• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Unpopular Opinions Thread? YUP!

Status
Not open for further replies.
Look at things people get banned for in any sort of societal threads. Rarely are they for extremely offensive things. Generally it's for a dumb obvious joke. Especially back when dragona was a mod.

Dragona was a mod a long time ago. Using her as an example is pretty bad for making your case.

I can't think of any bans off the top of my head that were uncalled for. The closest I can think of is maybe the Chic-Fil-A thread where people got banned for going "MMM GONNA EAT CHICKEN RIGHT NOW" in response to arguments, but I'd argue that was for blatant trolling rather than not being PC since most of the bans were short.


Not that you asked me, but I don't think the problem is so much that gaf is politically correct, but rather that there's a constant witch hunt to expose and kick out those that have ignorant views.

This I personally have seen. The witch hunts can get out of hand. However I feel they are justified at times. Like when people go "ima not say anything here" in a highly controversial thread.
 
The first 12 episodes of S.Cry.Ed is the best 12 episodes of anything

Good man.

Er...

  • The Beatles are underwhelming.
  • I don't vote because it's ultimately pointless, and can always be argued as such.
  • Abortion should always be viable, regardless of the stage of the fetus. Either women always have precedence over the fetus or they never do. The only exception I can imagine is if aborting the fetus would involve the same risks as giving birth to it in the first place.
  • The lives of animals are equal to those of human beings, and sometimes worth more.
 
GAF is obnoxiously politically correct and everything, somehow, always manages to offend someone.

You know, I often feel like this too, but then I remember that one of the main reasons why this community is so great is because of its no tolerance policy on certain issues that many other forums ignore. Indeed, it's often annoying when posters jump on another poster for saying something politically incorrect that they clearly meant no offense by, especially when back seat modders push for a ban, but it's a necessary evil I feel.

Just one peek into the IGN or GameFAQ message boards and I realize why GAF is the only major gaming forum I post on.
 
I played it with 6 other friends (we alternated) for about a month straight. I think we ran through it about 8 times. It was insane. It was unfortunate that the online component was broken for so many people because that's where it truly shined.

Now that you mention it, I think that may be the reason I 'shelved' it. Me and my old roommate played through it once but yeah, it didn't receive much attention after that (for different reasons but the online issue being the main culprit).


You know, I often feel like this too, but then I remember that one of the main reasons why this community is so great is because of its no tolerance policy on certain issues that many other forums ignore. Indeed, it's often annoying when posters jump on another poster for saying something politically incorrect that they clearly meant no offense by, especially when back seat modders push for a ban, but it's a necessary evil I feel.

Just one peek into the IGN or GameFAQ message boards and I realize why GAF is the only major gaming forum I post on.

I don't know. I'd like the prospect of having more a 'open' dialog. I respect people who not only express their views but stand by them. If you're open to your ideals being swayed and learning more, perhaps finding a middle ground of sorts of understanding then I'm all for it. Just keep it civil and be respectful of others. Belittling someone for having certain beliefs is bullshit, I don't walk around doing that shit in real life. I'm not going to do it on here either.

I think the way things work here breed just as much ignorance on the flipside... you can only have this kind of view on this subject or that kind of particular opinion to post in here or there... ehh...
 
Good Young Adult Fiction is better than Good Adult Fiction. I appreciate the simpler nature of it and even entering my 30s the theme of "growing up" is still more relatable then anything "adult"

Guinee Pigs are underrated pets. They are furry, cute, cuddly... why do cats and dogs get all the love?

The world needs more superhero novels. I don't get why they are relegated to comic books. We can have a million fantasy novels but god forbid someone write a book/series that reads like a superhero comic. Dresden Files is the closest I can think of

Speaking of Dresden Files, the tv show rocked. Edit: You know what, I'll say it... better than the books (only read the first two so far)

Mini Ninjas is the game of the generation and Kingdom Hearts 3 needs a Mini Ninjas world (along with a few other Edios worlds)
 
I also echo the sentiment I've seen posted in this thread regarding Half-Life 2. The game hasn't aged well, and I'm not talking about graphics. In fact it's really hard for me to go back and play any FPS before Halo. I feel like an asshole for saying this, but I just can't do health packs anymore. Regenerating health or bust.
 
No they don't. Why is that? That's so silly. Do you think people enjoy watching TV more today than they did 30 years ago? Because I see no compelling evidence that they do.

