Solo unless you count Yoko. Plastic Ono Band is the best solo album any of the Beatles made.
-
Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!
What happened to bands being popular?
- Thread starter Xeke
- Start date
- Status
brianjones
Member
i made a pretty cool playlist with songs from their early solo efforts
it almost like another beatles album
How did you set it up?
JJDinomite
Banned
I could rant for a very long time about how amazing music is these days, but I don't think it would go very far.
Just watch this daily.
Just watch this daily.
You know, the first fun. album is actually pretty good. But yeah, I can't believe they got mainstream popular with such a terrible song and album.
So anyway, I listen to indie and there's plenty of stuff to listen to. There's too much good stuff to listen to. There's bands actively making music right now that are some of my favorites, and are so much better than the shit I listened to as a teenager. Fleet Foxes, Beirut, The Civil Wars, The Arcade Fire, Vampire Weekend. You have bands like Mumford & Sons selling over 2 million records. It's never been easier to find good music, and there's never been more of it out there. We've just finally broken out of the radio/MTV cage of the past.
Ever heard of Everyday Chemistry? Pretty good mix of paul/john/george/ringo's solo work.
brianjones
Member
i actually stole it from another forum
i liked it cause it doesnt just pick their obvious hits and some thought went into the ordering of it
like paul/lennon taking shots at each back-to-back (dear boy / how do you sleep)
Davey Cakes
Member
Yeah, but people who primarily listen to radio will never be much more willing to look for the good stuff than they've ever been. They then remain ignorant and won't even take suggestions for new music from others who have broken away, because they're comfortable with what they have, sadly.
"What's good is what's popular" is still the mindset of the majority. To me, this would be limiting and frustrating, but to many others it's just the natural way.
Host Samurai
Member
It's all about EDM now. Tiesto, Avicii, Skrillex, Axwell, Nero, Armen Van Buren etc. There is a huge rave sub culture that's getting more popular by the day. Lots of these ravers remind me of hippies in the 70s. I personally call them Neo Hippies.
mysticwhip
Banned
D
Deleted member 17706
Unconfirmed Member
It's incredible. We have everything and it's immediately accessible. Still plenty of mainstream uber-produced stuff for those who like that, but there's a constant stream of amazing new acts all the time. I have discovered so many new groups and awesome songs since I started using services like Spotify and Rdio, and just searching the Internet in general.
Not only that, but we also have all of the amazing classics available at our fingertips. It's just great.
CrocMother
Banned
Black Keys are pretty popular, Kings of Leon, I dunno they are still around you just haven't heard of them.
I would replace that with Wolfgang Gartner, Justice, Pretty Lights and some dub step stuff like Rusko. I'm from NY tho but that seems to be what the EDM kids by me love.
O and bassnectar
I would replace that with Wolfgang Gartner, Justice, Pretty Lights and some dub step stuff like Rusko. I'm from NY tho but that seems to be what the EDM kids by me love.
O and bassnectar
blame space
Banned
i don't think i like any bands any more.
GamerVoice
Banned
There's plenty of good music, but mainstream culture represents the worst music in our history, which really makes the world a less enjoyable place.
I wish it was the 70s or the 90s again, man.
I wish it was the 70s or the 90s again, man.
Bulbo Urethral Baggins
Banned
Not even the monkees?
Keavy_Rain
Member
When I went to buy my tickets for the Clockwork Angels tour Live Nation was all "DID YOU MEAN BIG TIME RUSH?!?" and I was all "Dafuq?"
Then, on the drive home from seeing Van Halen with special guests Valerie Bertenelli and David Lee Roth, I had the radio on a pop station and during the time between San Jose and Vacaville I heard "Call Me Maybe," a song I think was by Adele (I honestly can't tell the difference between her, Duffy, and Amy Winehouse and you could easily convince me they're all one person) and a song by Katy Perry on what seemed to be a continuous loop, as if some teenager made a "songs I bought on iTunes" playlist and then hijacked a radio station.
What I'm saying is I'm fairly out of touch with modern music. I live in my own music bubble, supported by my iPhone and my local classic rock station and I'm generally pretty happy with it. Except when I hear "The Eagle presents the next generation of Classic Rock" followed by a song I remember being new when I was in middle or high school. YOU BASTARDS ARE MAKING ME FEEL OLD!!!
Not saying I don't listen to pop; I had an ex who loved Top 40 and I did buy a few songs and an album or two myself, but it was more of a "Goddamnit, I can't get California Girls out of my head" situation than a "I genuinely like this and would like to support this artist" thing.
