• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Steam Announces Family Sharing

Orayn

Member
so, couldn't people just use a remote desktop client prior to that?

Yes, though that's still a bit more of a hassle and/or security concern than just being able to authorize a remote computer without your account ever logging onto it.

Essentially, it's a more secure, convenient form of credential sharing, but only if you're willing to do inconvenient, insecure credential sharing at least once.

Rather limited, but still something I'd do with a few of my close friends.
 
Microsoft am cry.

This is literally exactly what I came in to post. Glad to see it so early in the thread, though it should have been the first post! Pretty much a megaton imo, this is everything MS promised without forcing you into an always-on walled garden.

But yeah, obviously there are going to be limitations to how it works - still, this is just what has been announced in the beta. I'm curious to see where it evolves over time.
 

L.O.R.D

Member
cnzf6q4.gif
 

Drkirby

Corporate Apologist
One minor thing I am not sure on. Lets say I want to play more Dota 2, but want to let someone else actually use the other 500 games I have purchased. If I go to play Dota, will the other person still be able to use my games, or are not allowed at all while playing Dota? Am I allowed to share my games and be logged in at the same time?
 

Khaz

Member
Haven't read the whole thread, someone probably already pointed it out but:

This is just an officialisation of what you could already do with your account, with the added security of no password sharing. When I log into Steam at a friend's, I can download and play any of my games. I usually forget to log out so he can continue to play my games, until I log back on my own computer. This family sharing allows exactly the same thing except my friend will use his account instead of mine, and can log back when I'm finished without having to know my password.

It's very good, and most certainly not what Microsoft was planning.


By typing that I realise I already had a similar discussion a few months ago. Didn't this feature get leaked in the past?


One minor thing I am not sure on. Lets say I want to play more Dota 2, but want to let someone else actually use the other 500 games I have purchased. If I go to play Dota, will the other person still be able to use my games, or are not allowed at all while playing Dota? Am I allowed to share my games and be logged in at the same time?

If I understand correctly it's an account sharing, not a game sharing. You momentarily give away your rights on your account so your friend can use it.
 

Orayn

Member
One minor thing I am not sure on. Lets say I want to play more Dota 2, but want to let someone else actually use the other 500 games I have purchased. If I go to play Dota, will the other person still be able to use my games, or are not allowed at all while playing Dota? Am I allowed to share my games and be logged in at the same time?

As someone with a secret extra Steam account, I think F2P games installed on a machine are always considered to belong to whoever is logged in. It would be great if they made an exception, but I think the simplest possible definition of "library" would include your Dota 2 credentials as "your copy" of Dota 2.

If I understand correctly it's an account sharing, not a game sharing. You momentarily give away your rights on your account so your friend can use it.

It is game sharing, just all-or-nothing game sharing. You can log into your account and do non-game things without booting someone who's currently accessing your library.
 
I wish this had come out before my brother unlocked three Steam achievements when I let him play BioShock Infinite!

It's cool. I would have unlocked them on my second playthrough, anyway.

Good to know I can let him play Saints Row IV / Sleeping Dogs without him messing with my account any further, though.
 

zainetor

Banned
This is literally exactly what I came in to post. Glad to see it so early in the thread, though it should have been the first post! Pretty much a megaton imo, this is everything MS promised without forcing you into an always-on walled garden.
But yeah, obviously there are going to be limitations to how it works - still, this is just what has been announced in the beta. I'm curious to see where it evolves over time.

you must be online to use the sharing, i think.
I just hope you can deactivate it and go offline.
 

Stuggernaut

Grandma's Chippy
Pretty limited to start off. But it is a great step in the right direction.

My daughter's husband buys a ton of Steam games I don't, and he never buys what I do. We can share libraries now and play a lot of stuff we normally would not.

We work opposite shifts for work so we would almost never cross paths for our gaming time.

Should work out nice.
 

Saty

Member
Have no problems with the one person restriction but if it's correct that the game owner has to initially physically use my computer to log in into his account before he'll be able to share games with me, then that's far less enticing.
 

Zhengi

Member
Pretty awesome. I'm definitely interested. Plus, I have so many games from the humble bundle and other sources that I don't even have time to play through and getting this will help me try out games my friends and family have that I don't.
 
Have no problems with the one person restriction but if it's correct that the game owner has to initially physically use my computer to log in into his account before he'll be able to share games with me, then that's far less enticing.

It says that you just send an electronic request.
 

Orayn

Member
Have no problems with the one person restriction but if it's correct that the game owner has to initially physically use my computer to log in into his account before he'll be able to share games with me, then that's far less enticing.

Well, the owner could also give you their password or do it by remotely controlling your computer, but yeah, that's effectively the same thing.

It says that you just send an electronic request.

...But only if one of your games has already been installed on that computer the request is coming from, according to Valve.
 