That's a dishonest question because you're trying to make comparisons across generational and cultural gaps. People back then were happy with color. It was the highest standard. TVs weren't as widespread as they are today. Now, the norm is higher definition, clearer colors, and crisper sound. It provides the entertainment in a much more coherent manner. That's now what people are used to. If everyone woke up today with television tech rolled back thirty years, there would be a strong outcry of displeasure.

That's objectively better. The same programs from 30 years ago gain new depth on the televisions of today.

Furthermore, the on demand nature of television today gives more control to viewers, whereas if you missed a program thirty years ago, you were shit out of luck more often than not. The library available to you today is expansive.

The people of the eighties didn't have an inkling of the control and clarity today's viewers enjoy.

Arguing that a 70'' television is "objectively better" because it has a higher resolution would be like arguing that a new piece of medical equipment is better because it has pretty lights on it.

The purpose of medical equipment is to improve health; pretty lights have no effect on its intended functionality. An ugly piece of medical equipment is neither worse nor better than a pretty piece of medical equipment ; the relevant question is, "which one makes me healthier?"

Similarly, the purpose of a television is to entertain (and in some rare cases, to inform). I see no compelling evidence that a nicer picture makes things objectively more entertaining or pleasing. Or less entertaining or pleasing. Better, more intelligent programming makes a television more entertaining, but a better picture does not.

Televisions provide entertainment through visual means. If you improve the transfer of information, you're improving the viewer's engagement with the program, which maximizes the production values. A medical instrument's looks have no bearing on its function, and if it did, it would certainly carry more aesthetic appeal.

You have objectively better imagine quality, sound, and utility. Can you prove that it makes watching TV objectively more enjoyable?

Do you think young kids would necessarily enjoy playing soccer in a stadium far more than in their neighborhood cul-de-sac?

Not in absolute terms, because I'm not of the mind of hunting down research articles.

Why does it have to be far more, and why does it have to be children?

If it's any more a greater enjoyment to play in the stadium, it's better. And children would have their opinions skewed by relatively simple emotions such as being in a large, unfamiliar place (alternatively, more compelled to play in the stadium because it's "cool").
 
I don't like 'Real Pic' trends. Even though I don't play a character or am any different online, I value my privacy and would feel really awkward about having my face staring at you every time I make a post.
 
What constantly holds back video games from being taken seriously are gamers themselves. Tribal, trollish, and constantly destructive. How can anyone take it seriously as an art form when its fan base seems largely comprised of spiteful manchildren?

The people who make a point of noting how rational and intelligent they are are often the opposite -- reactionary, emotional and conservative thinkers. Insecure parasites of actual intellect who don't have one thing to say that they haven't already heard someone else say.

Anyone who spends a considerable amount of time arguing the merits of some billion dollar company be that Google, Apple, MS, Sony, etc., are pathetic little toadies whom everyone should feel contempt for. People getting paid to tout the benefits of Corporation X are one thing, but those who do it for free and do it often seem to have nothing else in their life to identify with other than some megacorp which gives not one solitary fuck for anything else in this world other than their financials, it's really quite sad.
 
What constantly holds back video games from being taken seriously are gamers themselves. Tribal, trollish, and constantly destructive. How can anyone take it seriously as an art form when its fan base seems largely comprised of spiteful manchildren?

The people who make a point of noting how rational and intelligent they are are often the opposite -- reactionary, emotional and conservative thinkers. Insecure parasites of actual intellect who don't have one thing to say that they haven't already heard someone else say.

Anyone who spends a considerable amount of time arguing the merits of some billion dollar company be that Google, Apple, MS, Sony, etc., are pathetic little toadies whom everyone should feel contempt for. People getting paid to tout the benefits of Corporation X are one thing, but those who do it for free and do it often seem to have nothing else in their life to identify with other than some megacorp which gives not one solitary fuck for anything else in this world other than their financials.

A good post.
 
Sure, I'll bite.

Alcohol and indeed, various substances used to bomb your brain or make yourself shitfaced to forget life are overrated. If you put the effort in, you can enjoy life far more sober than intoxicated.

Your career and income mean squat measured against the universe and the full scope of life. You can survive and be healthy and experience life at many levels, society's structure permitting. It is largely an agreed-upon hallucination that you must achieve XX levels of culturally promoted success and advancement to be a full, complete human being, and be 'happy'. However, young dumb people are easily sucked into the game and throw whatever might have been their true best path away before they've even begun life. And the structure of society is continually perverted to force more and more people into the game to survive.

Most of what people argue over to determine what is good or bad is terribly subjective and ultimately settles nothing. Arguing about which beer is better, which fighting game is a 'real man's game', which television show or movie is crap in the end means little and counts for less in most ways. Most people don't debate or critique things on the esoteric level required to gain actual understanding, so it is mostly just spinning everyone's wheels. Everyone just wants to be a winner and have the "right" opinion. Determine the 'right' games, the 'right' movies, or music, or food.

Skrillex is awesome and one of the most purely entertaining musical creators to appear in the last ten years. He gives not a shit what you think because he is having the time of his life and so is everyone in the audience. That is all.

Speaking of which, people busy having fun also don't give a shit what you think when you come over to tell them what they're doing sucks and they should stop having their fun. Stop playing CoD, stop watching that cartoon you hate, stop talking about that fighting game you think is trash because it's not the one fighting game you're actually good at.

Also having said that arguments over which TV shows are good are pointless, I shall now be a hypocrite and say that the new Battlestar Galactica was a very poorly constructed show that lost its way after one season because the showrunner came to hate science fiction, and convinced most of the people involved with the show to hate it too and even be ashamed of the name. Paradoxically, I liked the one bit that many people didn't, the ending. The ending actually pulled everything together and took a stand on an idea, and executed it extraordinarily well. BTW it wasn't about Christianity and soft headed superstition people that is why Head Baltar f**king outright said "it doesn't like it when you call it God" for f**k's sake.

I'm going to get some chocolate milk see ya.
 
Your career and income mean squat measured against the universe and the full scope of life. You can survive and be healthy and experience life at many levels, society's structure permitting. It is largely an agreed-upon hallucination that you must achieve XX levels of culturally promoted success and advancement to be a full, complete human being, and be 'happy'. However, young dumb people are easily sucked into the game and throw whatever might have been their true best path away before they've even begun life. And the structure of society is continually perverted to force more and more people into the game to survive.

hnnggh...
 
Half Life is for kids. Kids with bad taste.

For kids? What are you talking about? I feel like it has a broad appeal, and has some mature-themes and violent content that might be inappropriate for children. I don't think Half-Life was marketed toward a young target audience.
 
i absolutely cannot stand arcade games like the kind people buy from craiglists. they do them up, spend a lot of hours cleaning em and then just throw them into a corner and admire them from afar.

yyaaaawwwnnnn
 
The X - Files is the only television show that was ever worth watching.

Not necessarily unpopular on here, but most of my friends would slap me for saying that the CFL is a third rate, boring league.

To the person above who made the Led Zeppelin comment, I shake my fist in your general direction.
 
Jay Z sucks

The Halo series is mediocre - nothing special about it

Sushi is not that good

Obama doesnt care about you, all he cares about is getting re-elected
 
Alcohol is disgusting, and so is ethnic food (especially the Asian variety).

I'm Chinese so I enjoy Chinese food, but I agree with the alcohol thing. It doesn't taste good, it has a whole bunch of calories, and it impairs your judgement and makes you do retarded things, nothing positive comes from drinking.
 
Dr Pepper and Mountain Dew are terrible, but especially Mountain Dew.

  • The Beatles are underwhelming.
  • Abortion should always be viable, regardless of the stage of the fetus. Either women always have precedence over the fetus or they never do. The only exception I can imagine is if aborting the fetus would involve the same risks as giving birth to it in the first place.
  • The lives of animals are equal to those of human beings, and sometimes worth more.
Great Scott!


Blink 182 was always shit

True.
 
Schattenjäger;41859731 said:
The Halo series is mediocre - nothing special about it

Obama doesnt care about you, all he cares about is getting re-elected

Can't really argue with those.

For myself:

The Transformers films were fantastic.

Indiana Jones 4 was a good movie.

Atlas Shrugged is an good book, and Ayn Rand is a good writer. (Though I don't agree with most of her philosophies)

Small Dogs > Big Dogs

Raphael was the best Ninja Turtle.

White "Chocolate" > Chocolate

The PSP has the best library of games of any handheld gaming system. (/flameshield)
 
90's anime is not better than 00's anime.

There were some great titles from that decade but there was still plenty of crap like the 00's and any other form of entertainment.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom