Support NeoGAF

[Delicious Waffles]

My Dad took me to our local mall where EB Games was after he got home from work one night so I can pick up a copy. The whole day, I kept flipping back and forth on which version I wanted, going over the exclusive Pokemon in each version. When I got there, I think I was all set to pick up the Red version but changed my mind the last minute and got Blue instead. I don't know why. I'm thinking it was the exclusive Pokemon or something minor like they didn't have Red in stock and I wasn't leaving without a copy.

Regardless, I played through it numerous times. I still have my original copy. The save still works. I checked it about a year ago and I was saved during another playthrough right in front of Articuno, ready to take it on. I even have the original strategy guide.

I've played other versions but this one still ranks #1 for me.

 

[Drago]

I remember the games and cards being really popular at school during the 3rd gen. I played Pokemon cards a lot with friends but not too seriously; we constantly switched between Pokemon and YuGiOh, lol. Despite liking the card games and it's general popularity, I never had a Pokemon video game. I just barely played video games in general until I was like 9 or 10 or so.

Anyway, one Christmas my parents ended up getting me Mario Strikers Charged, a game I already owned, so we went back to Costco to return it and get something in return, and I chose Pokemon Diamond. Mostly because everyone else was playing it, and because Lucario was in it. lol. I enjoyed it but it wasn't until I got an Action Replay a week later that I really started going crazy with it, hahah... the very first thing I did was give myself a Lucario

I didn't really play a Pokemon game for real until I got Platinum on release day, and I think that was really the first Pokemon game that hooked me since my Diamond was essentially just having fun with cheat codes. Played that game nonstop until I beat it and then some. Unfortunately this was around the time everyone else went into the "Pokemon is for babies" phase so I kind of had to play these games in secret. I did manage to keep my friends invested in the games though, haha.

From there the rest is history, really. I went back and played the gens that I missed, and have been playing new Pokemon games as they released ever since Platinum, with the exception of White 2; I really didn't want to play another DS Pokemon when 3DS was 1.5yrs old at that point despite White 1 having been my favorite in the series at the time. Which was a real mistake, as W2 ended up being even better than 1 and is now quite easily my favorite in the series.

Gen ranks I guess: 5>2>4>3>1>6
Hopefully Z is typical third version quality and redeems the gen because so far XY and ORAS have been really disappointing to me. They're certainly taking their time with it which gives me some hope.

 

[ghostjoke]

151 on Blue. Among the best childhood memories are connected to this game. Played through Yellow as well, but it didn''t have the same impact.

Put 200/300 hours into Silver. I think the legendary dogs (or whatever they're called) broke me. The realisation that Kanto was in the game blew my little mind.

Played about half of either Black/White because a friend wanted Pokemon from other version. It didn't grab me. By no means do I mean it was bad, just didn't have that everyone-is-playing-zeitgeist.

TwitchPlaysPokemon was the closet I ever got to that gen 1/2 feeling. Wish they had taken time between each game; going straight to Gold after the rollarcoaster of Red caused me lose interest. Tried getting back into series after it, but then Dark Souls happened.

Overall, Pokemon was as an obsession for about 3 years (anime/cards/games/soundtracks/pokeraps) in late 90s/early 00s, but it just teetered out after G/S/C and when the TV series went back to the very beginning for the third bloody time. It's always going to be a special series to me, but I can't see it ever being as gripping as those first two entries. Still, "be happy it happened" is how I'm thinking of it.

 

[NHarmonic.]

Got Blue when it came out, then silver, and crystal. Didn't play a game again until SoulSilver.

I've played XY and Omega Ruby and they're both disappointments in my eyes because they've ditched the classic game style of the older games. The villains are also lame.

The villains were always lame, though. Except for a few ones in black and white i'd say.

 

[Atolm]

I played Blue, Yellow and Gold. Then I stopped for no reason and haven't touched them since. The end.

 

[chemicals]

I only played the first 2 games Red/Blue, and Gold/Silver. Loved it. Never had a DS or 3DS to keep up with the series since then.

 

[MetalSlug]

My history with the series is:

Red > Yellow > Silver

Pokemon Silver was the last game I played. I'm looking forward to replaying Red. Not played it since it first released.

 

[I am Christina Aguilera]

I went to the Japan Center Mall in San Francisco when I was thirteen in I'm guessing 1997, when Pokemon fever was already hitting Japan but unheard of in the U.S. I was intrigued by this pack of Nintendo-copyright square stickers I bought with all of these wacky animal creatures, was further intrigued by the Japanese encyclopedia of all released Game Boy games I bought that had sections on toys and other merchandise from the series, and a multi-page preview of what I would understand later was "Pocket Monsters 2", the scrapped beta version of Pokemon Gold/Silver. I spent a good portion of the rest of that trip bored in the SF suburbs, but intrigued enough by my purchases from Japan Center to teach myself rudimentary katakana to get more of an idea what all of this stuff was about.

Back at home, before Pokémon really took off, I spotted a used copy of Pokémon Blue from FuncoLand and recognized it as an RPG and the English version of the game from the stickers and game preview that looked so neat.

I thought it reminded me visually a bit of Earthbound in some tenuous way, and it felt like kind of a rudimentary RPG for me, having been into the Final Fantasy series since 1992 and in the thick of FFVII/VIII madness at the time, but I thought that the collecting and rock-paper-scissors mechanics were neat and I found the character design pretty charming. I watched an episode or two of the anime when the English language version started out of morbid curiosity. I wound up beating the game, playing with my friend who owned Pokémon Red, and hacking the game with my GameShark to check out Mew and all of the Missingno stuff.

Then the anime started really taking off with young kids, and being 13, 14, I started feeling too old to be interested in the series, and wouldn't you know it, I missed Gold/Silver, which I guess a lot of people regard as possibly the best games in the series?

I hadn't played any of them for ages, but my girlfriend recently bought me a 2DS with Pokémon X pre-installed, so I've kind of been having fun trying to catch up and check out everything I've been missing since. I'm enjoying naming my Pokémon terrible puns, but I've been kind of distracted by the other 3DS games available.

I will totally buy Pokémon Yellow when it comes out on Virtual Console.

 

[whiterabbit]

I had Blue and Red when I was young, then got Pearl when I was a young adult. I enjoyed them and I remember playing late at night.

In 2014 my dad bought me both X and Y, so I played through and traded with myself to have all the starter Pokemon. I didn't play it at all after I beat the main game, but I do want to play through Y eventually and get the legendary Yveltal.

 

[Mista Koo]

I am a super casual Pokemon fan. Only skipped the 5th generation aside from the remakes, which I should fix soon.
Pokemon X is the only one I beat, I started playing it at launch but only decided to beat it a few months ago.

 

[Sparrowhawk]

Love the first three gens, but that's about it. I just can't get into the others for some reason.

 

[FTF]

Never played one in my life.

Me neither...but you know what, I think I want to.

So Pokemon fans, what game should I play? I have a Wii and 3DS XL...what's my best option, best one for beginners, etc? I'll subscribe to this thread to remember in a couple of days, but thanks in advance for all suggestions.

 

[thoseAREmySHOES]

Let's see...

- Red/Blue. I was 8 when the games came out, and they were immediately pretty popular at my elementary school. Except I had no desire to play them at first, but I think all the buzz wore me down and I eventually used some saved up Christmas and birthday money to buy a GameBoy Pocket and both Red and Blue in the summer of 1999. I was immediately hooked, moreso to Red. I'm certain I was pretty terrible at the games, looking back, as I distinctly remember having my Lv 100 Charizard learn Swords Dance because it sounded cool. But, I quickly filled the Pokedex with all 150 available Pokemon. I convinced my dad to take me to Toys R Us on black friday 1999 for their Mew giveaway. My scratch card didn't win, but on my way out of the store, I was interviewed by a reporter for the local paper who must have been doing a story on black friday shopping. I said something about being upset about not winning, and for some reason my comment actually made it into the reporter's article. Fast forward a short time, and my parents tell me that I received a letter in the mail from a return address they didn't recognize. They opened it, and it turns out someone that had a winning Mew ticket had seen my comment in the paper, and sent me their ticket in the mail! So, I was able to get a legitimate Mew and was the only one at school that had the Pokedex filled to 151.

- Yellow. I got Yellow for Christmas 1999, but didn't play it all too much, as I was too attached to my Pokemon Red save file.

- Silver. I read every Nintendo Power article that I could, multiple times, prior to the release of Gold/Silver. 10 year old me could not have been more hyped for a game release. It came out fall of 2000, but I didn't have any money as a kid, so I had to wait until Christmas of 2000. I specifically asked for Silver and my best friend asked for Gold - and we played them non-stop. I remember getting my game clock to 999:59, but one day, close to the release of Ruby/Sapphire, I booted up the game and my save was gone. I was crushed, and tried to start a new game, but the game simply wouldn't save. The save battery on the cart had malfunctioned.

- Ruby/Sapphire. I was 12 when these came out, and the Pokemon craze had definitely fizzled out at my school. With the loss of my Silver file, I kind of gave up on Pokemon and wasn't all that excited for the release. But, at some point I got Ruby as a gift and ended up playing it quite a bit. I kind of hid the fact that I was still playing Pokemon because it was well past the "in" phase and I didn't want to be made fun of. I actually ended up selling my copy of Ruby prior to the launch of FireRed/LeafGreen because of this.

- FireRed. I realized selling Ruby was a mistake and was excited to play an upgraded version of Red which I enjoyed so much. I played it a ton, but again, pretty much kept it a secret since I had just entered high school and was overly self-conscious of the fact that I was still enjoying the games.

- Emerald. I made sure to get Emerald since I had gotten rid of my copy of Ruby way too early, but I don't have much else to comment on it.

- Diamond. The idea of online trading and battling was too awesome for 17 year old me to pass up.I played Diamond a bunch, but I really was turned off by the fact that you could only migrate 6 Pokemon a day from the GBA games. Also, this is the gen where I decided to start caring about EVs, IVs, etc. I definitely regret getting into the advanced stuff, as I started to care less about having fun and more about getting near-perfect Pokemon. I played up until I left for college in fall of 2008 - again, being overly self-conscious, I decided that I was done with Pokemon, sold my copy of Diamond, and left the DS at home when I left for school.

- SoulSilver. I got sucked back into the pre-release hype again, getting nostalgic about losing my original Silver file and having a chance to revisit the game. At this point, I had made it through college basically covering up my love of the series. SoulSilver just happened to launch at the beginning of my spring break, so I bought it, raced through the entire game on my week off, and really never returned to it. I left it at my parents' house at the end of spring break and ended up selling it after graduating college.

- I convinced myself to buy Pokemon Black to play while away at school, despite previously not wanting to admit I liked the series. I went to a local game shop on launch day, but they had sold out. For some reason, upon not being able to buy the game right at that moment, I decided to skip the games entirely. I also skipped Black and White 2

- X. By 2013, I had graduated school, had a decent paying job, and had moved out on my own. I had quickly discovered how easy it is to build a gaming backlog and figured I'd pick up Pokemon X at launch since I had the cash. I ended up playing for only a few hours before starting to read up on EV/IVs again and realizing that I didn't want to dive back in to all that again and put the game down. I skipped OR/AS due to not playing X very much.

So that's my history with the series. Pretty sad how much I let what was "cool" at school dictate the way I enjoy the games, as well as not being able to look past the "advanced" aspects of the game to just enjoy them at a more basic level. I suppose I can't complain too much, as I've still put well north of 2000 hours into the mainline entries.

 

[SolarMystic]

Started with red on my Gameboy pocket as a child. I guess about 20 years ago I imagine. Been playing every mainline generation since.

I couldn't even try to rank them, but some standout favorites would have to be Red, Crystal, Ruby and X. Gen 4 and 5 are great too, as are the remakes.

 

[Bjoern the Smexy]

My Pokémon timeline:

Pokémon Blue/Red - The first game I bought without my parents consent. They only found out when my brother wanted Pokémon Red because I had the Blue version.
My second favorite Generation after Gen 2. I will always be a member of Team Water Starter. Water Pokémon are the best starter ever. Shut up, you know it's true.
It's the only generation I had a complete Pokédex in. All 151 Pokémon. And I actually got my Mew legitimately too.

Pokémon Yellow - When it came out I never bothered with it, aside from playing it once on an emulator. Ten years later I bought it to complete my collection of Gen1 Pokémon games. Still haven't played it, though.

Pokémon Gold/Silver - Got Pokémon Gold gifted from a friend back then. It was the first (and so far only) English Pokémon game I owned. Which made it a bit harder with the names but whatever.
I actually played quite a bit of Pokémon Gold before on an emulator with a terrible terrible translation patch but never went back to that once I got the game for real. It's my most played Pokémon game ever. I think I have something like 190 hours on it. Don't have a complete Pokédex though. I don't think I have even 200 different Pokémon.
Best moment of course was discovering Kanto all over again, which more or less made Gen1 obsolete for me. Best generation for sure.

Pokémon Crystal - Never played it. Never had it.

Pokémon Ruby/Sapphire - Got the Sapphire version. But here is when it starts going downhill for me. I went waaaay late into this generation, basically only buying the game when a friend of mine said he was making a Pokémon game with RPG Maker 2000 (and he did come very far even, recreating the complete battle system and everything, then real life came up and he never got back to it).
Obviously the soundtrack is awesome. Trumpets rule. That's pretty much the only thing this generation has going for it in my opinion, though.
I knew beforehand that the game only has Hoenn in it. I was pretty upset with that fact considering we got both Johto and Kanto in Gen 2, which was on a freaking Game Boy where the games were 2 MB max and this here is on a GBA where games can be up to 32 MB or something. It just made the game instantly less interesting for me.
I only ever got 4 badges and never played it again. I should though.

Pokémon Emerald - As with Crystal I never got this and never played it.

Pokémon FireRed/LeafGreen - Sadly I skipped that, mostly due to me being dissapointed with Ruby/Sapphire. I am planning on getting FireRed some time in the future though.

Pokémon Diamond/Pearl - Bought Diamond on release (got Pearl later when I found it on top of a trash can in the middle of the night. Finders keepers, I guess). Having gotten over the fact that no Pokémon game in the future will have more than one region anymore (unless they remade Gold/Silver) I happily went into the game and got relatively far (6 badges in). I had fun playing it with my then-girlfriend. We were pretty big into Pokémon. I never finished it, she did.
I have to say that I don't remember a single thing from this generation. Not the soundtrack, not the towns, not the Pokémon, just nothing.

Pokémon Platinum - And once again, I skipped that.

Pokémon HeartGold/SoulSilver - AWWWWWWW YIIIIIISSSSSS HERE WE GO!!! Pokémon Gen 2, as previously stated, is my favorite generation of them all. And I was hyped beyond anything when news broke that it was being remade. My then-girlfriend pre-ordered both games and gave me the SoulSilver version for my birthday. I must have played through that game three times or something in the span of just a few months, that's how much I loved this game. As with the original I never got a full Pokédex though, which was harder anyway as there are way more Pokémon now, so I didn't even bother. BTW if you're not on Team Feraligatr then you are worth nothing to me.

Pokémon Black/White/Black 2/White 2 - Here's the first generation I skipped completely. I wasn't interested in it. While the cover Pokémon looked cool the rest of the game...didn't.

