• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

'Star Wars' universe gets its first gay character

Status
Not open for further replies.

MiszMasz

Member
giphy.gif

n4ee4571c6e017.jpg


I can picture the entire scene and context for this but i'm still made uncomfortable by that gif.
 

Blizzard

Banned
I'm surprised no one has mentioned Gwendoline Christie yet -- isn't she supposed to play
an Imperial? If so I'm sad if she doesn't end up using a lightsaber for Jedi / Sith powers. She had some cool longsword sequences in Game of Thrones.
 

Sai-kun

Banned
Yeah. We need to get to the point where people don't worry about how to write a gay character, because the sexuality is not what defines people as a whole. Gays can be good, bad, friendly, mean, strong, weak - like every other human being, because they're just that.

Still laughing about the reaction to the homosexual Dumbledore thing were people were mad and claimed that there were never any indication. Why would there? Just because he liked men he didn't need to wear pink scarf or tight leather pants. He isn't defined by his sexuality.

Because saying "this character is gay!" after the books are done with literally zero indicator that the character is queer DOESNT COUNT as representation.

It doesn't count.

And honestly, fuck off with the bolded. That's so rude and that's hardly the only way to show homosexuality.

Also to whoever said that characters that don't explicitly state their sexuality could be gay: that doesn't count either and I refuse to settle for that kind of representation. It's bullshit and you know it.
 

Chariot

Member
I'm more bothered by that sort of announcement being more of a "tell and don't show".

Why couldn't Dumbledore have shown actual moments of his sexual orientation in a relationship like the rest of the characters in the series if it's not really that big of a deal?

Just seemed like a missed opportunity for such a massively popular character.
While she certainly could've dropped some more hints, I think he was just too old, plus mostly around pupils. We didn't get any relationship drop from any of the other teachers and I think, it's ok.

But it would certainly be funny if Harry or anyone asked somebody if Dumbledore ever got a wife and just earn heartfelt chuckles at answer."No, not a wife."
Because saying "this character is gay!" after the books are done with literally zero indicator that the character is queer DOESNT COUNT as representation.

It doesn't count.

And honestly, fuck off with the bolded. That's so rude and that's hardly the only way to show homosexuality.

Also to whoever said that characters that don't explicitly state their sexuality could be gay: that doesn't count either and I refuse to settle for that kind of representation. It's bullshit and you know it.
You should know that I deliberately choose such blatant symbols of gay people to make a point. And please, hold back a bit, I feel uncomfortable to reply to you with that tone.
 
It's nice to see a formal acknowledgement that gay people actually do exist in the new canon of Star Wars. But damn if announcements like this don't always bring out the same old "they have to justify it/why are they shoving this agenda down our troats for attention/how do you kno all other unspecified characters aren't gay" bullshit.

And please, hold back a bit, I feel uncomfortable to reply to you with that tone.
I have alerted the nearest branch of the Tone PD. This scoundrel won't get away with using anything but the most acceptable of tones.
 

JC Lately

Member
Cant wait ‘till all the neckbeards crawl out their basements to decry this as ‘shoving diversity down their throats’ or whatever, right before alt-tabbing over to their tumblr feed full of Leia/Padme or female Twi'lek-on-female-Twi'lek porn with nary a shred of irony on their minds.
 

antonz

Member
I like how they reference the lack of stuff but then say well in the expanded universe they had such and such but fans don't care about the expanded universe.

Yet the article is all about a book in the new expanded universe so why would it matter if "fans don't care"
 

ship it

Member
Cant wait ‘till all the neckbeards crawl out their basements to decry this as ‘shoving diversity down their throats’ or whatever, right before alt-tabbing over to their tumblr feed full of Leia/Padme or female Twi'lek-on-female-Twi'lek porn with nary a shred of irony on their minds.

good, let the hate flow through you
 

AxelFoley

Member
Someone probably beat me to it, but I see hilarity ensuing naming a lesbian character Moff Mors. Yeah, I know "Moff" is a title, but it's close enough to"muff". LOL
 
wait, they went through all the trouble of making all the books, games, tv specials etc non canon to make that universe as clean as possible

but they're still gonna make more fucking books?

who's to say this won't become non canon 25 years from now
 
Turning the Empire into an equal opportunity employer is so fucking stupid. You think the Nazis or Soviet Russia (or hell modern Russia) would tolerate this? The Empire in the movies was always very traditional republican and this shit Disney is doing is ruining the villains.
 

JC Lately

Member
Turning the Empire into an equal opportunity employer is so fucking stupid. You think the Nazis or Soviet Russia (or hell modern Russia) would tolerate this? The Empire in the movies was always very traditional republican and this shit Disney is doing is ruining the villains.

The whole ‘Palpatine is a sexist and human supremacist’ was a hand wave thought up by EU authors to explain why all the imperial officers in the original trilogy were human and male (also white). If you think about it, a Sith-run empire would respect power and ability over species or gender (or sexual orientation). The positions of power in the Empire ought to have been open to all with skill to hack it and the will/power to take it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom