• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

The new Yoshi game is... good?

LakeOf9

Member
It's really no secret I have been pretty unimpressed with Nintendo's lineup on the Switch 2. The Switch 1 made a Nintendo fan out of me for life, or so I thought. But then the Switch 2 has been a series of disappointments – Mario Kart World is very good, but a step down from Mario Kart 8. Pokemon Legends ZA is fine, but such a regression over Legends Arceus. Metroid Prime 4 is a fucking disaster. I appreciate Pokopia and Tamodachi, but those are in a genre I don't care about.

This Yoshi game looked supremely uninteresting to me. Like, it looked sleep inducing, I had no idea why making another fucking 2D platformer this early on in the system's life was what Nintendo was going for here. I had absolutely no interest in it, and was perfectly happy letting my Switch 2 and its dock gather more dust while I waited for this fucking company to release something interesting at some point in time.

Through a series of hilarious events, I ended up getting this for $11, so I decided to give it a go, because in the worst case, I figured I could trade it in for near full price value and get my money back. So what the hell.

And.. the game is... good?

Legitimately surprised. Like, for starters, it looks gorgeous. This is apparently an Unreal Engine 5 game on the Switch 2, I expected a blurry, stuttery, 30fps mess. Instead it looks absolutely stunning, arguably the best looking first party game on the Switch 2 so far.

But what I really like about it is how it plays. It's a delightful game. The entire game reminds me of an old game called Scribblenauts, in one way – every single thing you do in Yoshi is an interaction that responds to the player. No matter how minor, every single thing in the game reacts to you, and everything else. It's like a toy box, or learning a new subject for the first time as a kid – your imagination is unlimited, and the game lets you keep pushing and poking and prodding and getting delightful and often unexpected responses from how things respond to other things.

It's definitely an easy game, in terms of platforming. I'd actually argue it's not a platforming game at all, it's basically a puzzle game, where the difficulty is in having to suss out what you need to do, and how you need to do it, rather than difficulty in reflexes and response timings to level design and traversal.

It is built in the same style that so many Nintendo games have been since Breath of the Wild, open ended and inviting the player to push at the boundaries and see where they are able to go. Even as a grown man, this game is fun – I can imagine kids being able to get countless hours just from experimenting in a single level, let alone the full suite of all the game has to offer.
 
I drunkenly bought it like a week or so ago, and I haven't really been able to get into it. Visually, it's quite nice. But otherwise, it felt boring.

I'll have to give it another shot.
 
quite good if you have the skillset of an IGN reviewer maybe.

Edit* not throwing hate your way just saying. I see you thought that prime 4 sucked. So you obviously know ball
 
Last edited:
manchester united GIF
 
quite good if you have the skillset of an IGN reviewer maybe.
One of the only sites that gave it an actual low score?

The shitposting isn't funny if you won't even make an effort

I drunkenly bought it like a week or so ago, and I haven't really been able to get into it. Visually, it's quite nice. But otherwise, it felt boring.

I'll have to give it another shot.
Yeah I didn't like it right away, it took a couple attempts. I recommend getting past the first level or two since those are tutorials basically. Once it lets you loose and lets you decide where you want to go and what you want to do (the last few levels in Chapter 1, but especially past it) it's a lot more fun imo

It's a Nintendo Tax, pay it and you'll feel better
The Nintendo pricing is truly insane, I like this game, but it's overpriced. Even with the variable pricing.
 
Yeah, it's decent. But not great. While it does get better in many ways in the later levels, it also grows quite boring with the gameplay loop being "find creature in book, go to level, do things with creature, finish level, get stars, move to next creature". Bowser Jr shows up once or twice per chapter to have some sort of semblance of story.

I'm on the third chapter and about to give up on it just because the novelty has worn off. Adding actual voice acting to the game (for the book character) would have gone a LONG way.
 
The other Yoshi games were good, this one was surprisingly not good, but not entirely terrible either.

I'm more interested in what series of hilarious events led you to get this for $11. Cheap gamer GAF would be interested in that. I suspect you bought it off somebody who didn't want it anymore for that price? Did you con some kid? 😄
 
The other Yoshi games were good, this one was surprisingly not good, but not entirely terrible either.

I'm more interested in what series of hilarious events led you to get this for $11. Cheap gamer GAF would be interested in that. I suspect you bought it off somebody who didn't want it anymore for that price? Did you con some kid? 😄
Um... kinda, yea lol
 
From what i saw, it's like the others, cute little game that doens't even exist in the same universe of the only godly yoshi title, yoshi islands for snes.
 
I agree 100% with you, OP. I started playing it last night and I was pleasantly surprised at how charming it is and how engaging the mechanics are. Instead of being a game that kicks you in the face with cheap enemies and a screaming baby every time you get hit, it encourages you to explore, discover and experiment in a beautiful storybook setting. I've found myself looking for every secret I can and going back to find the ones I miss after finishing the initial "study" of a creature or area.

I get that a lot of folks wanted something more akin to Yoshi's Island on the SNES or the DS game, but I'm perfectly okay with what's on offer. It's a lot of fun!
 
After watching a fair number of reviews describe the game as repetitive and shallow, I'm surprised by how positive your impressions are. What price would you say the game is worth?
 
Last edited:
Care to share how????
I took advantage of an annoying kid's stupidity basically

After watching a fair number of reviews describe the game as repetitive and shallow, I'm surprised by how positive your impressions are. What price would you say the game is worth?
Maybe $40 at most? It is exceptionally pretty, and the gimmick is really fun. But I definitely see it wearing thin, and obviously there isn't much of a challenge. It's a good game, just not full price good.
 
Top Bottom