Clevinger said:
I don't think that was really dishonest or an attempt to fool people. I read a lot about the development and what they tried to do. They tried something very ambitious, with way more complicated AI than you'd normally see in an RPG and they tried implementing this AI into the world and deeply into the quests, but it produced a whole shitload of bugs and it became more trouble than it was worth (along with all of the other problems they were having with Oblivion, like not having the finished 360 development tools). If they had continued along that path instead of scrapping a lot of their plans, it would have ended up like Stalker and been released a lot later. Years later. That video was simply a rushed, few minute demo of a vague example of what they were trying (and ultimately failed) to do.
That's not to say this dragon thing will be incredible. We'll see.
I can understand that, but when you show people what your game is gonna be (and in the E3 demo, they where saying the game would have been like that, they weren't saying "we're trying to do this and that") you gotta deliver at least something close.
I mean, Molyneux wasn't trying to be flat out evil with the whole
Project Ego-->Fable story, but everybody called out his bullshit till the end of time, while it was something similar to Oblivion's case: having unrealistic ambitions and not delivering them in the slightest.
Moreover, that wasn't the only thing i didn't like about Oblivion. Being Morrowind on my top 10 favorites of all time, i didn't like the dumbed down structure and the bland art direction of it, in comparison.
So that's why i'm going to take all this with a grain of salt; while other softhouse have proven themself raliable about what they say/show about their games (say, Naughty Dog?), Bethesda have a broken reputation, just as Molyneux does, to me.
This doesn't mean i think their are evil dudes or anything, but i just filter what they say a lot and, if they deliver on everything, double is the joy for me.
Dennis4K said:
Because they may have seen the error of their ways and are returning to the glory that was the concept of Mass Effect?
One can hope.
Dragon Age 2's direction, should give you confidence.