Pokémon X/Y - The first new Pokémon game I was really hyped for since Gold/Silver. I know that I set my alarm clock to 12am so I can buy it on the eShop and let the download go over night. Played it first day in the morning and was actually amazed. Sadly I didn't play through it. I stopped some time after the 2nd or 3rd badge and didn't touch it again. I liked it, though.

Pokémon Alpha Sapphire/Omega Ruby - Since I wasn't that big of a fan of Gen 3 (aside from the soundtrack of course) I skipped these remakes. I don't know if I'll get them some time in the future (probably will because of my collection) but for now...nah.


As for my rating of the main series (not counting remakes and "inbetweeners") it goes like this:

Gold/Silver > Red/Blue > X/Y > Ruby/Sapphire > Diamond/Pearl > Black/White

Or in generation numbers:

2 > 1 > 6 > 3 > 4 > 5

 

[AppleSeason]

I had to fight to get a copy of red for christmas, Played like crazy on my original gameboy to the point of abhorring it. I played the partly fantranslated roms of silver and gold while waiting for the games, but by the time they came out and had a GBC I had lost all interest.


In 2011 I played the original Crystal as it was one of those things that had been in my backlog forever, and that's the end of it. I have tried a few modern ones, but thing are too complex and weird now.

 

[Owari]

Started with Red. Have gotten at least one game from each following generation. Red/Blue/Gold/Silver/FR/LG/HG/SS are objectively the best games in the series. The rest just feel... Diluted. Not bad games, but very by the numbers and quite "meh".. ORAS being the worst of the series by far.

Hopefully Z will turn things around for Pokemon otherwise TPC will face the Yokaipocalypse. At least those games have a little soul.

 

[Perih Xoph]

Let's see. I got Red, Blue and then Yellow when it came out.

Gold, Silver then Crystal.

Ruby, Sapphire, then Emerald.

Diamond, Pearl, than Platinum.

Black

White 2.

And X.

 

[GamerJM]

I've bought every single one (every individual version, not just one version per gen), almost since day 1, and poured over 1k hours collectively into the franchise.

 

[Evilisk]

Played FireRed on a family friend's GBA

Played my brother's copy of Diamond on DS (and completed that). I played a bit of Pearl but I never bothered to finish it

I did play the first two Mystery Dungeon games in between FireRed and Diamond, had a Cubone as my playable character for those.

Haven't bothered with the series since. Nothing against the series itself but now that I have to get my own games, I've just stopped with Nintendo stuff. They're too expensive here and they never drop in price.

 

[JoeM86]

I'm somewhat curious as to what puts XY so high on your list? Just as an opinion mind.

Like Azuran said, I'm a competitive player and XY brought so much to the fold and is such a joy to both play and watch, unlike past gens which just isn't watchable for some reason.

Plus the setting of Kalos is great, the Pokémon variety is great, the story is touching. It's just a great game and I'm really looking forward to the next Kalos game, whatever it is.

 

[Astery]

Played Green,
watched the anime, then played Red and Yellow.
hooked into the IP and played the hell out of Silver and Gold.
Then I sorta lose interest in it.

Boredom and interested to see how far the games has came I played a bit of Black and White but quickly switched to Black 2 since its released.

Lost my interest again as other games released, I guess I just have no idea on the new pokemons killed my interest in it, and I'm too old to be bothered to find out.

 

[OnADock]

Started playing kind if late when I was 11 eith Saphhire. I loved that game though and bought every iteration at release since then. Excpet for Platinum for some reason, which is a shame since its the beat Shinoh game. I've played all the games since then though. Even first and second gen just to see how they compare.

My rankings:
1.Heartgold & SoulSilver- easily the best in the series. These games just had so munch content. 16 badges, a battle frontier and a ton of legendaries to catch. I put about 400 hours into my Heartgold version. There was so much to do and I loved every second of it. Accept for the shiny leaves, that felt kind of silly.

2.Platinum- Sinnoh was always my favorite region. Large, plenty of different envioments and many of my favorite pokemon were introduced here. But Diamond and Pearl has serious problems, I just couldn't play them a second time. Platinum fixed most of those problems. Faster battles, better pokemom variety in the main game, some added content. It was a fun game and I just wish I had bought it at release so I could have sprnt more time with it.

3.Black and White 2- I already enjoyed the first one, but here the fixed the issue of only having new pokemon available. In addition, the new towns and few changed up spots made playing through Unova a second time not feel like just a retread of the first gen 5 games, but instead like a proper sequel. The PTW was also a nice addtion, even if I would have preffered a battle frontier.

4. Emerald- Although kind of short as far as the main story goes. The reworking of the story made it feel far more complete than Ruby or Sapphire with the expanded roles of the villain teams. Now they both actually play a role in the game! Why did gamefreak meed to make on of the villain teams completly incompetent in the first versions? At least have them do something. Emerald shines with the battle frontier. Additionally, the Emerald Battle Frontier is my favorite one. With 7 different facilities, it takes time and skill to actually get all the gold badges.

5. Diamond and Pearl- Technically unimpressive and painfully slow paced battles have aged these versions terribly. The DS ran an enhanced version of super mario 64 at launch but Game Freak had to delay these games for a year because of technical issues And still make everything run at a snailpace? These games highlight Gamefreaks poor preformance as a developer technically, but Sinnoh shines in its design. As i stated above, Sinnoh is a large region with a varied number of enviroments. And several cities with a fair amount to do in them. The less linear construction of the routes along with the post game island to the north all helped me to love this region more than any other. If only there was more than one fire pokemon to carry through it. Seriously, the only fore type you can get before the eliete 4 is a Rapidash.

6. Black amd White- While objectivly a better game than Diamond and Pearl, it just never stuck with me. While playing through a region with only new pokemon was fun the first time. Generation 5 has probably the most boring line up of pokemon out of any generation. There are definatly some good ones, like Chandelure. I even likes the icecream cones. But there are some ugly ones. Gurrdurr? That vieny monster scares me to this day. The linear region also felt boring to play through. Seasons were really cool though and I was sad to see them go. But thats the least of Generation 6's issues.

7. Ruby and Sapphire- good games, but there honstly is too much water, esspesially if you play Sapphire. Spout your 7.8 memes all you want, but a whole 1/3 of the game in the ocean on top of one of the villian teams specializing in Water types makes a game with rock paper scissors mechanics a bit out of balance. In addition the game is kind of on the short side with little to do afterwards. Battle tower is fun, but i beat it rather quickly and moved on. Contests did nothing for me. Felt like a waste of time. Even after i beat all 5 master ranks with mudkips and got all those mudkip paintings in the museum.

8. X&Y- Average games, poor for the series. They added so much but in the end felt incohesive and purposly dumbed down. Thhe new experiamce share is fantastic. Griding to level up all your party members is honestly an outdated mechanic in any jrpg. But it feels like the game wasn't balanced for it at all. In fact this is probanly the second easiest game in the series. Also, all the routes and caves are clearly made to be simpler than in previous games in Gamfreaks feeble attempt to catch the growing moble audience. The games also started out feeling packed with content, the space between the first few gyms was huge. Then the second half flys by before ending eith an underpowered eliete 4. The Battle mansion is basically the same as the Battle Tower or subway, so no complaint there, but between that and the looker quests, there is very little content. A huge step down from prior games. In fact probably the least since Ruby and Sapphire a decade prior. Speaking of which...

9. Omega Ruby and Alpha Sapphire- These games are just subpar all around. Bassically the same as the originals, but easier. You're handed a legendary pokemon half way though the main story for fuck sake; does game freak think the only way to compete with Yoki Watch is to make the easiest game possible. Besides the Delta episode there is little new content post game as well and the delta episode is nothing to great either. It relies heavily on story witch the pokemon series is rightfully not known for. And why is the battle maison here again? Couldn't even reskin that into the Battle Tower? Really? The game honestly feels rushed. Between the lack of content, the vattle maison reappearing again and several glitxhes ive noticed inclusing trainers seeing me before they begin to turn to look at me, I was really let down. They seriously couldnt take the battle frontier or any Emerald improvments and add them here? Some people say the game was meant to be a strict remake, but honestly, it just leaves us with a low quality, content starved game.

10. Fire Red and Leaf Green- my least favorite games in the series. Although I will admit that they are objectivly better than ORAS, I just hate kanto, its boring and eveything looks the same. Also purposly stripping out friendship and time based evolutions was a dumb move. The only people who would enjoy this are stricken with nostoliga.

The first and second generations i left out because i feel thier remakes are better in every way from the originals.

As far as ranking generations goes, i'd say.
4>5>3>2>1>6

I put 1 above 6 because at least the series was brand new and actually pretty impressive considering the system it was on.

 

[MikeBreezy92]

Everything done in BW1 was done better in BW2. I don't like most of Gen 5's mons. I despise the region. The plot was too ambitious and trips up in the first act. None of music besides a few here and there sticks out. Railroading to the MAX. I just did not have fun with those games.

 

[Kamina]

I'm somewhat curious as to what puts XY so high on your list? Just as an opinion mind.

I'm not the one who posted before, but as X/Y is also one of my top 3 i thought i could answer in some way.

For me X/Y just marks the first Pokemon game of a really new generation. While the other gens had arguably small jumps in graphics and gameplay (the largest jump having beeing HG/SS to B/W/B2/W2) the jump to 3Ds was just so good. Everything felt so neat amd new. I was reminded in the first time i played Red/Blue and immediately enjoyed the it. I especially liked the trainer customizations because it gave the game even more RPG aspects.
That doesnt mean the game didn't have downsides. I didn't like the constant interruptions by the children because i prefer exploring alone. Also the postgame was underwhelming. OR/AS did that right though.
Overall i just got this refreshing feeling when i played X/Y the first time. I own both btw, which i usually never do.

 

[MikeBreezy92]

I'm not the one who posted before, but as X/Y is also one of my top 3 i thought i could answer in some way.

For me X/Y just marks the first Pokemon game of a really new generation. While the other gens had arguably small jumps in graphics and gameplay (the largest jump having beeing HG/SS to B/W/B2/W2) the jump to 3Ds was just so good. Everything felt so neat amd new. I was reminded in the first time i played Red/Blue and immediately enjoyed the it. I especially liked the trainer customizations because it gave the game even more RPG aspects.
That doesnt mean the game didn't have downsides. I didn't like the constant interruptions by the children because i prefer exploring alone. Also the postgame was underwhelming. OR/AS did that right though.
Overall i just got this refreshing feeling when i played X/Y the first time. I own both btw, which i usually never do.

This is the general sin of Gen's 4-6 to me. Can't go to a new city without some bullshit from the cast.

 

[The Sum of Zero]

I started with Yellow. I've lost count of how many times I beat it. It was that great to young me.

Silver was the very first video game I got on release day, I was hyped. Eventually got Gold as well, then Crystal.

Not sure why, but my interest in Pokémon started to wane after Crystal

Spoiler

Actually I think I can blame Yu-Gi-Oh for it

. My mother got me Sapphire but I only got as far as Kyogre before quitting.

Later on when Soul Silver came out I got it. Only got past the first gym and quit. At the time I thought I just couldn't enjoy Pokémon games anymore.

Fast forward to X and Y. A bunch of my friends were actually getting them, the first time in years they'd all played Pokémon. So I jumped in too with Y. Yveltal? Mega Mewtwo Y? I was ready to sign up again and I'm so glad I did. I rediscovered my love for the games.

I then finally corrected my younger mistake in not finishing Sapphire by getting and finishing Alpha Sapphire.

And here I am, hyped by all this 20th anniversary goodness, and actually playing the card game with my roommate, the first time I'd messed with these cards since elementary school.