• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

The Man With The Iron Fists

Status
Not open for further replies.
How could anyone NOT love Kill Bill? Shit's amazing.

I liked Part II. But I was mostly bored by part one (minus the Crazy 88 fight and some bits of the fight in the house which were great too). I'm more of a dialog guy. Action/fights have to be really well done for me to care when they are the focus.
 
New 'Top Critic' review (RT Top Critics now 80%)

"'The Man With the Iron Fists' is enjoyably bad"
I didn't read any reviews beforehand, but this one is pretty close to my own verdict after diving in blind. It's not good enough to be taken seriously, nor bad enough to be mistaken for camp, and it's barely a kung-fu flick as much as it is a live-action shōnen anime. The highs of the movie are the set pieces and costume design, and like the review mentions the acting can get downright embarrassing. Though I wouldn't be surprised if fully two-thirds of the movie's screen time was encapsulated with action. Tons of CGI and wire-fu. It's worth a few bucks if that's your bag.

A solid three star movie.
 
I didn't read any reviews beforehand, but this one is pretty close to my own verdict after diving in blind. It's not good enough to be taken seriously, nor bad enough to be mistaken for camp, and it's barely a kung-fu flick as much as it is a live-action shōnen anime. The highs of the movie are the set pieces and costume design, and like the review mentions the acting can get downright embarrassing. Though I wouldn't be surprised if fully two-thirds of the movie's screen time was encapsulated with action. Tons of CGI and wire-fu. It's worth a few bucks if that's your bag.

A solid three star movie.
Sounds like something to rent from redbox.



With a coupon.
 
Was it entertaining?

Looks like it has cool fights at least.

I think the fights were planned out to be cool. But I think the stylistic editing kind of took away from the potential to be cooler.
 
I was planning on seeing this sometime just for the hell of it, but a good friend of mine was tweeting about the movie after seeing it and it just sounded awful. His mini reviews were funny, though.
 
Just saw this, you know what kind of movie you're getting when you walk into the theater....I mean exactly. If a martial arts action film with Lucy Lui as the madam of a whore house, Russell Crowe as an outlaw hamming up his role 100%, Brotista no-selling everything and some random clans warring over shit is what you want to see.....you're going to be entertained.....oh and RZA is there too.
 
I don't know if this will be the same for anyone else, but Batista and Russell Crowe were highlights of this movie for me.
 
There was some appallingly bad acting that was so bad that it had to be satire/parody.

I agree with everyone who said that Crowe was the highlight of the movie. I didn't think it was a bad movie, though, but I liked Tai Chi Zero far more.
 
I didn't read any reviews beforehand, but this one is pretty close to my own verdict after diving in blind. It's not good enough to be taken seriously, nor bad enough to be mistaken for camp, and it's barely a kung-fu flick as much as it is a live-action shōnen anime. The highs of the movie are the set pieces and costume design, and like the review mentions the acting can get downright embarrassing. Though I wouldn't be surprised if fully two-thirds of the movie's screen time was encapsulated with action. Tons of CGI and wire-fu. It's worth a few bucks if that's your bag.

A solid three star movie.

Sounds exactly like the kungfu flicks I enjoyed watching so much (and still do). There never were any really good kungfu flicks. The vast majority of them had 'embarrassingly' bad acting, story and everything else was terrible too. But they were fun in their own right.
This film makes it clear when it comes to what you should be expecting from it.
 
How was Bautista?
He looked like he enjoyed his role. I found it odd that they didn't put makeup over his tattoos, but with a twenty million dollar budget and ten weeks to shoot I imagine that was a corner to cut, if they ever saw it as a problem at all.
 
I enjoyed it. The movie had a bunch of issues, but it's a silly fun action movie with a mildly self aware premise. I'd really love more theatrical movies like it.

He looked like he enjoyed his role. I found it odd that they didn't put makeup over his tattoos, but with a twenty million dollar budget and ten weeks to shoot I imagine that was a corner to cut, if they ever saw it as a problem at all.

RZA's Wu-Tang tattoo is also visible every now or then.
 
Silly, post-racial, good-natured, anachronistic fun. Filmmaking is not all that great, but that may be intentional. I was amused and left the theater in a good mood.
 
I'm going on monday. Expecting to see an amalgam of Kid With the Golden Arm, Seven Samurai, and Legendary Weapons of China.

That being said the soundtrack was dope so im expecting to enjoy this on some level. I just hate this super fantastical wushu wire shit. Less is more.

I'm basically going cause its RZA the god.
 
Since multiple trailers all showed the same scene's I'm not surprised there is little action. I was thinking since RZA is so into Shaolin that there would be more. Still going to see it at some point. I really hated the advertising though something about we put the FU in Kung Fu? Come on really.
 
Since multiple trailers all showed the same scene's I'm not surprised there is little action.
There's lots of action. Who stated otherwise? It's filled to the brim with the stuff. There has to be an hour's worth of decapitation, flesh cutting, disembowelment, skull-crushing, sword-slicing, kicks, punches and arms being ripped apart.

If the trailers show the same stuff it's because there's only so much that could be shown on television without some cat dropping his monocle in his glass in disgust.
 
There's lots of action. Who stated otherwise? It's filled to the brim with the stuff. There has to be an hour's worth of decapitation, flesh cutting, disembowelment, skull-crushing, sword-slicing, kicks, punches and arms being ripped apart.

If the trailers show the same stuff it's because there's only so much that could be shown on television without some cat dropping his monocle in his glass in disgust.

Read back a page

Saw it this morning and was very let down :(

I was thinking we'd get a good martial arts flick with some good action, really didn't get that at all. Not many fight scenes and the ones it had weren't very good, it just feeds you a story that isn't interesting at all. At least it was short...

I guess difference of opinion.
 
Xevren may have equated the lack of traditional kung-fu with the lack of action. There's some martial arts to be enjoyed from The Man With The Iron Fists, but it makes up a smaller proportion of the overall ass-kicking that happens in this movie. There's a lot more 300 or Immortals style violence and a lot less Shaw Bros than many would expect from a film by The RZA.

I'm almost positive he'd agree with me, because this movie is filled to the brim with action, just not the brand he expected (blame Eli Roth?).
 
I'll echo what MjFrancis is saying. If you're expecting old kung-fu movie/Bruce Lee style action from this film you are going to be disappointed. If you've seen Kill Bill, you should know what to expect from this film, except there are a lot less one on one fights and more scenes like the fight scene on the stair case in Kill Bill (but not nearly as good as any of Kill Bill's fights).

The acting and story are on the same cheesy level as the old kung fu films though.

http://my.spill.com/profiles/blogs/the-man-with-the-iron-fists-audio-review


I really wanna see the film now! Holy fucking shit this film was cut down from 4 hours.

The film definitely "feels" that way too.
 
did anyone really think it was going to be good?

No, but a lot of people hoped it would be campy and funny and have amazing fight sequences. The era of amazing fights in martial arts movies seems to be long over though. When the most memorable movie fights I can remember in the past few years were in The Expendables and The Expendables 2, solely because of Jet Li, then movie fights have problems.
 
Silver Lion = Chappelle Purple Rain Lion
 
Saw this yesterday. Not bad, but not great. I was hoping for something a little more original overall as opposed to a rip and remix of previous martial arts films.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom