jonnybryce said:
I'd actually put Android in first, with webOS and iPhone tied or iPhone last. webOS still needs some work, it's coolest ideas have been perfected in various versions of Android and remain flawed on webOS, such as (basically everything about) synergy. Android lets the user have updated info and pictures without importing all your FB friends, it doesn't add all your buddylist screen names to your address book, etc. webOS often gets in the way, where Android is smart in the background.
iPhone is just pretty and can sync. It doesn't really hold it's own to either, as it's just a menu screen and a good browser/media experience. It is very polished though.
I'd actually flip that ranking around with WebOS first, Android maybe tied with iPhone OS or dead last behind a jailbroken iPhone OS. We have different ways of evaluating I think, but Android's perfected which parts exactly? You'll have to give specific examples to convince me.
Take syncing. Android and Palm both do it over the air but Android requires a google login which is a downer for me personally. My gmail isn't connected to my facebook account for example. But, besides that, Pre supports Palm Profiles so
everything syncs over the air, settings and all. I don't think Android syncing is that sophisticated yet. Yes, Palm had some kinks at the start, and Synergy can be a battery drain, but all the reports I see say it's only getting better.
Pre also perfected easy to use multitasking and, more importantly, app switching, in WebOS. Using Android you have to download a third party task manager app (just those words 'task manager' sounds so archaic) else all you got is a list of 6 recently used apps. WebOS gives you the brilliant cards metaphor. No contest really.
Both the Android and WebOS have decent notifications systems but I lean towards WebOS because...
WebOS looks better. Sure the Droid and NexusOne have better screens but I don't want to look at (relatively) ugly icons and UI in higher resolution. WebOS looks nice to me, I probably won't bother themeing it. The iPhone's look is adequate, I just wish they would get rid of the gloss. Android *ugh* This stuff matters to me as I'm going to be looking at, and touching it, every day.
Where the iPhone wins out is, although the OS is pretty simple on the surface, all the apps have a great deal of depth and polish which makes up for it. WebOS has got all the basics covered too; I don't see anybody advising to newbies to try out three media apps from the store to figure out which one they prefer (unlike say Android). Most people admit upfront that even when an app appears on all OS's stores, the iPhone one is the best. If you jailbreak it, you can mod the OS to come close to WebOS: SBSettings (system settings always one swipe away), iRealSMS (send text from within any app, at any time, reply to texts without leaving what you're doing or save them for later), GriP & isbgriplog (better notifications system). You can even imitate WebOS's cards with ProSwitcher for jailbroken iPhones.
Imitate not improve though, which is why WebOS is still the best imo.
Quick Edit: I don't want Pre on Verizon. I want GSM and besides Sprint is way more cheaper. Pre was slow to begin with and it's getting older by the day. I'm not buying that now and would rather wait for the next itireation especially if it comes with a software keyboard wih multitouch.