Support NeoGAF

[DaciaJC]

Mount & Blade: Warband, if it counts.

 

[Tenrius]

I agree, the atmosphere, the sound, the story, combat, the voice acting, even the graphics are awesome today, i still play it from time to time


Also Neverwinter Nights 2 (with graphic mods looks very nice), also great combat, loot system, lots of companions, i love it
Clicky for bigger image

And it is a 2006 game :O

It's completely the opposite for me. I never liked NWN2, I think it looks ugly (and I thought so back in 2006) and its appearance has always been a big letdown for me.

 

[Sentenza]

It's completely the opposite for me. I never liked NWN2, I think it looks ugly (and I thought so back in 2006) and its appearance has always been a big letdown for me.

Same here, I find the game simply hideous looking, both in terms of graphics and UI.
Not to mention controls and camera.

 

[Varna]

Witcher 1 had god awful combat which ruined the game. I'll never see the story just because of how bad the combat is in the beginning of the game.

TW2 has pretty terrible combat as well. Failing to capture the essence of it's main inspirations. I consider the two equal. Both lacking in some areas, but in general the complete package is amazing.

Fallout 1/2 for me for all the reason listed already. Never really understood how people can consider the game "dated" or any other such thing. Honestly, the UI alone is light years ahead of that piece of shit UI from F3/FNV.

 

[finley83]

Agreeing with all the Fallout comments in here. I replayed both games a few years ago in preparation for Fallout 3 and they are honestly still some of the most atmospheric games ever made. The music alone... it says a lot that Obsidian just reused the entire score for New Vegas and that alone made it my favourite game of 2010.