fluffydelusions
Member
Ds4 is good but no native drivers plus button prompts for 99% of games make me stick with my xb1 controller.
-
Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!
The best PC gaming controller according to The Wirecutter is....
- Thread starter entremet
- Start date
Dawg, this is literally what I want. I've been scouting online stores for some bootleg controllers and I've never come across six face buttons on a twin stick pad of any type. Why has no one done this yet?
Not sure what these no driver complaints are coming from literally just connect a DS4 to a PC (either via Bluetooth or micro USB cable) and Windows instantly recognizes it as a gamepad and installs the necessary drivers.
I use it for PCSX2 constantly and I have literally done nothing but plug it into a USB port. Shows up in control panel as a generic controller.
I use it for PCSX2 constantly and I have literally done nothing but plug it into a USB port. Shows up in control panel as a generic controller.
PlayALLtheGames
Banned
I've used both XB1 and DS4 and I'm honestly not sure I have a favorite. Actually, I primarily used my DS4 but then I spilled a glass of bourbon on it; now I use the XB1. It's at least as good because I haven't been able to tell a noticeable difference. Maybe I preferred the softer triggers on the DS4 but that's about it.
StrangeTaco
Member
It's a nice controller but for PC? Yeah no sorry no dice.
360 controller if you want something cheap and don't care about the D-pad.
Elite if you want the best.
360 controller if you want something cheap and don't care about the D-pad.
Elite if you want the best.
TemplaerDude
Member
I dunno, seems kind of a personal choice. I gotta have offset sticks, the XB1 controller works fine.
+1
VlaudTheImpaler
tl;dr
First someone was murdered in the woods behind my house and now this... The day just keeps getting stranger and stranger.
Also,
It's great though isn't it? Best money I have ever spent on a controller by a huge margin.
Also,
It's great though isn't it? Best money I have ever spent on a controller by a huge margin.
Spacejaws
Member
Steam controller for functionality and customizability.
And leagues behind its DS4 for me for comfort. Elite feels great and as someone who gamed on PC with a 360 controller for years there is something about the DS4 that makes it a great controller. Not sure if its the button placement/size and responsiveness but something about it makes me think the xbox pad is a hunk of cheap derivative plastic.
And leagues behind its DS4 for me for comfort. Elite feels great and as someone who gamed on PC with a 360 controller for years there is something about the DS4 that makes it a great controller. Not sure if its the button placement/size and responsiveness but something about it makes me think the xbox pad is a hunk of cheap derivative plastic.
Mushroomer25
Member
How does the need to set up macros not make it objectively worse?
Most people just want to plug in a controller and go. It doesn't take a ton of time to set one up, but the lack of native prompts and inherent unreliability makes it a real hard sell as 'the best'.
Especially with something like the Elite on the market.
I wish more devs would allow selectable UI prompts in their games, it's a small feature, but makes it feel more PC like when you have a choice for that, games like Assassin's Creed Unity, Far Cry 4, Hotline Miami 2, etc, all allow this on PC to switch between Xbox and PlayStation prompts, and a lot of modders include the options for it in their work, but some studios just don't consider it.
There was one a few years back. actually.
Hori Pad Ex Turbo 2 <--- Best third party controllers in the market.
professor_t
Member
I'm going to let everyone in on a little secret: far fewer people would have paid attention to their little article if they had picked the obvious and correct answer: The Xbone controller.
alife
Member
DS4 with Xbox One controller sticks is pretty nice. Some games have native DS4 support with PS button maps. And when other games still display Xbox button maps on the screen, it really does not bother me. Remembering Square = X, Triangle = Y, Circle = B, and Cross = A isn't a big deal.
entremet
Member
The Wirecutter doesn't run ads or do pay per click models.
tiggerkiddo
Member
Would try it on PC but the Xbox One pad being pretty plug and play for my PC means I probably won't bother sadly with the PS4 one.
Crimsonclaw111
Member
With that battery life? Lmao
You plug it in. Still how it can be better than either Xbox controller when it's not natively supported is pretty suspect. Not to mention I think the Xbox controllers feels a million times better.
There was one a few years back. actually.
Hori Pad Ex Turbo 2 <--- Best third party controllers in the market.
My brother has this, but I don't really like the feel of it at all lol. Still, the layout is great for fighters, and my brother has no issues with it.
metalhead79
Neo Member
Steam Controller
selfconfessedcynic
Member
Even with driver issues, IMO the PS4 is definitely the best standard (ie not tricked-out) controller for PC. I keep falling in love with it again whenever I return to my ps4.
That said, the Xbox One Elite controller is - I would hazard to say - objectively the best mass-produced gaming controller ever made. If not certainly the best, it's definitely in the running.
So yeah, good picks for best controller and best upgrade (they usually give "best" to best bang-for-the-buck and "best upgrade" to all-round-best).
That said, the Xbox One Elite controller is - I would hazard to say - objectively the best mass-produced gaming controller ever made. If not certainly the best, it's definitely in the running.
So yeah, good picks for best controller and best upgrade (they usually give "best" to best bang-for-the-buck and "best upgrade" to all-round-best).
They're interested in people visiting the site no matter what methodology they use for income. Hell, the site could operate at a pure loss as a hobby of a billionaire and they'd still want people to drive traffic to the site, otherwise they wouldn't make a website.
You literally plug it in and windows recognizes it as a generic gamepad. That's it.
DS4 Windows just adds extra goodies like Xbox controller mappings and using the touchpad as a mouse.
Right?!
I liked the DS4 for my PC but once the X1 wireless receiver was released I swapped. Couldn't stand to charge it all the time, I ended up having a USB cable run across my living room. But I guess the average person doesn't play on the PC from their couch.
Jawbreaker
Member
I still use a 360 pad for PC gaming, but I'll always break out the DS4 if I'm playing emulated Sony games or games that rely on the d-pad.
Seeing people shout at each other for apparently having the "Wrong" controller or that their opinion is wrong is funny, that's the joy of PC Gaming, you can use any controller you want as long as it connects, and luckily, current Xbox/PlayStation controllers connect fine, even the Wii U Pro Controller works! Let people use whatever controller they like, it's their freedom of choice here, people don't need to be told they're using the wrong one because you prefer a different option.
Spring-Loaded
Member
Lion Heart
Banned
Agreed its the best, but I find myself using the Bone controller since I have the wireless adapter. If I could have it wireless it would be used exclusively.
TheSaddestSort
Member
Ha, no. X360 controller still has that crown.
AlphaDragoon
Member
Hahaha no. Wii U Pro Controller or Xbone Controller all day every day. I don't even like using the DS4 on my PS4.
packy34
Member
The Xbox One controller isn't comfortable in my hand at all.
Teletraan1
Banned
I use it but I would probably rather have something with a better battery life and proper prompts. The battery life on all my DS4s is maybe 4-5 hours. I usually have it plugged into a charger behind my chair it got so obnoxious. The prompts thing I am pretty much adjusted to but obviously would take actual button prompts.
RandomSeed
Member
It's funny how the DS4 is a better PC controller than a PS4 controller. Most PS4 games don't use the track pad for much, but you can set up all sorts of custom swipes and touches with it for games on PC. Never having to go into the radial menu in Witcher 3 to change signs is one example.
Nice. Sadly not wireless though, at least from that pic. Really surprised there hasn't been more, I'm kind of over the SNES-style 2x2 button layout... really messes with arcade games.There was one a few years back. actually.
Hori Pad Ex Turbo 2 <--- Best third party controllers in the market.
Lion Heart
Banned
LMAO