• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

USSR: Great National Anthem...or GREATEST?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Not nearly stirring enough, imo.

Concur. TBH, I think the most stirring American national song is Stars & Stripes Forever. It needs some love.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SXwu0h_ulpw

Musically, it is without question superior to the Star Spangled Banner.

Disagreed...I think the USA's anthem is perfect in its structure and length. It's concise. And it has the words "bombs" and "rockets" in it, which makes it win automatically

It's also a historical telling of how we crushed the British. "gave proof through the night...that our flag was still there"...WOWW what a powerful visual image.

...and the home of the brave!

And it can be sung in a bunch of different ways, and a lot of celebrities have sung it

Examples:
 
Disagreed...I think the USA's anthem is perfect in its structure and length. It's concise. And it has the words "bombs" and "rockets" in it, which makes it win automatically

It's also a historical telling of how we crushed the British. "gave proof through the night...that our flag was still there"...WOWW what a powerful visual image.

...and the home of the brave!

And it can be sung in a bunch of different ways, and a lot of celebrities have sung it
But...you didn't crush the British at all in the War of 1812.
 
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bfx4J6aL3dE

It's not Finland's official anthem, but many people prefer it over the real one. My Finnish friend was pretty passionate about it and her hate for the actual anthem. I think it'd be interesting to hear something like this during a football game where a full stadium would sing it.
Came here to post this. Can't believe our official anthem is what it is when it could be Finlandia. What is also funny is that the official one is shared with Estonia.

Here is Finlandia performed by a male singer after Finland won the hockey championships last year

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eRjf7yPZlGU
It is a shame that not many know the lyrics because it is not the official anthem :(

All that said though, I have to admit Russia's anthem is no doubt the best official national anthem, even with the history between Finland and Russia.
 
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0yDrtNEr_5M

As much as I love hearing some Jennifer Hudson sing the Star Spangled Banner, there's something about the old Soviet National Anthem that touches me deeper. Perhaps I just have a soft spot for mass choirs, but the passion the choir sings with gives me chills every time I hear it. The refrains are pure emotion and power. The belief in what they're singing about, unmistakable. I greatly admire it and it has a place on top of my list.

That said, I can't say I've heard all that National Anthems. Is there one better, GAF? School me, ladies & gentlemen.

As a person that grew up in the former Soviet Union, I always thought the anthem was ominous and evil-sounding. But then again, I associate bad things with it.
 
Wait... This isn't an old thread that got bumped? I'm pretty sure this has been covered before, not just best national anthems but specifically USSR.

The Soviet anthem was okay, it's a bit too dramatic for my tastes, as someone said above, ominous and evil-sounding. It sounds like... Soviet propaganda!
I'd place the US #1 because the lyrics and story are awesome. It doesn't hurt that so many singers (and celebrities like Carl Lewis and Roseanne Barr!) have done it.
I'd place England above it though, if they replaced God Save blah blah with William Blake's Jerusalem.
 
Feels like USA's anthem is more about the person(s) singing than the actual anthem. I agree it's versatile but, something's just off about it.

It's because it's "notoriously difficult for nonprofessionals to sing, because of its wide range – an octave and a half." (Wikipedia)

The best part about the Star Spangled Banner is the storytelling and visuals of the flag as a symbol and rockets and bombs flying around it and lighting up the night sky. You get an image of everything the US stands for in one short verse.

O! say can you see by the dawn's early light,
What so proudly we hailed at the twilight's last gleaming,
Whose broad stripes and bright stars through the perilous fight,
O'er the ramparts we watched, were so gallantly streaming?
And the rockets' red glare, the bombs bursting in air,
Gave proof through the night that our flag was still there;
O! say does that star-spangled banner yet wave,
O'er the land of the free and the home of the brave?

Also it's very "modern" and not a bunch of stuffy soldiers in a choir hailing the country or king or whatever...instead it's like "you dare tax us w/out representation?? we're gonna declare independence and beat your ass!"

6a00d8341c009153ef00e55372cdf28834-800wi
 
The USA's national anthem is surprisingly muted in terms of patriotism, death, war and stuff compared to other countries.

And I do agree it's the individual's recital/interpretation of the anthem that makes it special. It seems to be uniquely tailored in that way; contrasted to other anthems. Especially the USSR.
 
Estonian national anthem.

Not the best example pace-wise, but warms my heart every time. The anthem was so good that Finland copied the tune.
The tune is an old composition created by Fredrik Pacius in 1840s. It's pretty much a mere coincidence that it has ended up being both Finland and Estonia's national anthem.

It reached the official national anthem status quite simultaneously in both countries (Finland got its independence in 1917 and Estonia in 1920).
 
The tune is an old composition created by Fredrik Pacius in 1840s. It's pretty much a mere coincidence that it has ended up being both Finland and Estonia's national anthem.

It reached the official national anthem status quite simultaneously in both countries (Finland got its independence in 1917 and Estonia in 1920).

I don't blame y'all for splitting it up between you two... it really is excellent.
 
O.K., we are talking about the CCCP anthem in here, right? This is:

Файл:Internationale Russian.ogg — Википедия
http://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/Файл:Internationale_Russian.ogg

File:Internationale orchestral arrangement.ogg - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Internationale_orchestral_arrangement.ogg

Not really a national anthem, but the anthem of the European Union is hard to top - "An die Freude" by Beethoven: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=piJXGl8uSLU
It feels like cheating when such a piece can be adopted as an anthem.
 
What a cop out.
Okay... I didn't say any anything about good or bad singers. I'm just responding to all the ''oh this person sung it and this one too'' posts and saying that to me personally it feels like something is off about it. I agree the lyrics are interesting and I can see why people like it. Just feels very different from other anthems.

Does the USA still require immigrants to sing it when they get their citizenship? Gotta start learning the lyrics and looking like I mean it.
 
Does the USA still require immigrants to sing it when they get their citizenship? Gotta start learning the lyrics and looking like I mean it.

I'm sure you are required to learn it, and the pledge. Not sure if you sing it or not. I went to a ceremony once when a friend got his citizenship, but can't remember if they did that or not, and if they did, whether it was a spontaneous thing or not.
 
Also it's very "modern" and not a bunch of stuffy soldiers in a choir hailing the country or king or whatever...instead it's like "you dare tax us w/out representation?? we're gonna declare independence and beat your ass!"

http://leatherneckm31.typepad.com/.a/6a00d8341c009153ef00e55372cdf28834-800wi[IMG][/QUOTE]
You're thinking of the wrong war there. Not one the US should be proud of either, not exactly the heroic tale that the American Revolution has become.
 
it doesnt talk about rockets and bombs bursting in the night sky making everything bright so you can see us better

so second best
 
NOPE. "Jerusalem" should be your pick if you guys ever wanna stop using the Canadian Anthem.

:P

Edward Elgar > Hubert Parry.

We in England don't actually have a National Anthem. 'God Save The Queen' is the anthem of the United Kingdom. If we were to have an anthem, it has to be 'Land of Hope and Glory', it's simply perfect.
 
Today class: Political Correctness
Subject: Argentina's National Anthem lyric

Original
Hear, mortals, the sacred cry:
"Freedom! Freedom! Freedom!"
Hear the noise of broken chains,
see the noble Equality enthroned.
On the surface of this land now rises
A Nation glorious and new,
Her head is crowned with laurels,
And a Lion lies at her feet.

From the new Champions their faces
Mars himself seems to encourage
Greatness nestles in their bodies:
at their march they make everything tremble.
The dead Inca are shaken,
and in their bones the ardour revives
which renews their children
of the Fatherland the ancient splendour.

Mountain ranges and walls are felt
to resound with horrible din:
the whole country is disturbed by cries
of revenge, of war and furore.
In the fiery tyrants the envy
spit the pestipherous bile;
their bloody standard they rise
provoking the most cruel combat.

Don't you see them over Mexico and Quito
throwing themselves with tenacious viciousness?
And who they cry, bathed in blood,
in Potosí, Cochabamba and La Paz?
Don't you see them over sad Caracas
spreading mourning and weeping and death?
Don't you see them devouring as wild animals
all people who surrender to them?


To you it dares, Argentines,
the pride of the vile invader;
your fields it steps on, retelling
so many glories as winner.
But the braves, who united swore
their merry freedom to sustain,
to those blood-thirsty tigers
bold chests they will know to oppose.

The valiant Argentine to arms
runs burning with determination and bravery,
the war bugle, as thunder,
in the fields of the South resounds.
Buenos Aires opposes, and it's leading
the people of the illustrious Union,
and with robust arms they tear
the arrogant Iberian lion.


San José, San Lorenzo, Suipacha,
both Piedras, Salta and Tucumán,
La Colonia and the same walls
of the tyrant in the Banda Oriental.
They are eternal signboards that say:
"Here the Argentine arm found triumph,
here the fierce oppressor of the Fatherland
his proud neck bent".

Victory to the Argentine warrior
covered with its brilliant wings,
and embarrassed at this view the tyrant
with infamy took to flight.

Its flags, its arms surrender
as trophies to freedom,
and on wings of glory the people rise
the worthy throne of their great majesty.

From one pole to the other resounds
the sonorous bugle of Fame,
and of America the name showing
they repeat "Mortals, hear!:
For their most honorable throne have opened
the United Provinces of the South."
And the free ones of the world reply:
"To the great Argentine people, hail!"

May the laurels be eternal,
that we knew how to win.
Let us live crowned with glory...
or swear to die gloriously!

Modern
ear, mortals, the sacred cry:
"Freedom! Freedom! Freedom!"
Hear the noise of broken chains,
see the noble Equality enthroned.

Their most honourable throne have opened
the United Provinces of the South.
And the free ones of the world reply:
"To the great Argentine people, hail!"
"To the great Argentine people, hail!"
And the free ones of the world reply:
"To the great Argentine people, hail!"
And the free ones of the world reply:
"To the great Argentine people, hail!"

May the laurels be eternal,
the ones we managed to win,
the ones we managed to win.
Let us live crowned in glory...
or let us swear in glory to die!
Or let us swear in glory to die!
Or let us swear in glory to die!
 
Edward Elgar > Hubert Parry.

We in England don't actually have a National Anthem. 'God Save The Queen' is the anthem of the United Kingdom. If we were to have an anthem, it has to be 'Land of Hope and Glory', it's simply perfect.

Meh. It's kinda just "the Graduation Song" over here in the USA. I know it doesn't have that stigma over there, but once you hear something one way, it's hard to retrain your ear, you know?

I was joking about it earlier, but "God Save the Queen" always sounded like a weaker version of "Oh Canada" to me for some reason. And y'all can't have that. I don't know why but to my ear, your anthem, Canada's and Denmark's all have a similar quality. Maybe I just always hear similar arrangements. Anyway, Canada's anthem is certainly one of my favorites as well so you're in good company at least.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom