete and total collapse from somewhat anarchistic-peace-through violent overthrow into full blown rightwing warhawk liberal-hating conservative was very, very sad to watch. He was always somewhat authoritarian, but 9/11 pushed him straight off the edge to full blown "If you're not with us, you're against us" authority.
 
^ That doesn't give me a lot of confidence for the film, but t'is a sad story.

I don't think it'll ruin the film TOO much. There's little to no Muslim terrorist presence in Sin City, the corruption is traditional American mafia old money and how it infects everyone from cops to politicians.

The stories are all about the average (albeit super-tough and moral) joes doing what they can to survive a corrupt city where no one is honest. Terrorism doesn't really fit those themes.

While Miller is insane, I doubt he'd rewrite his own material to change the core themes that made him famous in the first place.
 
To those who say Miller should stay away from the script, you do realise that Sin City was pretty much verbatim what was in the comics?
 
just open with alexis bledel getting shot from hartnell.

mmm, bledel is so cute

fFHiL.jpg


as a button
I swear, there's a girl who works at the bakery at the local Publix who looks like her. I hope Bledel is back. And I hope they keep the same art style the first movie had. Or something very similar at least.

I can't believe the first one released in 2005, it's been that long? Time flies. Marv was so awesome, one of my favorite characters in the movie. I'm ready for a part 2.
 
What's amusing is that Mickey Rourke, who was still a faded, down-and-out actor when Sin City was released, is currently doing much better career-wise than most of the rest of the cast.
 
Since the original:

Dead - Brittany Murphy
Career is dead - Clive Owen, Bruce Willis, Rosario Dawson, Elijah Wood, Alexis Bledel, Devon Aoki, Nick Stahl, Marley Shelton, Michael Madsen, Josh Hartnett, Jaime King
Crazy and stoned - Mickey Rourke
Vanished to parts unknown - Benecio Del Toro, Jessica Alba
Banished to TV land - Michael Clarke Duncan, Carla Gugino
Still a boss - Rutger Hauer, Powers Boothe
Had a meltdown - Frank Miller

Do not want.

... i don't understand the relevancy of this list. why does it matter what an actor has been doing in the mean time?

and willis is going to be in moonrise kingdom and looper this year. those two look very cool.
 
Since the original:

Dead - Brittany Murphy
Career is dead - Clive Owen, Bruce Willis, Rosario Dawson, Elijah Wood, Alexis Bledel, Devon Aoki, Nick Stahl, Marley Shelton, Michael Madsen, Josh Hartnett, Jaime King
Crazy and stoned - Mickey Rourke
Vanished to parts unknown - Benecio Del Toro, Jessica Alba
Banished to TV land - Michael Clarke Duncan, Carla Gugino
Still a boss - Rutger Hauer, Powers Boothe
Had a meltdown - Frank Miller

Do not want.

Since this post, Nick Stahl has literally vanished to parts unknown.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom