Kinect sports sold in two games what the The Show sold collectively this entire gen. THAT is making money.
This isn't a knock at the series at all, but it would be extremely silly for them to jump into a true baseball sim when they can sell Kinect games to core and casual and get millions more sales.
Even with Move, which makes perfect sense for a baseball game, the last MLB did horribly. Although, Sony did a good job marketing the Vita version.
No core baseball fan is going to buy a shovelware motion game. The Show's one of the best sports games of any kind, let alone the single best option for baseball now.
I dunno I get what you're trying to say, but it kinda rubs me the wrong way that you're defending MS' decision to not make real games and just make motion shovelware. That it's "not worth it" to them. I don't very much care what's worth it to them, I care what's worth playing for me. And motion shovelware isn't it.