Then, on the drive home from seeing Van Halen with special guests Valerie Bertenelli and David Lee Roth, I had the radio on a pop station and during the time between San Jose and Vacaville I heard "Call Me Maybe," a song I think was by Adele (I honestly can't tell the difference between her, Duffy, and Amy Winehouse and you could easily convince me they're all one person) and a song by Katy Perry on what seemed to be a continuous loop, as if some teenager made a "songs I bought on iTunes" playlist and then hijacked a radio station.
What I'm saying is I'm fairly out of touch with modern music. I live in my own music bubble, supported by my iPhone and my local classic rock station and I'm generally pretty happy with it. Except when I hear "The Eagle presents the next generation of Classic Rock" followed by a song I remember being new when I was in middle or high school. YOU BASTARDS ARE MAKING ME FEEL OLD!!!
Not saying I don't listen to pop; I had an ex who loved Top 40 and I did buy a few songs and an album or two myself, but it was more of a "Goddamnit, I can't get California Girls out of my head" situation than a "I genuinely like this and would like to support this artist" thing.
GamerVoice
Banned
Davey Cakes
Member
I'm pretty sure not a single person who listens to music outside the Top 40 could agree with you here.
By believing such a thing you're really doing a disservice to yourself as a listener. Music is as good as it's ever been, but the landscape has changed, and there's a lot out there. You have to search for what is good (and good to you), but the process is very easy due to technology, and the payoff is really satisfying.
The Technomancer
card-carrying scientician
I watched the Call Me Maybe video on YouTube today on a whim. I give it credit, it had a great ending.
I'm starting to see that I'm reaching the age (37 now) that I listen to new music less and less and just fall back on the greats from the 90's of grunge and alt rock as well as the classic rock from the 70's and some 80's.
Thankfully, services like Steam, GoG, Netflix, Hulu, Youtube, etc have proven that it's super easy to dwell in the back catalog of entertainment and be satisfied for the rest of your life.
So I'm perfectly happy ignoring the Biebers of the world and I still have lots of music to listen to.
Thankfully, services like Steam, GoG, Netflix, Hulu, Youtube, etc have proven that it's super easy to dwell in the back catalog of entertainment and be satisfied for the rest of your life.
So I'm perfectly happy ignoring the Biebers of the world and I still have lots of music to listen to.
You know who really makes me cringe? Niki Minaj.
not only is she more makeup than human, but her songs have the worst messages. I couldn't think of a worse role model for my eleven year old sister. She was singing "You're a stupid ho" the other day and my dad and grandfather got livid, to say the least.
Ya know, its alright to sing and write about these themes but have some maturity and gravity behind them, they aren't light subjects. I think that's what bothers me about a lot of this shallow rap music, other than boring rap (people need to listen to more J5), they just treat these slurs and themes of prostitution gangs and murder like its perfectly alright and acceptable.
not only is she more makeup than human, but her songs have the worst messages. I couldn't think of a worse role model for my eleven year old sister. She was singing "You're a stupid ho" the other day and my dad and grandfather got livid, to say the least.
Ya know, its alright to sing and write about these themes but have some maturity and gravity behind them, they aren't light subjects. I think that's what bothers me about a lot of this shallow rap music, other than boring rap (people need to listen to more J5), they just treat these slurs and themes of prostitution gangs and murder like its perfectly alright and acceptable.
Keavy_Rain
Member
I caught the error and have fixed it. Thanks!
Go back to 2000, replace Nicki Minaj with Lil Kim, it works.
scotcheggz
Member
Fuck. Yes.
The Strokes, Mumford and Sons, Arcade Fire, The Killers. I guess they aren't popular on the scale that some bands were in the 80s and 90s, but they are pretty big.
I think a big difference is that pop music stations would play big rock bands more back then. They stick to the solo pop artists now. Hip hop is bigger among white suburban teenagers now more than ever before as well.
I think a big difference is that pop music stations would play big rock bands more back then. They stick to the solo pop artists now. Hip hop is bigger among white suburban teenagers now more than ever before as well.
Face it Tiger..
Banned
Admiral Bone to Pick
Banned
Not to mention the complete lack of genuine emotion. I have no idea what the average person sees in all of the auto-tuned crap that gets played so constantly. It's just so...boring. It lacks humanity and feeling.