To put an end to all the account sharing hype:

Question:


Answer from Valve:


http://steamcommunity.com/groups/familysharing/discussions/0/846964363936308178/

This is pretty contradictory to this:

How do I enable Family Sharing on my computer?
Family Sharing is enabled in one of two ways: You can either locally enable sharing in Account Settings, with Family Sharing & Devices, or remotely respond to a user’s Steam request to share your previously installed games via email.
 

PureGone

Banned
Can share library but cant play games at the same time. Well i better find a friend
"family"
in a different time zone.
 
did you not read anything?

Ya, I read it all. But this is what confuses me ...

Share your computer?
Now share your games too.

I read that as, same computer different Steam accounts. Plus it says you have to share your entire library, not selected games.

Where does it specifically say I can let a friend on a different computer on a different subnet borrow my games?

Sorry if I missed something.
 

Orayn

Member
Ya, I read it all. But this is what confuses me ...

Share your computer?
Now share your games too.

I read that as, same computer different Steam accounts. Plus it says you have to share your entire library, not selected games.

Where does it specifically say I can let a friend on a different computer on a different subnet borrow my games?

Sorry if I missed something.

It says that a friend can request access to your library if you've already installed a game on their computer.

You do share your entire library, but everyone gets to use their own account.
 

eastmen

Banned
Very cool, I've been wanting this ever since the XB1 mentioned their similar service.

Which I still want back :-

I wonder if you'll be able to get cards
Yup microsoft had so many awsome features that were just killed off for no reason. Now I can just laugh whem someone trys and claim xbox one game sharing was just demos. This proves publishers would have been on board
 
So I have to give my friend my Steam username and password, let him install the game I want to share with him, get him to log off from my steam, log on to his steam and send the request to play the game to me?

If the game must be installed on friends PC its a major pain in the ass.
 

Orayn

Member
So I have to give my friend my Steam username and password, let him install the game I want to share with him, get him to log off from my steam, log on to his steam and send the request to play the game to me?

If the game must be installed on friends PC its a major pain in the ass.

That's the way it looks right now, yeah. I figure Valve will either remove this restriction or clamp down even more when they realize that plenty of people will do this.
 

Enco

Member
So I have to give my friend my Steam username and password, let him install the game I want to share with him, get him to log off from my steam, log on to his steam and send the request to play the game to me?

If the game must be installed on friends PC its a major pain in the ass.
Wait, that's what it is?

If so, pretty shitty implementation. Not surprising coming from Valve.

edit:

CAN A FRIEND AND I SHARE A LIBRARY AND BOTH PLAY AT THE SAME TIME?
No, a shared library may only be accessed by one user at a time.
So we can't even play different games at the same time? lol
 

Sibylus

Banned
So I have to give my friend my Steam username and password, let him install the game I want to share with him, get him to log off from my steam, log on to his steam and send the request to play the game to me?

If the game must be installed on friends PC its a major pain in the ass.
You don't have to share your credentials with him if you're doing a Remote Desktop Connection, just launch Steam, punch in your username/password, uncheck the option to remember those credentials, and then proceed with the installs and requests.
 

Saty

Member
That's the way it looks right now, yeah. I figure Valve will either remove this restriction or clamp down even more when they realize that plenty of people will do this.

But it doesn't make sense. If it's so simple to bypass this restriction, and most will, then why put it in the first place?
 

Sibylus

Banned
Oh, and the wording implies that you only have to have one game installed on the given computer to gain access to the entire library ("access, download and play").
 

Orayn

Member
But it doesn't make sense. If it's so simple to bypass this restriction, and most will, then why put it in the first place?

Well, it's not so simple. Maybe they want it that way because they're not ready for this to be a full-blown "share with whoever" system yet.
 

PG2G

Member
Yup microsoft had so many awsome features that were just killed off for no reason. Now I can just laugh whem someone trys and claim xbox one game sharing was just demos. This proves publishers would have been on board

Pretty much, thanks guys!

Well, I'm sure it'll come back for digital purchases.
 

plainr_

Member
This is great news. My only complaint about Stream before was being unable to share games between profiles on a single machine. At one point, I almost made a thread specifically about this issue.

I'm glad Valve can read my mind. :lol
 

TheTrain

Member
So...if i share my library with my brother, i can't play anything with steam online.
But i don't need to stay online for share my Library...so i can put steam in offline mode and continue my playthrough.
That is...beautiful.
 

Sibylus

Banned
Well, it's not so simple. Maybe they want it that way because they're not ready for this to be a full-blown "share with whoever" system yet.
It builds an inherent bias into the system that favors accounts that have purchased major releases on Steam before, given that they'll have higher odds of already having a game installed that the lender's library also has.
 

Blizzard

Banned
This could be a cool idea for some people, and I imagine will lead to big message board community areas where people try to be on certain friends lists to demo/play games.

I do hope it doesn't result in more restricted or more broken offline mode, though.
 
Top Bottom