GamerVoice
Banned
The declining quality of popular music is directly proportional to the rise of hip hop. It's a shame.
Its alright to autotune for artistic creativity if done right, like with electronic music, but when its done to make you sound better than you actually are, it just grinds my gears.
The same with Artists that aren't good live. Once I hear them live, if they sound like shit... I lose interest in the band all together.
No I don't think so, these popular bands have always been around in different forms, different eras. Most rise and fall.
Also, what do you mean Rise of Hip Hop? Hasn't hip hop been on the decline for a while.
This is real Hip Hop: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fqj1Q1a2mzU Do give it a listen by the way. Its great, artistic, creative.
Keavy_Rain
Member
You'd never hear a pop star of today record a song like "Time Stands Still" or "Under the Bridge."
The best you can hope for is a song like "With Arms Wide Open" that went from "A song Scott Stapp wrote about what fatherhood must feel like" to "A song Scott Stapp wrote about what fatherhood is like." The difference being that year or so between the tour in support of their first mainstream album and their second.
I'm not a huge fan of her voice, but I would argue Adele is pretty good.
Davey Cakes
Member
A lot of the popular dance pop and pop rap songs are shallower than drops of water.
I'm all for "just letting go and having fun" when it comes to hearing some of this stuff in the clubs, but being bombarded with it on a daily basis is a different story. At that point I'm wondering why every song basically requires me to turn my brain off. The messages and subject matter are played out, and the lyrics are so simple they're mind-numbing.
People who listen to this stuff don't believe in "context." Like I said, I think this sort of music fits the context of clubs and parties just fine, since dancing is a particular kind of experience and background music for parties isn't a big deal, but I don't get how typical pop/dance/pop rap music is fitting for the context of pure listening.
I don't see how listening to the same thing every day, regardless of the situation, is satisfying. Then again, music for me isn't the same experience as it is for others, I guess.
I'm all for "just letting go and having fun" when it comes to hearing some of this stuff in the clubs, but being bombarded with it on a daily basis is a different story. At that point I'm wondering why every song basically requires me to turn my brain off. The messages and subject matter are played out, and the lyrics are so simple they're mind-numbing.
People who listen to this stuff don't believe in "context." Like I said, I think this sort of music fits the context of clubs and parties just fine, since dancing is a particular kind of experience and background music for parties isn't a big deal, but I don't get how typical pop/dance/pop rap music is fitting for the context of pure listening.
I don't see how listening to the same thing every day, regardless of the situation, is satisfying. Then again, music for me isn't the same experience as it is for others, I guess.
GamerVoice
Banned
Rolling In The Deep is the only good successful song of the current decade.
MTV stopped playing videos, so that was a thing. And most local alternative or rock stations died out during the late 90's. In Austin we had 3 of the 4 modern rock stations die within 2 years.
With the Internet now, we have thousands of bands competing, when before we had a couple of hundred artists hand selected by the studios making up the music scene.
Napster was the beginning of the end of traditional radio play and record buying. And now we are here where you get the occasional big seller like Adele, but the industry as a whole is super fragmented. Tower Records and Virgin Megastores are dead. No more midnight sales for albums like OK Computer.
I am not sure whether or not it is a good or bad trend, but buying a physical copy of an album vinyl or cd has been replaced. It is a feeling that the current and next generation will not experience and that is sort of sad.
mysticwhip
Banned
what are you trying to say?
GamerVoice
Banned
That Jay Z killed the alternative music star.
RobotMafia
Banned
Especially since they sing about payphones. Have any of their fans ever used a payphone?
user8503492
Banned
I have a BIG question
With every rap album released post 1999ish have 37 rappers on the album...how the fuck do they tour?
Seriously?
I pick up any rap album now and EVERY single track features no less then 1 rapper besides the main artist.
With every rap album released post 1999ish have 37 rappers on the album...how the fuck do they tour?
Seriously?
I pick up any rap album now and EVERY single track features no less then 1 rapper besides the main artist.
GamerVoice
Banned
JJDinomite
Banned
Isn't that one of those cell phones where you have to pay per minute and text?
the only credit I'll give them is drops of jupiter has some decent lyrics. Like well thought out creative ones.
SpeedingUptoStop
will totally Facebook friend you! *giggle* *LOL*
Did you miss the part when I said right now or something?
A Pretty Panda
fuckin' called it, man
Do the Jonas Brothers count as a band?
GamerVoice
Banned
It's boring to me, sorry.
- Status